DPP says poor police investigations have impacted results of criminal trials
– also highlights inconsistencies in evidence, poor identification
– two judges, too many cases
THE Chambers of the Director of Public Prosecutions (DPP) has issued a statement detailing the reasons for the outcome of certain court trials, especially at the criminal assizes.
Some of the issues highlighted include poor police investigations, as well as poor identification; inconsistencies in evidence and other things that could have impacted the results of cases.
The DPP statement, issued on Monday, said: “Gaol Delivery was done on June 4, 2012, which brought to an end the Demerara April 2012 Criminal Assizes. This Assizes commenced on 3rd April, 2012. There were 234 cases listed to be heard by two judges and five of these cases were completed during the Assizes, 117 cases listed to be heard by Madame Justice Roxanne George and 117 cases listed to be heard by Mr. Justice Franklin Holder.
“Three matters were completed by Mr. Justice Franklin Holder. Two were for the offence of murder. In one of the murder cases, the accused pleaded not guilty to murder and guilty to the lesser offence of manslaughter and was sentenced to eight years imprisonment. In the other murder case, the trial judge upheld a no-case submission and, thereafter, directed the jury to return a formal verdict of not guilty.
“In the third matter, the accused was indicted for two offences, rape and robbery under arms. In this case, the
jury returned a not guilty verdict against the accused. The victim positively identified the accused and an independent witness testified seeing the accused spring off from the victim during the course of the rape, and two men who were in the car of this witness pursued the accused and caught him. Despite this strong and compelling evidence, the jury
returned a verdict of not guilty, which was inconsistent with the evidence.
“Two matters were completed by Madame Justice Roxanne George. These matters were both for the offence of murder. In one of the matters, there were three accused. Two of them pleaded not guilty of murder and guilty to the
lesser offence of manslaughter and were each sentenced to 30 years imprisonment. A formal verdict of not guilty was returned by the jury for the third accused. In the second case, the trial judge upheld a no-case submission and, thereafter, directed the jury to return a formal verdict of
not guilty.
POOR INVESTIGATIONS
“The trial judge upheld a no-case submission because of the poor investigations done by the police in relation to identification of the accused. The police, in taking the statement of the main witness who saw the alleged accused, did not take from her a detailed description of
the person whom she saw. Also no identification parade was held. This is another case of poor investigations by the police in relation to the issue of identification.
“Prior to the April Assizes, there was the January Demerara 2012 Criminal Assizes, which commenced on January 10, 2012. Two judges sat for the January Assizes, Madame Justice Dawn Gregory and Mr. Justice Franklin Holder. Madame Justice Dawn Gregory had a list of 112 matters and Mr. Justice Franklin Holder had a list of 114 cases.
“Six cases were completed during the January Assizes. Three matters were each done by Madame Justice Dawn Gregory and Mr. Justice Franklin Holder. Of the three cases which were done by Madame Justice Dawn Gregory, one of
them was for the offence of rape and robbery under arms. In this matter, the jury returned a verdict of not guilty of both counts. The other two matters were for the offence of murder. In one of them, the jury returned a unanimous verdict of guilty and the accused was sentenced to death by
hanging. In the other matter, the accused pleaded not guilty of murder but guilty of manslaughter and was sentenced to 12 years imprisonment.
“The three trials that were done by Mr. Justice Franklin Holder were for the offence of murder. In one of the matters, there were two accused. The jury returned a formal verdict of not guilty for one of the
accused and a retrial was ordered for the other. In the second matter, the accused pleaded not guilty of murder but guilty to the lesser count of manslaughter and was sentenced to 10 years imprisonment. In the third matter, a no-case submission was upheld and the jury, on the direction of
the trial judge, returned a formal verdict of not guilty against the accused.
“A total of 11 matters were presented for the Demerara Criminal Assizes, from January to May 2012.
The Demerara June 2012 Criminal Assizes commenced on June 5, 2012 and there are 234 cases listed to be heard for this Assizes. Madame Justice Roxanne George and Mr. Justice Franklin Holder will be sitting for the month of June during the June 2012 Criminal Assizes.
“At the same time, while the Demerara Criminal Assizes were in progress, there were criminal Assizes also being held in both Berbice and Essequibo.
“The Berbice Criminal Assizes continued in January 2012 with Mr. Justice Brassington Reynolds sitting as the judge. During that month, two cases were completed. One of the cases was for the offences of murder and assault
causing actual bodily harm. In this matter, the accused pleaded not guilty of murder but guilty to the lesser offence of manslaughter. As a result, the accused was sentenced to nine years imprisonment. The second offence of assault causing actual bodily harm, the matter was nolle prosequi by the DPP, because the victim, who was the wife of the accused, gave a statement that she did not wish to proceed with the prosecution. In the second case, which was for the offence of murder, the accused pleaded not guilty to murder and guilty to the lesser offence of manslaughter and was
sentenced to 12 years imprisonment.
“Gaol Delivery was done on 31st January, 2012, which brought an end to the Berbice October 2011 Criminal Assizes and 29 cases were outstanding. These cases were included on the following list for the February 2012 Criminal Assizes.
“The February Assizes opened on the 7th February, 2012 and continues until the 18th June 2012. There were 42 cases listed to be heard by Mr. Justice Bovell-Drakes during this session. Of these 42 cases, five matters have been completed, so far.
HUNG VERDICT
“For the period from January to May, a total of seven cases were completed for the Berbice Criminal Assizes. In three of the cases, the accused pleaded not guilty of murder but guilty of manslaughter. In a fourth case, the accused pleaded guilty to the offence of abduction. In the other three cases, there were trials and, in one of those cases, there was a hung verdict for the offence and a retrial was ordered. In the other two cases, there was a not guilty verdict for the offence of carnal knowledge and a guilty verdict for the offence of murder.
“Forty-three cases are listed for hearing for the Berbice June 2012 Criminal Assizes which will commence on 19th June, 2012.
“The Essequibo October 2011 Criminal Assizes continued in January 2012 with Madame Justice Roxanne George sitting as the judge. Madame Justice Roxanne
George completed three cases as of 20th February, 2012. The three cases were for the offences of buggery, manslaughter and murder. In the case for the offence of buggery, the jury returned a unanimous verdict of guilty and the accused was sentenced to 18 years imprisonment. In the second matter, which was for the offence of manslaughter, a no-case submission was upheld by the trial judge and the jury was directed, by the trial judge, to return a formal verdict of not guilty. In the third matter, which was for the offence of murder, the judge quashed the committal, since it was bad and made an order for a new preliminary Inquiry to be done.
“The February Criminal Assizes was opened on the 21st February 2012 and concluded on 14th May, 2012. There were 18 cases listed to be heard by the judge and one matter was completed, which was for the offence of murder. In
this case, the jury returned a verdict of not guilty.
“At present, the Essequibo May 2012 Criminal Assizes is in progress. This Assizes was opened on the 15th May 2012. There were 18 cases listed to be heard by Mr. Justice Winston Patterson during this Assizes. So far, one
matter was completed, for the offence of murder. In this matter, the accused pleaded not guilty to murder but guilty to the lesser count of manslaughter and was sentenced to twenty years imprisonment.
“For the period from January to May, there were five cases completed for the Essequibo Criminal Assizes. In one case, there was a guilty verdict and in two cases there were not guilty verdicts. In one case, the indictment was quashed and in yet another, the accused pleaded guilty to the lesser
offence of manslaughter,” the statement by the DPP reported.







