‘The President acted lawfully’

–AG maintains, files notice of appeal against ruling in PSC challenge

ATTORNEY-GENERAL, Anil Nandlall, S.C., will be moving to appeal Justice Gino Persaud’s ruling in favour of a constitutional action challenging the suspension of the former Police Service Commission (PSC) in 2021.

In March, Justice Persaud found that the President acted unlawfully when, based on the advice of the Prime Minister, Brigadier (ret’d) Mark Phillips, and in accordance with Article 225 of the Constitution of Guyana, he suspended the then Chairman, Paul Slowe, and the members of the Commission, pending the findings of a tribunal that was to be established.

However, Nandlall has rejected the ruling and filed a notice of appeal at the Court of Appeal of the Supreme Court to have the decision overturned.

In the application, the Attorney-General is contending that Justice Persaud misdirected himself in the law when he determined that the expired PSC could lawfully continue to maintain legal proceedings, and in so determining, refused the applicant’s application to strike out the defunct PSC challenge.

Nandlall further contended that Justice Persaud erred when he determined that the PSC, for which members were appointed on May 31, 2022, was not properly constituted and, therefore, could neither participate in continuing nor discontinuing the proceedings before the court.

Among other things, the Attorney General is arguing that the Judge misdirected himself when he ruled that the President breached the constitution when he suspended Slowe and other commissioners.

Justice Persaud, in his ruling, posited that after the question of removing the officers is put to the President by the Prime Minister, the President shall act in accordance with the advice of the Judicial Service Commission (JSC) in appointing a tribunal.

This tribunal is to consist of a chairman and not less than two other members. However, Nandlall, in his notice of appeal is contending that the Judge erred.

“The Learned Judge erred when he failed to properly appreciate that all of these peculiar circumstances concatenated to give rise to a necessity upon which the President, having received the advice of the Prime Minister, acted to suspend the former Commissioners, or otherwise, the machinery of administration, impacted by the actions of the Police Service Commission, may have further broken down,” the Attorney General reasoned.

Previously, Nandlall said that many of the crucial reliefs sought by Slowe fell away with the passage of time and other legal challenges, including those filed by the opposition.

The Attorney General went on to explain that the PSC is an independent body responsible for the promotion of certain ranks in the Police Force and for disciplining those ranks.

He alleged that Slowe is a known critic of the People’s Progressive Party/Civic (PPP/C) and is not impartial.

Nandlall stressed that Slowe is currently criminally charged and is before the Georgetown Magistrates’ Court on three counts of sexual assault, and the offence of conspiracy to defraud the State of just over $10 million.

The Attorney General, in addressing this aspect of the judge’s ruling, said that the President acted in the public’s interest, and in the interest of national security.

“What should the President have done in those circumstances to allow such a rogue organisation to proceed with a course of action that would have had destructive consequences to the police force of the country? Or should he sit and twiddle his thumb because there is no Judicial Service Commission?” he questioned.

Nandlall underscored that President Ali acted lawfully by exercising his executive power, and in the exercise of his deliberate judgement, since there was no JSC in place to which he could have turned to establish his tribunal.

Last year, Justice Persaud threw out an application for a stay of the proceedings which was filed by Attorney-at-Law Darshan Ramdhani, KC, who was representing the interest of the reconstituted PSC and the Attorney General.

The two parties had called for a stay of the substantive case, pending the outcome of appeals filed against the rulings made by Chief Justice (ag) Roxane George, S.C., in cases which touched on the subject of the action before Justice Persaud.

SHARE THIS ARTICLE :
Facebook
Twitter
WhatsApp
All our printed editions are available online
emblem3
Subscribe to the Guyana Chronicle.
Sign up to receive news and updates.
We respect your privacy.