THE need for the society to have a culture of transparency has arisen once more with the recent issue of GHK Lall. No one can doubt that there must be transparency in government. But the culture of transparency cannot be confined to one section of society only. It has to be a national value system encompassing the nation.
Transparency in society becomes necessary when people take on the role of public scrutinizers. The society would not be interested in how a farmer markets his products if he assigns one price for Jones and a different price for Smith. That it is business, and Jones is the person to ask him for transparency. The farmer is not a public figure, and he does not impress upon the society and government that he wants answers for national occurrences.
It is a different ambience with the media and civil society players. They both operate in the public sphere, and they demand answers from government and public figures. The perfect example is the editor-in-chief of the Stabroek News (SN), Mr. Anand Persaud. He sent me an email and inquired if it was true that when I was a teenager, I stole books from the National Library, which someone informed the newspaper about.
When Persaud made his request, I was a newspaper columnist and a university lecturer. I had public status; thus, Mr. Persaud was in his right to wrest obligation from me, and I had an obligation to be transparent as a public figure. I told Mr. Persaud that I did steal the books. The newspaper ran a story on that. The incident was more than 50 years old, but as a public figure, the newspaper had an interest in me.
When civil society and the media make the news, then they have an obligation to be transparent because society must have a culture of transparency. The best example of this is the New York Times (NYT). Last year when Israel was committing genocide in Gaza (it still does at the moment), it was revealed that NTY was investigating some of its reporters who leaked the story about biased information in favour of Israel, which described how Hamas killed babies and hung their heads on sticks.
It was not true that Hamas did that. When the behavior of NYT became public, the media that reported the news had now become the news, and NYT had to be transparent. There is no national culture of transparency in Guyana, and this lack of transparency has even afflicted certain embassies in Guyana.
The EU Embassy refuses to be transparent and tell Guyana which NGOs it gives money to. This writer’s research reveals that all the receiving NGOs are anti-government actors. So yesterday (Wednesday), Mr. GHK Lall, a frenetic accuser of the government, was called upon to be transparent, but the man refused to be.
In a letter in yesterday’s SN, he was asked once more if he gave a mining licence to Travis Chase, has money invested in Demerara Waves (DW), and misled Guyanese when the-then Minister of Natural Resources contradicted when Lall told Guyanese that when he, Lall, was head of the Gold Board, Azruddin Mohamed and his father were never mentioned in any correspondence from the US.
DW has not seen the obligation to be transparent and tell its subscribers what investment Lall has in DW. SN contacted me about a youthful indiscretion that I did more than 50 years ago but never ran a story on attorney Rex McKay, who was convicted in a court of law in the 1950s of stealing a tube of bicycle tyres from Booker’s Garage when he was a clerk there. And it was easy to get the story because it was reported in the Guiana Graphic.
This is the lop-sided way transparency operates in this country. Do Chris Ram and GHL Lall have shares in SN? The two men are very close to SN and are given unprecedented latitude by the newspaper. I asked Ram if he is a shareholder; he said no. But I should have asked if Ram and McRae, as a company distinct from Ram himself, has shares in SN.
To this day, the newspaper does not see the need to be transparent and answer if Ram and Mc Rae and Lall are shareholders. Mr. Anand Persaud is still to answer if he is a huge shareholder in SN. The Guyana Human Rights Association says it receives no money from the EU Embassy, but the Catholic Church does so on behalf of Policy Forum which both the GHRA and the church are part of. I guess transparency is a one-way street in Guyana.
DISCLAIMER: The views and opinions expressed in this column are solely those of the author and do not necessarily reflect the official policy or position of the Guyana National Newspapers Limited.








