ISHION Hutchinson is a Jamaican poet of rare skill and intellectual depth, a reputation secured by his three acclaimed poetry collections: Far District, The House of Lords and Commons, and School of Instruction, each of which has garnered major awards and nominations.
Born and raised in Jamaica, Hutchinson now teaches literature at Cornell University in New York.
His latest book, Fugitive Tilts, is an expansive collection of essays that ranges across the esoteric and the literary. At nearly four hundred pages, the title evokes the notion of “side pursuits” — works undertaken obliquely or in passing yet animated by larger artistic ambitions.
It recalls Odd Jobs (1979), John Updike’s collection of literary essays; like Updike, Hutchinson proves himself an exacting observer and a deeply attentive reader.
Fugitive Tilts is wide-ranging in both form and subject, bringing together personal reminiscence, literary criticism, travel writing, interviews, reviews and reflective essays. The collection comprises nearly thirty pieces of varying length.
Among the most substantial is Hutchinson’s extended engagement with The Guyana Quartet — the first four novels of Wilson Harris: Palace of the Peacock, The Far Journey of Oudin, The Whole Armour and The Secret Ladder.
In this essay, Hutchinson offers a striking interpretive framework for Harris’s dense, highly metaphoric fiction. He reads the novels through the conceit of a lost Eden: Guyana becomes a symbolic origin from which the characters are estranged and to which they futilely attempt to return.
These figures exist in a perpetual state of flight — pursued or pursuing — and are thus “fugitives” in both literal and metaphysical senses. Their repeated failures, their cycles of death and rebirth, suggest that the Eden they seek can only be apprehended at a remove, beyond conscious grasp.
Hutchinson extends this fugitive quality to the landscape itself, which shifts and eludes stable meaning through Harris’s language and imagery.
The opening essays — “Treasure Island and Me”, “First Reading” and others — are more personal in tone, tracing Hutchinson’s early encounters with literature.
“Treasure Island and Me” is especially affecting, linking Robert Louis Stevenson’s imagined geographies to Hutchinson’s own sense of his island home.
Another piece, “An Exquisite Simulacrum: Remembering Philip Levine”, reflects on the poet Philip Levine, Hutchinson’s teacher at New York University, and stands as a meditation on influence, mentorship and poetic craft.
In the densely argued “Birds of Prey”, Hutchinson turns to Claude McKay’s sonnets, offering a sustained analysis of the word “surrender”. His reading traces its tonal and semantic variations, connecting McKay’s usage to the rhetoric of James Baldwin and the poetry of Kamau Brathwaite.
The essay is intellectually ambitious and often illuminating, demonstrating Hutchinson’s ability to draw unexpected connections across literary traditions. At times, however, its density risks obscuring its central thread, demanding careful attention from the reader.
Another standout essay examines the well-known feud between Derek Walcott and V. S. Naipaul. Hutchinson is less interested in rehearsing their antagonisms than in exploring the deeper affinities in their work.
He approaches the subject obliquely, resisting the temptation to take sides, and instead probes the shared concerns that underlie their writing.
Both authors, he suggests, grapple with the problem of representing the Caribbean without reducing it to spectacle or despair. While Walcott’s vision is often marked by a wary sensitivity to the dangers of aestheticising poverty, Naipaul’s outlook tends towards a more sweeping pessimism, echoing colonial critiques such as those of Anthony Froude.
Yet Hutchinson complicates this binary, arguing that Walcott’s scepticism is not wholly distinct from Naipaul’s, even if it leads to different artistic conclusions.
Across these essays, Hutchinson emerges as a versatile and exacting critic. One senses the deliberation behind his prose — the careful shaping and reshaping of ideas as he works through them.
His approach is marked by a kind of subterranean rigour, an almost “mole-like” excavation of literary texts that reveals their hidden structures and resonances.
The result is a collection that testifies to a profound engagement with literature and to the pleasures of close reading. Fugitive Tilts rewards patient readers, inviting them to share in Hutchinson’s sustained, thoughtful encounter with the written word.








