DEMOCRACY can be messy. It can be slow to respond, frustrating to watch and vulnerable to those who would exploit its freedoms. Yet it works. It remains alive in much of the world, including Guyana, and American voters have offered a forceful reminder of its capacity for self-correction.
Democracy depends not only on the right to vote, but also on the ability to make a persuasive case for what deserves defending. A longtime staff writer for The New Yorker and one of my favourite authors, Adam Gopnik’s Angels and Ages uses the shared birthday of Abraham Lincoln and Charles Darwin – February 12, 1809 – to explore the place of language and persuasion in the making of liberal society.
Most people remember the words of Lincoln during his Gettysburg Address on November 19, 1863: “…and that government of the people, by the people, for the people, shall not perish from the earth.” The reason we remember these words is that they reflect deep truths that continue to resonate in our age.
Similarly, the quote that is attributed to Lincoln: “You can fool all the people some of the time, and some of the people all the time, but you cannot fool all the people all the time” reflects a faith in the public’s capacity to see through deception.
It is a useful standard to apply to Guyana.
The questions I would put to the Mohameds are straightforward: What precisely would you change about the institutions of our democracy? Which laws, safeguards and constitutional amendments would you propose? How would those changes make government more accountable to the people? And how would citizens benefit?
These are questions any political party or movement should welcome. They invite an explanation, not another street protest as WIIN’s leader becomes familiar with the inside of our prisons and courtrooms.
Those questions also apply to the PPP/C. Scrutiny requires looking beyond political personalities to the work of government. The PPP/C is not President Irfaan Ali’s personal property, and its obligation is to advance a national project in which Guyanese, across ethnic, religious and cultural lines, can exercise their rights and improve their lives.
Take the recent launch of the Revised Laws of Guyana, updated through December 2022, alongside the Law Reports covering 2008–2021, championed by Attorney General Anil Nandlall; the exercise brought together an updated collection of legislation and significant judicial decisions.
Why should anyone outside the legal profession care?
Because citizens cannot effectively assert rights they cannot identify. Lawyers need to establish what the law provides; courts need access to relevant decisions; and people challenging an injustice need a legal foundation on which to stand. Updating the country’s legal resources is not glamorous political work. It is necessary work.
The current constitutional reform process, established under legislation adopted in 2022, with a commission constituted in 2024 and the consultation process earlier this year, aims to strengthen current and future rights, duties and obligations of the Guyanese people. It is an opportunity to improve not merely the machinery of government, but the protections under which we live.
Improving democracy means more than simply improving the arrangements through which politicians exercise power. It means strengthening the citizen’s ability to question that power, seek redress against injustice and live with dignity and freedom. Constitutional reform cannot, by itself, deliver a better quality of life. But it can help secure the rights, accountability and stability on which that better life depends.
The PPP/C should be judged both by its undertaking of this work and, yes, by what the process will ultimately deliver. The measure of success will not be how many provisions are rewritten, but whether Guyanese emerge with a stronger voice, more secure freedoms and more effective protection under the law.
That brings me back to Gopnik. Democratic persuasion is not simply the ability to command attention even if you shout and holler yourself hoarse. It is the willingness to explain, to answer objections and to submit an argument to public judgement.
As Attorney General Nandlall said this last week, the Mohameds are entitled to challenge the government, but they are not allowed to get a free pass just because they are rich and believe themselves to be entitled. To that extent, Guyanese are equally entitled to ask what the Mohameds would replace the government with.
Judge the PPP/C by its programmes, its record and even the work still outstanding. But also judge the Mohameds by the same demanding standard – not by the attention they covet, but by the alternatives they can articulate and reasonably defend.
The eloquence of Lincoln and Darwin is evidence that the loudest claims to defend democracy are not necessarily the strongest case.
Democracy is not a spectator sport. Citizens must question the government, test its challengers and refuse to let either substitute a show for an answer.
DISCLAIMER: The views and opinions expressed in this column are solely those of the author and do not necessarily reflect the official policy or position of the Guyana National Newspapers Limited.








