Azruddin faces backlash over ‘misguided’ call for blanket price controls
US-indicted businessman and Opposition Leader Azruddin Mohamed
US-indicted businessman and Opposition Leader Azruddin Mohamed

–critics say suggestions expose lack of understanding, knowledge of economy’s management

 

US-INDICTED businessman and Opposition Leader Azruddin Mohamed is facing backlash by critics for his lack of knowledge and understanding of how the economy works after he suggested blanket price controls on commodities.

Mohamed, in an interview with reporters on Friday, suggested that price controls would help alleviate cost of living issues. However, according to analysts and historical evidence, price controls could be damaging to a modern, free-market economy.

The primary mechanism to determine prices in a market-based system is through supply and demand. Price control schemes risk creating myriad unintended negative consequences, including but not limited to shortages (due to increased demand for products); less supply (as producers are no longer incentivised to produce); and black markets.

Historically speaking, price control mechanisms have proven to be short-lived and costly. Furthermore, since Guyana relies heavily on imports to meet domestic needs, the likelihood of discouraging importers and retailers from supplying products at higher than controlled prices is likely. Therefore, price control mechanisms are unlikely to achieve their intended purpose of making products more affordable.

Guyana’s experience with price controls during the 1970s-1980s under the People’s National Congress (PNC) government was disastrous, according to critics.

The World Bank had recommended in recovery frameworks that Guyana reduce price distortions by limiting price controls only to highly essential commodities with low demand elasticity.

The financial institution said when the government abolished price controls and liberalised markets in the early 1990s, GDP grew six per cent in 1991 after fifteen years of continuous decline, with growth continuing at five-seven per cent annually through the mid-1990s.

Industries like rice, sugar, and gold had rebounded as private initiative returned to the economy.

Historical experience is further reason that there could be no chance of success with such ideas.

During the interview, the reporter mentioned that he thought that the historical experience was an example of how we should avoid implementing policies that did not work before.

Mohamed responded by saying he is confident it would work, without offering an explanation. 

The reason Mohamed’s comments also raised questions among analysts is because he attempted to draw a parallel between regulating the foreign exchange market and establishing price controls for food.

Many have indicated that this analogy does not hold true. A government can regulate a currency in a foreign exchange market by employing various methods, including but not limited to setting interest rates; managing reserves; and implementing other monetary policies. These actions fall under the realm of monetary policy.

As previously stated, these types of regulatory actions do not equal the direct administration of price controls. Price controls are direct administrative regulations on a product and its associated retail price, and as such they are directly opposed to market signals.

Many have also expressed concern over Mohamed’s lack of understanding regarding fundamental economic principles.

He appears to conflate foreign exchange regulation with price control mechanisms, suggesting he fails to comprehend how different these two mechanisms truly are.

A number of observers have suggested that there are better ways for a government to assist consumers during periods of high inflation than through blanket price control mechanisms.

The government has already rolled out and continues to roll out several forms of assistance, including subsidies, offering tax relief, and increasing income levels.

Specifically, over the past five years, more than 200 taxes have been repealed, while social programmes have been broadened to include all sectors of society.

Measures have been introduced to offer subsidies and direct support for housing construction and improvement, with a particular focus on assisting poor and vulnerable families.

Initiatives to encourage banks to lower interest rates and ease collateral requirements for low-income groups have also been pursued, while a SME development bank is on the horizon.

SHARE THIS ARTICLE :
Facebook
Twitter
WhatsApp
All our printed editions are available online
emblem3
Subscribe to the Guyana Chronicle.
Sign up to receive news and updates.
We respect your privacy.