THE Caribbean Court of Justice (CCJ) has ruled in favour of Janet Hassan in a long-running Guyana land ownership dispute, restoring a High Court decision that dismissed a claim for possession and finding that a 1990 receipt constituted evidence of an agreement to sell the disputed property.
In a judgment delivered on November 3, 2026, in Janet Hassan v Romanie Gouveia [2026] CCJ 16 (AJ) GY, the regional court allowed Ms Hassan’s appeal, overturning the Court of Appeal’s interpretation of the receipt as merely granting permission to occupy the land.
The CCJ also set aside a G$300,000 costs award previously imposed against Ms Hassan by the Court of Appeal, describing the award as excessive and disproportionate.
The dispute centred on a receipt signed in 1990 by Eric Sue, recording a payment of G$2,235 made by Ms Hassan’s husband, Abdool Hassan, “for the use of” the land.
The document recorded that full payment had been made and contemplated the construction of houses on the property. However, it also stated that the land was reserved for the straightening of the Essequibo Road and that “no transport can be issued”.
In Guyana, a transport is a legal instrument recording ownership of land or immovable property.
Romanie Gouveia, the executrix of Sue’s estate and the transported owner of the property, subsequently instituted proceedings in the High Court seeking possession of the land.
The trial judge dismissed her claim, finding that the receipt was authentic and constituted evidence of a binding agreement for the sale of the property by Sue to Abdool Hassan.
However, the Court of Appeal overturned that decision, interpreting the receipt as a mere licence or permission to occupy the land. It ordered Ms Hassan to surrender possession by December 1, 2025, and pay G$175,000 in costs.
Dissatisfied with that ruling, Ms Hassan appealed to the CCJ, which found that the Court of Appeal had erred by failing to properly consider the receipt in its entirety and the circumstances surrounding its creation.
The regional court held that the document, when objectively interpreted alongside the factual, contractual and textual context, demonstrated an agreement to sell the land rather than simply granting permission for occupation.
In reaching its decision, the CCJ found that the Court of Appeal had placed undue emphasis on particular wording in the receipt without giving sufficient consideration to the broader circumstances.
The court particularly noted that the reservation of the property for the straightening of the Essequibo Road, together with the undisputed fact that Sue was not the transported owner, provided a compelling explanation for the statement that no transport could be issued.
Consequently, the CCJ allowed the appeal and restored the High Court order dismissing Gouveia’s claim for possession.
The court also addressed the costs imposed during a separate application before the Court of Appeal, in which Ms Hassan had been granted permission to appeal to the CCJ but was refused a stay of the order requiring her to surrender possession by December 1, 2025.
In that application, the Court of Appeal had ordered Ms Hassan to pay G$300,000 in costs.
The CCJ found that no reasons had been provided to justify an award exceeding the costs of the substantive appeal, particularly since the application was routine and had been partly successful.
It further considered the award excessive and disproportionate, warning that arbitrary or significantly disproportionate costs orders could undermine access to justice and procedural fairness.
The CCJ therefore ordered Gouveia to repay the G$300,000 to Ms Hassan by December 3, 2026. Gouveia was also ordered to pay Ms Hassan’s standard costs before the CCJ, as well as her costs in the High Court and Court of Appeal.
The matter was heard by Justices Rajnauth-Lee, Jamadar, Ononaiwu, Eboe-Osuji and Bulkan.
Appearing for Ms Hassan were Senior Counsel Seenath Jairam, Abiola Wong-Inniss, Joel Ross, Akeeta Kingston and Paula Gomes, while Arudranauth Gossai represented Gouveia.







