I HAVE been thinking about expectations and the rather peculiar things we humans do when we become emotionally invested in one another. We enter relationships with hopes, assumptions and a collection of unspoken agreements about how we believe we should be treated. Then reality hits unexpectedly and reminds us that what we expect and what another person is prepared to offer can be two entirely different things.
Plenty of advice exists about managing expectations. We are told not to expect too much, not to depend on others for happiness, and, preferably, not to be disappointed when people behave in ways we would never consider toward them. It sounds practical until we begin examining what we are actually being asked to surrender. Are we supposed to abandon our emotional needs because somebody else might find them inconvenient?
Psychologists Edward Deci and Richard Ryan developed Self-Determination Theory, which identifies three fundamental psychological needs: autonomy, competence and relatedness. Relatedness concerns our need for meaningful connection and belonging. In other words, wanting to feel connected to the people who matter to us is not some unfortunate personality defect. It is part of being human.
Of course, this does not mean another person must constantly reassure us, anticipate every emotion, or put our needs above their own. Relationships require individual freedom, boundaries and a reasonable understanding that two people will not always see things alike. However, there is a difference between demanding that someone organise their entire existence around us and expecting them to demonstrate some consideration for our feelings.
Research by psychologist Harry Reis and his colleagues offers another valuable perspective. Their 2020 study, published in Emotion, examined perceived partner responsiveness and emotional expression. Their findings showed that people are more inclined to express their feelings when they perceive their partners as responsive. This matters because emotional vulnerability requires trust. We are generally more willing to reveal the uncomfortable parts of ourselves when we believe the person listening will take them seriously.
Think about that for a moment: when someone repeatedly explains what makes them vulnerable, they are giving another person information that could strengthen the relationship. They are effectively saying, ‘This is something I struggle with, and I need you to understand it.’ Naturally, understanding does not guarantee that another person will always get things right. However, when the same concerns are repeatedly dismissed, the disappointment can extend beyond the original incident. The person may begin questioning whether their feelings were ever given the importance they believed they had.
Relationship psychology also describes an interesting pattern known as demand-withdraw. Researchers C. L. Heavey, Andrew Christensen and colleagues investigated this dynamic in marital conflict. It describes situations in which one partner pushes for discussion or change while the other withdraws from the interaction. Their longitudinal research, published in 1995, examined how this pattern affected relationship satisfaction over time.
It is easy to understand why this dynamic becomes exhausting. One person wants to discuss the problem, while the other wants to escape the discomfort of discussing it. The more one pursues a response, the more the other may retreat. Eventually, the original disagreement becomes only one part of a much larger problem. The inability to communicate becomes another source of hurt.
We should, however, distinguish between someone who occasionally needs time to process a difficult conversation and someone who consistently refuses to engage. Taking a little time to collect one’s thoughts is perfectly reasonable. Leaving another person indefinitely with unanswered questions is an entirely different matter.
This is why the work of family therapist and researcher Pauline Boss deserves particular attention. Boss developed the concept of ambiguous loss, which examines the psychological distress associated with losses that lack clarity or resolution. In a 2022 interview with the American Psychological Association, she explained that what people often want after a loss is not necessarily closure, but certainty about what that loss means.
Although she developed her theory in more specific contexts of unresolved loss, it offers an interesting perspective on relationships that end without meaningful explanation. Sometimes the relationship has effectively ended, but the mind continues searching for answers. What changed? What did I misunderstand? Could something have been done differently? We keep revisiting conversations, examining incidents and mentally preparing for discussions that may never take place. Unfinished emotional business can occupy so much of our attention for a reason. We want our experiences to make sense. We want a beginning, a middle and an ending that we can understand. Unfortunately, other people do not always cooperate with our preferred arrangements.
So this brings us back to expectation. Maybe we need to stop treating every unmet expectation as a personal failure or evidence that we wanted too much. We should also examine whether we sometimes expect others to meet needs we haven’t communicated or cannot reasonably ask them to fulfil. The important distinction is between expecting perfection and expecting participation. Nobody can promise never to disappoint us, but relationships become difficult to sustain when only one person is willing to acknowledge problems, have uncomfortable conversations or make an effort to understand the other.
I also think we should reconsider our obsession with closure. Sometimes an explanation helps, and sometimes an apology makes a considerable difference. But when neither is forthcoming, we cannot allow our lives to remain permanently suspended while waiting for somebody else to complete the conversation.
Maturity means acknowledging our disappointment without making it our permanent residence. We can accept that something mattered, that it hurt, and that we may never fully understand another person’s decisions.
I am certainly not advocating a life without expectations; that would make human relationships a rather uninspiring exercise. I still believe in loyalty, kindness, consideration and the pleasure of knowing that somebody has genuinely thought about us. Let’s pay closer attention to the difference between what people promise, what we hope for and what their behaviour consistently demonstrates. After all, expectations deserve examination, but so does the behaviour that gives rise to them. Enjoy the poem below.
I Asked
I asked my heart why it held on tight,
To conversations lost from sight.
It said that hope can linger long,
When endings never sound a song.
I asked if wanting care was wrong,
Or if my expectations were too strong.
It said that love needs room to grow,
And both must give for both to know.
I asked why silence leaves a scar,
When two once knew each other so far.
It said that words can mend or sever,
But absence cannot answer forever.
I asked if hurt should make me cold,
Or turn my heart to stone and gold.
It said that pain may change your view,
But need not change the good in you.
I asked if closure had a key,
Or if its door would open for me.
It said that some will never explain,
And life cannot be lived in vain.
I asked what lessons I should keep,
When memories disturb my sleep.
It said, let wisdom guide your way,
And do not let the past consume today.
So I shall carry what I have learned,
And leave behind what cannot return.
For hearts may hope and hearts may mend,
Without another’s hand to close the end.
Romella Dasratt








