WIN must serve its voters, not the Mohamed family

FOR a week, protests and livestreams have made one demand — release Azruddin Mohamed. Rather than account for his conduct, the Mohamed family appears determined to make enough noise to force the authorities to give way.

Azruddin is entitled to defend himself, his family to support him, and his supporters to protest peacefully. They exercised all three rights this week, yet members of his family shouted themselves hoarse, crying dictatorship at the democratically elected PPP/C government.

Their grievance appears to be that political office and a prominent surname have failed to secure the treatment they expect.

The issue is accountability. The Mohameds cannot demand it from everybody except themselves.

Take the dispute over prison visits. Hana Mohamed claimed that officials were defying a court directive, but access for lawyers to prepare legal documents is not the same as unrestricted daily access for relatives. The family has not produced an order establishing the right it claims. Waving an envelope at a prison officer during an angry broadcast does not settle the matter.

Produce the order. If it grants the access claimed, prison officials will comply. Otherwise, stop accusing them of defying a judge.

The family has also made serious allegations about Azruddin’s treatment in prison. The Prison Service has disputed their account. Those claims require evidence and proper scrutiny, not acceptance because Hana repeats them loudly.

A prisoner retains his rights. A famous prisoner does not acquire extra ones.

Then there is the CCTV footage.

Mohamed is accused of paying GY$800,000 to police constable Ryan Greene to obtain recordings from the police surveillance system. The charges connected to that alleged transaction led to his remand.

His lawyers could have pursued disclosure through the courts. Instead, Mohamed said a source had told him the footage would be deleted. That claim itself required evidence; it was not a licence to obtain protected material by whatever means he chose.

Prosecutors have since begun disclosing statements, photographs and video material in the weapons case arising from the October 12 incident near the home of Special Branch head, Senior Superintendent Prem Narine.

What the footage shows must be examined. How it was obtained is a separate question. Evidence challenging a police account does not automatically excuse an offence committed to obtain it.

Guyanese can understand that distinction without the Mohameds supplying a slogan.

What is astonishing is how quickly Azruddin’s legal problems become political emergencies. His supporters are asked to treat the fact that he faces proceedings as proof that those proceedings are persecution.

Consider the affidavit filed through his mother.

Attorney General Anil Nandlall challenged it for containing hearsay, legal opinions and claims outside her personal knowledge. The court permitted an additional affidavit from Azruddin.

Nandlall’s objections were arguments for the court to determine, not a judgment he could hand down himself. Disagreement with those objections is no evidence that he controls the judge.

These are legal disputes. Azruddin’s attorneys are paid to handle them. If their documents cannot withstand scrutiny, the responsibility does not belong to the politician who points out the defects.

No amount of Facebook outrage from Hana or Hadi can repair a defective affidavit.

Meanwhile, what happens to the people caught up in this widening drama?

A young policeman is on remand. Employees have been arrested in connection with the footage investigation. A livestreamer associated with the protests has been arrested while police investigate alleged threats. Their guilt remains to be determined, but their troubles will not disappear when the Mohameds’ live broadcast ends.

WIIN should remember that loyalty runs both ways. Its supporters are citizens with futures, not disposable extras in Mohamed’s political roadshow.

I don’t imagine that Guyanese who voted for WIIN did so to elect an opposition to provide a running commentary on its leader’s legal difficulties. They need representatives doing the parliamentary work that can improve their lives.

That means examining government spending and following public problems beyond the next opportunity to shout outside a courthouse.

Where was that work in last week’s uproar?

Nobody outside the Mohamed family can honestly claim to know its private strategy. The public can, however, judge a campaign whose demands keep returning to one man’s aspirations.

Azruddin’s legal interests are not automatically the interests of everyone who voted for WIIN. His party owes those voters representation, even when its leader is occupied with defending himself.

WIIN’s MPs must decide whether they are prepared to serve their constituents or the Mohamed family’s defence campaign.

Those who voted for the party deserve an answer in Parliament, not another outrageous livestream.

DISCLAIMER: The views and opinions expressed in this column are solely those of the author and do not necessarily reflect the official policy or position of the Guyana National Newspapers Limited.

 

SHARE THIS ARTICLE :
Facebook
Twitter
WhatsApp
All our printed editions are available online
emblem3
Subscribe to the Guyana Chronicle.
Sign up to receive news and updates.
We respect your privacy.