Witness tells court SoPs not provided during key tabulation stage

–as variance identified in vote count

 

A KEY witness in the ongoing election fraud trial, People’s Progressive Party/Civic (PPP/C) agent Sasenarine Singh has testified that original Statements of Poll (SoPs) were not provided during a critical stage of the 2020 General and Regional Elections tabulation process, even as he observed a variance in one of the documents being reconciled.

Under cross-examination by Defence Attorney-at-Llaw Dexter Todd on Friday, this prosecution witness told the court that while 421 of 879 SoPs for District Four had initially been tabulated and reconciled without issue, the process later shifted away from direct SoPs comparison.

Guyana’s Ambassador to the European Union, Sasenarine Singh

“So, yes, there was full ascertainment and tabulation of 421 of the 879 Statements of Poll for District Four, under the leadership of Mr. Mingo,” Singh testified.

Mingo, one of the nine defendants in the trial, was at the time serving as the Returning Officer for District Four.

He stated that the results reflected “a clear correlation with what I had”, as well as what other political parties had recorded.

However, Singh testified that the situation changed during the continuation of the process at the Guyana Elections Commission (GECOM) Ashmins Building, where he said SoPs were no longer physically presented for verification.

“When we started at the back of the building, that is when everything went amok,” he told the court.

Singh said that instead of being shown original SoPs, figures were called from what he described as a spreadsheet.

Defendant Denise Babb-Cummings

“They just called numbers from a document in front of them… It was not a Statement of Poll. It was a set of numbers on a spreadsheet,” he stated.

He further told the court that despite repeated requests from multiple parties, including commissioners and observers, the original SoPs were not produced at that stage.

“Even the GECOM commissioners…the ambassadors asked to see the original statements of poll… but it was never provided,” Singh said.

During questioning on a specific document, SoP 4076, Singh acknowledged that he observed a variance, but maintained he had no knowledge of who prepared the spreadsheet used during the process.

Singh also confirmed that while he had access to PPP/C copies of SoPs during the reconciliation process, he did not have custody of GECOM’s original documents.

“The original Statements of Poll is always in the possession of GECOM,” he added.

The witness told the court that he only observed discrepancies during the later stage of the tabulation exercise, after the initial reconciliation of 421 SoPs had been completed.

Singh has since concluded his testimony.

 

NO SIGN OF DARREN WADE

Moreover, Chief Magistrate Faith Mc Gusty noted the absence of Defence Attorney Darren Wade during proceedings in the ongoing election fraud trial.

The issue arose as cross-examination of Singh progressed.

During the sitting, the court indicated that it had not heard from Wade, who was part of the defence team, and sought clarification on his whereabouts.

“I’ve heard nothing from Mr. Wade,” the Chief Magistrate stated, while asking whether any member of the defence team had been in contact with him, or whether he remained actively engaged in the matter.

The court further noted that one of Wade’s colleagues, Attorney Ronald Daniels, had communicated an inability to attend due to another commitment, but no explanation had been provided for Wade’s absence.

“Has anyone on the defence team heard from Mr. Wade? Is he still a part of the defence team? I have not seen him for an extended period. If someone could contact Mr. Wade, I’d be happy,” the magistrate stated in open court.

She further noted that telephone calls made to him had gone unanswered, and were not returned.

This prompted brief discussion among counsel regarding the composition and availability of the defence team.

The court ultimately granted a short adjournment to allow time for contact to be made with Wade, while proceedings in the matter remain ongoing.

Shortly thereafter, Todd informed the court that Wade had since returned his call.

Todd told the court that Wade had extended his apologies, and indicated that he would not be proceeding with the cross-examination of Singh.

When the proceedings resumed for the afternoon session, PPP/ C tabulation officer Bibi Aneishaw-Mohamed was asked by Prosecuting Attorney Latchmie Rahamat to explain a series of recordings she had made, which were tendered into evidence through a police rank.

She told the court that the recordings in question captured discrepancies between what was being announced in the tabulation room and what she believed were the official SoPs.

Mohamed testified that the recordings were made in the District Four tabulation exercise, and later handed over to the police.

When played in court, she identified several clips and repeatedly explained that, “the audio represents what was being announced in the room… and the image [of SoPs] represents what the actual numbers are.”

“If you notice, it’s 207 that’s recorded [on the SoP] for APNU [A Partnership for National Unity], but 267 was announced,” she noted, in support of her claim that votes were inflated for APNU during the tabulation process.

She told the court that the announcements were made by two female officials, whom she described as GECOM agents, one of whom was heavily pregnant, though she could not recall their names.

According to her, “they were the ones that were basically announcing what was on the SoPs.”

She further explained that the tabulation process as one involving a live spreadsheet displayed on a screen, where figures were entered after being called out.

However, her testimony drew objections from the defence team, which argued that she was drawing conclusions beyond what she directly observed.

 

ANNOUNCEMENTS VERSUS LIVE ENTRIES

 

Under questioning, Mohamed maintained that she observed both the announcements and the live entries, stating that the numbers being announced did not match those recorded on the SoPs.

The trial is set to resume on Monday, April 27, 2026 at the Georgetown Magistrates’ Courts, where Mohamed is expected to continue giving testimony.

Those on trial include former Chief Elections Officer (CEO) Keith Lowenfield; former Deputy CEO Roxanne Myers; former Region Four Returning Officer Clairmont Mingo; former Health Minister Volda Lawrence; and People’s National Congress Reform (PNCR) member Carol Smith-Joseph. Also facing charges are former GECOM staffers Michelle Miller, Sheffern February, Enrique Livan, and Denise Babb-Cummings.

The defendants collectively face 19 charges, including conspiracy to defraud and misconduct in public office. Each has entered a plea of not guilty and was released on significant cash bail.

The prosecution, led by King’s Counsel Darshan Ramdhani, has argued that the defendants each played a “critical role” in attempts to inflate votes in favour of the then-incumbent A Partnership for National Unity and Alliance for Change (APNU+AFC) coalition while reducing votes for the PPP/C.

Initial results announced by Lowenfield had declared an APNU+AFC victory, with 171,825 votes against the PPP/C’s 166,343. However, after five months of litigation and a Caribbean Community (CARICOM)-supervised recount, the PPP/C was declared the winner with 233,336 votes to APNU+AFC’s 217,920, paving the way for Dr. Irfaan Ali’s swearing-in as president on August 2, 2020.

The fallout from the election controversy led to the termination of Lowenfield, Myers, and Mingo’s contracts at GECOM in August 2021.

The Presidential Commission of Inquiry (CoI) into the events of the 2020 General and Regional Elections have found that there were collusion and collaboration between senior GECOM officials to divert votes to the APNU +AFC instead of safeguarding and preserving the integrity of the electoral system.

SHARE THIS ARTICLE :
Facebook
Twitter
WhatsApp
All our printed editions are available online
emblem3
Subscribe to the Guyana Chronicle.
Sign up to receive news and updates.
We respect your privacy.