Gangster of Love: The Lost Love Songs of Boysie Singh by Ingrid Persaud

THE Lost Love Songs of Boysie Singh (Faber & Faber, $30.00) takes as its point of departure one of the Caribbean’s most notorious criminals: Boysie Singh, the Trinidadian gangster who was hanged in 1957 for murder and piracy among a catalogue of other crimes. Singh—charismatic, theatrical, and widely feared—was often referred to as “Raja,” Hindi for king, a sobriquet befitting the mythic aura that came to surround him.

A gambler, pimp, club owner, and racketeer, he occupied in Trinidadian folklore something like the place John Gotti would later hold in American popular imagination: a criminal whose notoriety became inseparable from legend. Stories about him have long passed into Caribbean lore. He is reputed to have murdered more than four hundred people. According to popular accounts, Singh would transport migrants by boat from Venezuela to Trinidad, only to rob and murder them mid-journey, throwing their bodies into the sea.

It is this spectral and terrifying figure who stands at the centre of Ingrid Persaud’s dazzling new novel. The book arrives on the heels of her Costa Prize-winning novel, Love After Love, a deeply Caribbean novel distinguished by its warmth, humour, emotional intelligence, and vivid evocation of contemporary Trinidadian life. That earlier work captured a Trinidad that was politically alert, dangerous, tender, and exuberantly alive. The Lost Love Songs of Boysie Singh takes a darker turn. It is a larger, more ambitious novel, populated by a broader cast of characters and animated by a more ominous historical imagination.

Despite the title, this is not Boysie Singh’s story in any straightforward sense. He is less a protagonist than a gravitational force, the dark centre around which the novel’s “love songs” orbit. The phrase itself is deeply ironic, for Boysie is not a man easily loved. Instead, the novel belongs to the women whose lives intersect with his violence, charisma, and appetite. The story unfolds through the voices of four women: Popo, Rosie, Manalala, and Doris. Each woman has a distinct relationship with Boysie, and through their testimonies, the reader gradually assembles a portrait of the man. Boysie himself never truly speaks except through their perceptions of him.

Manalala, the mother of Boysie’s only child, is perhaps the most tragic of the quartet. She endures his beatings and humiliations with a kind of exhausted resignation, clinging to him despite the degradation he inflicts upon her. Popo, by contrast, is Boysie’s lover and accomplice, a former prostitute whose streetwise cunning rivals his own. She understands the brutal logic of survival and navigates Boysie’s dangerous world with hard-earned intelligence. Ultimately, she is a very tragic figure in this novel.

Rosie, however, emerges as the novel’s most compelling figure. The owner of a bar and dry goods store, she survives through wit, instinct, and emotional independence. Rosie refuses the conventions imposed upon women of her era, choosing lovers—both men and women—with unapologetic freedom. In a society crowded with gangsters, hustlers, and desperate strivers, she remains defiantly self-fashioned. Hers is the voice that most fully captures the novel’s mixture of resilience, sensuality, and danger.

Doris, meanwhile, is perhaps the most socially ambitious of the women. A “red woman,” as the novel repeatedly emphasises, she longs to transcend her status as a maid and ascend into respectability and wealth. Her marriage to Boysie appears to promise such elevation, but the rewards prove hollow. Doris is vain, acquisitive, and often delusional about the life she believes she deserves. Compounding her disappointment is the fact that Boysie’s interest in her rapidly cools, leaving the marriage emotionally barren and sexually unconsummated. Yet Doris remains believable because Persaud grants her a deeply human mixture of vanity, longing, insecurity, and calculation.

Through these four women, Boysie emerges as monstrous but strangely elusive. We learn of his compulsive gambling, his womanising, his manipulations, and his acts of terrifying cruelty. One particularly harrowing scene—in which Boysie robs and drowns three men at sea—lingers long after the novel ends. The episode confirms the brutality that the women repeatedly attribute to him and crystallises the terror that underpins his legend.

One of the novel’s most remarkable achievements is its handling of language. Persaud carefully distinguishes the women’s voices through subtle variations in Trinidadian speech patterns and Creole usage. Manalala’s speech carries traces of Hindi vocabulary and cadence; Doris aspires toward Standard English, frequently correcting herself whenever she slips into Creole; Rosie and Popo speak in a raw, vibrant idiom thick with colloquialisms, slang, and rhythmic improvisation.

These linguistic distinctions never feel ornamental. Rather, they reveal class, aspiration, ethnicity, education, and temperament. Persaud demonstrates an extraordinary ear for the nuances of Trinidadian speech, using language not merely to authenticate setting but to deepen characterisation. The women’s voices become unmistakably their own.

Equally impressive is the novel’s recreation of Trinidad in the 1930s, 1940s, and 1950s. Persaud conjures a society shaped by colonial hierarchies, racial tensions, economic precarity, and shifting moral codes. It is a world populated by hustlers, gamblers, migrants, sex workers, shopkeepers, and drifters—all engaged in the difficult business of survival. Yet the novel never reduces this society to sociological portraiture. Instead, Persaud renders it alive with humour, sensuality, gossip, violence, and longing.

What ultimately distinguishes The Lost Love Songs of Boysie Singh is its refusal to romanticise criminality, even as it acknowledges the seductive power of myth. Boysie may dominate the imaginations of those around him, but the novel belongs to the women who endure, resist, desire, survive, and narrate him into being. Their voices transform what might have been a conventional gangster story into something richer: a meditation on power, gender, memory, and survival in the Caribbean imagination.

 

SHARE THIS ARTICLE :
Facebook
Twitter
WhatsApp
All our printed editions are available online
emblem3
Subscribe to the Guyana Chronicle.
Sign up to receive news and updates.
We respect your privacy.