The Language of Appeal: Understanding Literary Fiction Through The Dancer Upstairs

JOYCE Saricks, in her wonderful primer for librarians, Reader’s Advisory Service in the Public Library, argues that the primary appeal factor of literary fiction is its writing style and language. Saricks describes literary language as elegant or “lyrical”, suggesting prose that approaches poetry in its rhythm and beauty. She also characterises literary language as “layered”, implying syntactic complexity and stylistic richness reminiscent of writers such as Nabokov or García Márquez. Such prose is pleasurable to read for its metaphors, wordplay, and allusions, much like the dense and playful style found in the works of Thomas Pynchon.

However, a refined prose style or complex syntax is not the sole defining feature of literary fiction. Literary works are also distinguished by their subject matter and thematic depth. Often, these novels grapple with profound questions about human existence, morality, and history. Gabriel García Márquez’s One Hundred Years of Solitude, for example, presents the genesis and destruction of an entire world through the mythical history of the Buendía family. Cormac McCarthy’s Blood Meridian offers apocalyptic and brutal visions of violence and human depravity. Pynchon’s Mason & Dixon, by contrast, combines ribald humour with dense historical and literary allusion. These works illustrate how literary fiction engages readers through both stylistic sophistication and thematic ambition.

The appeal of language in literary fiction differs from that of genres such as mystery or horror. Readers of those genres may not necessarily seek lyrical prose or stylistic complexity as primary sources of enjoyment. Instead, they often value elements such as plot, suspense, and pacing. Yet the boundary between literary fiction and genre fiction is not always clear. Many mystery writers, for example, display considerable literary craftsmanship. The novels of P. D. James and Ruth Rendell combine intricate plotting with refined prose, while Raymond Chandler and Ross Macdonald bring a kind of gritty urban poetry to the detective genre.

Language, therefore, remains a central appeal factor of literary fiction, and it plays a dominant role in Nicholas Shakespeare’s political thriller The Dancer Upstairs. The novel is reminiscent of the sophisticated espionage fiction of John le Carré—particularly The Constant Gardener and The Tailor of Panama—as well as the politically charged narratives of Graham Greene, such as The Quiet American and Our Man in Havana. These works share another appealing element: their vividly rendered exotic locations. Through such novels, readers can vicariously experience distant cultures and political landscapes—Cuba, Vietnam, Panama, and Peru—while following gripping narratives of intrigue and conflict.

The nationality of these authors may also contribute to their appeal. British writers such as Greene, le Carré, and Shakespeare have long excelled at combining political insight with narrative suspense. Similarly, one might prefer the mysteries of P. D. James or Ruth Rendell not only for their literary quality but also for their distinctive British sensibility.

Nevertheless, the fundamental appeal of suspense novels remains suspense itself. This is certainly true of the works of le Carré and Greene, and it is equally true of Shakespeare’s The Dancer Upstairs. Beyond its poetic prose, reviewers frequently describe the novel as “nail-biting”, “chilling”, “tension-filled”, “exciting”, and “compelling”. These adjectives highlight the importance of pacing and dramatic tension in shaping the reader’s experience.

A professional review clearly illustrates these appeal factors. Drawing inspiration from political turmoil in Peru, Shakespeare crafts a literary thriller in which a detective’s pursuit of a terrorist leader unfolds into a complex narrative of politics, violence, and personal relationships. The story is framed through a British journalist, John Dyer, who encounters Agustín Rejas, a former police colonel responsible for capturing a notorious Maoist insurgent known as President Ezequiel. This character is modelled on Abimael Guzmán, leader of Peru’s Shining Path movement. Through Rejas’s recollections, the novel explores both the psychological toll of political violence and the intimate details of everyday life within a nation plagued by ideological conflict.

Shakespeare builds tension gradually and with remarkable precision. Rejas recounts chilling episodes—from the manipulation of children into acts of violence to the constant threat that shadows daily life in a society caught between a repressive government and revolutionary insurgents. Although the journalist narrator functions primarily as a framing device, the novel ultimately offers a powerful examination of the motivations and moral dilemmas faced by individuals living through turbulent historical events.

The language used in such reviews reveals much about the vocabulary of appeal. Words like excruciating, deadly, powerful, struggle, tension, gripping, and terrorised point to key elements of plot and pacing. Tension suggests not only the speed at which the story unfolds but also the conflict between opposing forces—often framed as good versus evil. Similarly, the term compelling conveys a book’s “page-turner” quality, implying narrative momentum and believability.

Readers and librarians often rely on such descriptive vocabulary when selecting books. Terms like gripping and chilling frequently appear on book covers or promotional materials to signal excitement and danger. The phrase many-layered, meanwhile, suggests complexity—either in the plot structure or in the richness of the prose. These descriptors form part of what Saricks calls the language of appeal, a set of terms used to describe pacing, characterisation, storyline, and narrative frame in ways that readers and librarians can understand consistently.

In practice, however, a single word may evoke multiple aspects of a book simultaneously. Descriptions such as “vivid” or “lush” can refer to both the prose style and the richness of narrative detail. In The Dancer Upstairs, for example, Shakespeare’s vivid, lush language creates an immersive portrait of both the characters and the setting.

Notably, readers do not necessarily need to read the novel itself to understand its appeal. Book reviews often provide sufficient information to identify similar works. After reading a review of The Dancer Upstairs, several potential read-alikes come readily to mind: Mario Vargas Llosa’s Death in the Andes and Who Killed Palomino Molero?, V. S. Naipaul’s Guerrillas, John le Carré’s The Constant Gardener, and Graham Greene’s Our Man in Havana. Recommendation tools such as NoveList and Amazon frequently suggest similar titles, demonstrating how shared appeal factors guide reading suggestions.

These appeal descriptors often become the blurbs featured on book covers and promotional materials. Publishers selectively highlight the most flattering descriptions from professional reviews. The paperback edition of The Dancer Upstairs, for instance, prominently features terms such as tension-filled, suspenseful, exciting, compelling, excruciating, chilling, riveting, haunting, violent, gripping, and frightening. Collectively, these words encompass a wide range of appeal factors.

Librarians and readers may also be influenced by endorsements from other authors working in similar genres. Such blurbs reinforce the novel’s literary and thematic qualities. One reviewer describes the book as “a fascinating and wholly compelling novel, lucidly and expertly told and ringing with unmistakable authenticity”. Another praises Shakespeare’s prose as “clean and precise as a coroner’s scalpel”, while emphasising the vitality of his characters and the intensity of their political environment.

These endorsements serve not only as praise but also as guides for readers seeking comparable works. In this case, the comparison to Graham Greene’s The Third Man provides yet another potential read-alike. For librarians engaged in readers’ advisory work, such connections can be invaluable in helping patrons discover books that match their interests.

 

SHARE THIS ARTICLE :
Facebook
Twitter
WhatsApp
All our printed editions are available online
emblem3
Subscribe to the Guyana Chronicle.
Sign up to receive news and updates.
We respect your privacy.