When the Hand That Hurts Becomes the Hand We Reach For

A KING was seated in his court, holding a chicken in his hands. He began plucking its feathers, one at a time. The chicken cried out, twisted, and struggled, desperately trying to escape, but the king continued until he removed every feather. When he was finished, he dropped the poor creature onto the floor. There it lay, naked, trembling and visibly distressed. After a while, the king took a few kernels of corn from his pocket and tossed them on the floor to the chicken. The chicken immediately ate the corn. The king repeated this until the naked bird had followed him across the entire room. Satisfied, the arrogant man turned to his court and said, ‘This is how you control people.’

This psychological phenomenon is far more common in human relationships than many people realise. It is known as traumatic bonding, and it raises some difficult questions about the nature of attachment, emotional dependency and why people sometimes find themselves longing for affection from the very individuals who have caused them the greatest distress.

We generally assume that when someone hurts us repeatedly, our instinct should be to distance ourselves from that person. In healthy circumstances, that may well be the case. However, human attachment is more complicated, particularly when affection and mistreatment are woven into the same relationship.

Psychologists Donald Dutton and Susan Painter examined this phenomenon in their 1993 study, Emotional Attachments in Abusive Relationships: A Test of Traumatic Bonding Theory, published in the journal Violence and Victims. Their research involved 75 women who had recently left abusive relationships. The researchers identified two important factors associated with the development of powerful emotional attachments to abusive partners: an imbalance of power and intermittent periods of mistreatment.

Their findings were particularly interesting because they challenged the assumption that repeated mistreatment would necessarily weaken emotional attachment. In some circumstances, the opposite appeared to happen. The unpredictable alternation between abusive behaviour and positive treatment could contribute to an attachment that persisted even after the relationship had ended.

This is where intermittent reinforcement becomes relevant. The concept originates in behavioural psychology and describes a pattern in which rewards are delivered inconsistently rather than every time a particular behaviour occurs. When applied to abusive relationships, it helps explain how occasional affection, apologies, reassurance or tenderness can become enormously significant against a background of repeated distress.

Consider someone who spends days being criticised, ignored, humiliated or emotionally rejected, only to receive an unexpected expression of affection from the same person. This brief moment of warmth may feel disproportionately rewarding. The individual remembers the better moments and begins hoping the person they fell in love with will return.

When the affection disappears again, the waiting begins. An apology brings relief, a loving message restores hope, and a few pleasant days may be enough to convince someone that circumstances are finally changing. Unfortunately, the pattern repeats.

Over time, the individual may become increasingly preoccupied with restoring the good moments rather than examining the relationship as a whole. They begin measuring happiness by the absence of conflict, rather than by the presence of genuine emotional security.

A considerable difference exists between being loved and being relieved of the pain someone else has caused.

Another important aspect of traumatic bonding is the way it can affect a person’s perception of themselves. Constant criticism, unpredictable affection and emotional manipulation can gradually undermine self-confidence. Someone who once knew their worth may begin questioning their judgement, apologising for things they did not do and accepting treatment they would previously have considered unacceptable.

The individual may even find themselves defending the person responsible. Friends and relatives may struggle to understand why someone keeps returning to a relationship that appears so damaging from the outside. Yet what observers see as an obvious reason to leave may be experienced by the person involved as a complicated mixture of attachment, fear, hope, grief and dependency.

This does not mean that everyone who remains in an abusive relationship has developed a trauma bond, nor does it mean that every difficult relationship should be labelled as traumatic bonding. The term describes a particular pattern of attachment associated with abuse, unequal power and intermittent positive treatment. It should not become another convenient label for every relationship that ends badly.

Still, the psychological implications deserve understanding, particularly because people are often quick to judge those who struggle to leave. The most revealing part of the king’s behaviour is not simply that he removed the chicken’s feathers. It is that he had complete control over a creature that depended on its surroundings for survival. The chicken had no way to negotiate its circumstances, challenge its treatment, or demand an explanation.

In human relationships, however, the situation can become even more complicated because emotional attachment introduces memories, expectations and the hope that things will return to how they once were. Sometimes, people hold on to the treatment they are receiving. They are holding on to the person they remember, or the person they keep hoping will reappear.

Breaking that attachment isn’t always an immediate decision. It can involve grieving the relationship, confronting uncomfortable truths, rebuilding self-esteem and learning to recognise the difference between affection and emotional manipulation. Most importantly, it requires understanding that leaving does not mean the feelings were never genuine.

Remember, peace isn’t found in becoming better at enduring behaviour that hurts us; it isn’t found in waiting indefinitely for someone to return to the version of themselves we once loved. The hardest part of healing is accepting that the hand we keep reaching for is the very hand we need to withdraw from. Enjoy the poem below.

 

The Hand That Hurts

 

The hand that wounds may offer care,

And leave us hoping it will spare;

We cling to moments warm and kind,

While leaving all the hurt behind.

 

A little love, a little grace, Can make us long to see its face;

We wait for tenderness to stay,

And hope the hurt will fade away.

 

But love should never come in turns,

Where every touch conceals what burns;

Nor should the heart be made to plead,

For simple things it ought to need.

 

We learn to doubt the things we know,

And blame ourselves for every blow;

Until the truth we once could see,

Becomes a stranger to the me.

 

Yet healing starts when we discern,

That pain is not the price to earn;

And no apology can mend,

A wound that has no proper end.

 

The heart may grieve, the soul may ache,

And time may test the steps we take;

But leaving what destroys our peace,

Can be the place where we find release.

 

For love should never leave us torn,

Or make us wish we weren’t born;

The hand that loves should help us rise,

Not keep us captive with disguise.

 

Romella Dasratt

 

 

 

SHARE THIS ARTICLE :
Facebook
Twitter
WhatsApp
All our printed editions are available online
emblem3
Subscribe to the Guyana Chronicle.
Sign up to receive news and updates.
We respect your privacy.