What Is Information?

BY most scholarly accounts, the concept of information is notoriously difficult to define. Definitions vary so widely from one scientist or theorist to another that the disagreements can appear almost schizophrenic in their inconsistency. The reason for this diversity seems to be that information is often defined by the context in which it is used across different fields of inquiry.
Because there is no single mathematically definitive formulation that decisively invalidates all competing interpretations, a multitude of definitions persists; to ask, therefore, “What is information?” immediately invites a second question: in what context? If the context is textual—and one may argue that there is no context without text—and the field is Library and Information Science, then information may be defined quite differently than it would be in physics, computer science, literary studies or communication theory.
One can hardly disagree with the proposition that information is what information does; that is, its most salient definition lies in its mode of function, its purpose and its reason for being across its many forms of existence: image, idea, allegory, prose, poetry, speech, symbol and code. A poem about mangoes is not about the fescue lawns of the American Southwest. Meaning is directed by intention and context. Few things communicate their function more immediately than a title.
The Order of Things, for example, announces its subject with relative clarity, while The Lighthouse, whether approached literally or metaphorically, still centres upon the image and symbolic significance of the lighthouse itself—metaphor and allegory similarly present information through symbolic comparison and representation. The traditional image of Death—skeletal, hooded, carrying a scythe in one hand and a cresset in the other—is a powerful allegorical embodiment of an idea; even a child may recognise the information conveyed by the symbol.
The argument that information is defined by what it does finds perhaps its clearest realisation in modern computing applications, whose functions constitute their very reason for existence: the flashlight application, the GPS application, the Online Public Access Catalogue (OPAC) application, the heart-rate monitor. In each case, information is inseparable from utility and operation.
The multiplicity of definitions is therefore largely allied with context and meaning. Meaning itself may be allusive, symbolic, abstract, culturally embedded or inaccessible to a particular reader unfamiliar with the assumptions that govern interpretation. The problem, then, is that it is difficult to formulate a single definition for something that potentially concerns everything.
Information relates to culture as much as culture has been described as “everything we do” within society. Information, correspondingly, may be understood as the record—recorded or unrecorded—of everything done within such a society. Living generates information; dying generates information. An epitaph is information, as is a eulogy, a tombstone or a stele.
Luciano Floridi, citing Donald MacKay and Gregory Bateson, notes that information “is a distinction that makes a difference” (MacKay) and “a difference that makes a difference” (Bateson). Such formulations suggest that information emerges not merely from the existence of data, but from meaningful differentiation.
A prudent point of departure in defining information may therefore be to identify what it is not. Such a process resembles a kind of conceptual triage: ruling out inadequate definitions to approach a more useful one. A rudimentary definition might claim that information is fundamentally fact-based, but this is persuasive only within an empirical framework where truth and verification are paramount. This is clearly insufficient in literary or artistic contexts.
Images and ideas—the foundation of poetry and fiction—are rarely concerned with factual representation alone; rather, they often depend upon transformation, disguise and symbolic displacement.
Figurative language deliberately alters the factual nature of the objects it represents. A simple metaphor such as “that man is a mountain” does not claim literal truth; instead, it transfers qualities associated with mountains—strength, size, endurance and immovability—to the man in question. More elaborate metaphors, conceits and kennings operate similarly. The information conveyed by such devices bears little relationship to scientific fact, yet remains profoundly meaningful within literary or poetic truth. To personify the sun and say that it smiles is fantastical and antithetical to empiricism, yet it remains intelligible and evocative as poetic information.
This suggests that information, in its innumerable permutations, permits continual redefinition according to the needs of scientific, artistic or social inquiry. Such flexibility does not imply that all definitions are equally valid, only that validity itself is often determined by disciplinary context.
Information may also be understood as inherently self-referential—that is, as metadata. Yet this definition risks excessive abstraction, possessing something of the “art for art’s sake” quality that neglects the indispensable role of agency and creation. Information does not merely exist independently; it is generated, interpreted and contextualised by minds.
Perhaps information might ultimately be anything said, done, thought, imagined, recorded or inferred—or even nothingness itself. Absence can signify as much as presence. A blank page communicates differently from a written one, but both communicate. Floridi’s example of the blank page illustrates precisely this point: there is no true absence of information, because even silence, emptiness or omission may itself be meaningful. The claim that there is “no information” is already informational.
For the student of literature, information often concerns symbolic representation: the means by which one thing stands in for another. Synecdoche allows a part to represent a whole; acronyms condense complex entities into abbreviated signs. Even the fractured syntax of text messaging constitutes a transformation of informational form. Entire systems of language may themselves become symbolic artefacts, as in Egyptian hieroglyphs or cuneiform inscriptions.
An illuminating illustration of the complexity of informational meaning appears in the Star Trek: The Next Generation episode “Darmok”, featuring Paul Winfield. In the episode, the alien Tamarian language communicates almost entirely through metaphor and cultural reference. Literal translation fails because what is said is not identical to what is meant. Meaning depends upon shared narratives and symbolic associations. The episode demonstrates the profound gap between data and semantic understanding: language is not merely the transmission of facts, but the communication of culturally encoded meaning.
As Floridi remarks in The Philosophy of Information, “information is a conceptual labyrinth”. So too, inevitably, is its definition.
What emerges from these considerations is the recognition of a wide gulf between data and meaning. What is spoken or written is not necessarily identical to what is understood. A semantic conception of information may therefore come closest to capturing its essence, because information almost always involves the shaping, shifting and negotiation of meaning according to purpose and context.
In this sense, information becomes inseparable from human inquiry itself. Thomas Kuhn’s understanding of paradigms and Michel Foucault’s reflections on discourse both support the notion that definitions arise from systems of thought shaped by language, culture and institutional practice. Foucault, particularly, emphasises the power of language to create, define, classify and order reality. Definitions are products of discourse; they do not exist outside it. The multiplicity of definitions for information may therefore reflect not conceptual failure, but rather the inexhaustible flexibility of language itself.

SHARE THIS ARTICLE :
Facebook
Twitter
WhatsApp
All our printed editions are available online
emblem3
Subscribe to the Guyana Chronicle.
Sign up to receive news and updates.
We respect your privacy.