Nigel Hughes versus the PNC, AFC and APNU+AFC government

THIS is part 5 of the series in which I look at the absolute confusion in the coalition government of the PNC, AFC and WPA after power was won in May 2015. The series started on October 11 and began with the role of Khemraj Ramjattan versus the Mulatto/Creole class (MCC) after the AFC got into power.
I noted in part 2 that what took place after 2015 between President Granger and the PNC, the AFC and the PNC and within the AFC itself constitutes the most mysterious period in the history of Guyanese politics. There is no period in Guyanese history in which so much confusion descended on the government. I did state that, as I go along, readers will find a lot of the descriptions of the actions of the PNC, AFC and the government itself as mumbo jumbo. Indeed, it was.
The PNC never liked Nigel Hughes. Research is needed to explain why, but the probable reason is that the PNC would not have reached out to Hughes because PNC leaders saw him as a huge, charismatic figure that may have diminished their standing and influence in the PNC. It was natural then that trouble was bound to happen with Hughes when the PNC and AFC got into power.
Hughes is a quintessential MCC personality. But as Chairman of the AFC when the AFC came into power, Hughes ran into problems with his own class in the AFC. Two reasons explain this. Hughes, because of his exposure to Rodneyite politics and his experience in the long anti-Burnham struggle, had nuances to his politics that none of the MCC founders of the AFC had, including his own wife, Cathy Hughes.
Those nuances were bent towards some sympathy for working class benefits and transformational politics. The most conspicuous example of this was his confrontation with the AFC leadership over local government elections in Bartica in 2016. Hughes took the position that it is best for local leaders to run the local government system rather than the centralised parties. He opposed APNU+AFC contesting the local government election in Bartica in opposition to a local group named BIGGA. His stance was rejected by the entire AFC leadership
His role in the AFC from 2015 onwards was not in line with the elitist governance of his MCC colleagues in the AFC. The second reason was that Hughes responded to the dislike the PNC showed him with mutual dislike. What he did from 2015 onwards was to rock the boat, much to the dislike of his MCC colleagues, who felt Hughes’s two demands could weaken the government or bring about its collapse.
The first demand was for the birth of a monitoring committee of APNU and AFC cadres to iron out disagreements between the two parties in government. I know this because he talked to me about it several times. Both Granger and the AFC did not want this and it was dropped. The second demand made Hughes persona non grata in the AFC.
Hughes felt that the PNC was miniaturising the AFC and was hogging power. He wanted more latitude for the AFC. Up to this point, the PNC and President Granger did not know about this intra-party split in the AFC. It burst out into the public domain when Hughes could no longer contain his anger. Hughes’ second demand was causing him to lose out among both his MCC colleagues in the AFC and the non-MCC leaders like Ramjattan and Moses Nagamootoo. They felt he was pushing too far
Hughes requested a retreat of all party executives, heads of the 10 regional management committees, the AFC ministers and parliamentarians. The agenda has one item on it – to decrease the enormous state power that the Minister of the President wielded. The retreat agreed with Hughes, but the next day things fell apart.
President Granger was annoyed at the decision made at the retreat and expressed deep disappointment at the AFC’s position. Granger argued that the AFC’s behaviour was not conducive to coalition harmony. What happened next enraged Hughes. The AFC ministers of government, without exception, mollified the President and disassociated themselves from Hughes obduracy. Hughes the very next day resigned from the chairmanship and the membership of the AFC and announced his retirement from politics.
The story of Granger and Hughes was a contrasting one. Granger was successful in staving off the PNC after 2015. Hughes was unsuccessful in getting the AFC leadership to stand up to Granger. Sadly, Hughes threw away the Walter Rodney moment that made him famous in Guyana. After retiring from politics, his activism became Afro-centric. He lost the huge multi-racial support he had when AFC was born in 2005. Next – the AFC, not Granger, was afraid of losing power.
DISCLAIMER: The views and opinions expressed in this column are solely those of the author and do not necessarily reflect the official policy or position of the Guyana National Newspapers Limited.

SHARE THIS ARTICLE :
Facebook
Twitter
WhatsApp
All our printed editions are available online
emblem3
Subscribe to the Guyana Chronicle.
Sign up to receive news and updates.
We respect your privacy.