Corruption, brutality occurred under PPP – U.S. report
Colwyn Harding
Colwyn Harding

UNLAWFUL killings by police, abuse of suspects and detainees by security forces, and poor prison and jail conditions were cited as the most serious instances of human rights abuses in Guyana by the U.S. Government in its 2014 Human Rights Report on Guyana during the tenure of the People’s Progressive Party (PPP) Administration. The report also highlighted the issues of lengthy pretrial detention; excessive government influence over the content of the National Communications Network (NCN), and continued restrictions on radio licensing; allegations of government corruption, including among police officials; sexual and domestic violence against women; abuse of minors; and laws that discriminate against lesbian, gay, bisexual, and transgender (LGBT) persons.

Alex Griffith
Alex Griffith

However, few reports of the People’s Progressive Party (PPP) Government or its agents committing arbitrary or unlawful killings during the year assessed were found.
The shooting to death of Adrian Bishop by police while they attempted to arrest him was reported as an accident by police. However, eyewitness accounts reported through the media suggest that the police officer had arbitrarily shot Bishop in the police van.
No politically-motivated disappearances occurred, but there were reports alleging mistreatment of inmates by prison officials, as well as allegations of police abuse of suspects and detainees.
“The Police Complaints Authority (PCA) received 36 complaints of unnecessary use of violence in 2012, the latest year for which data was available. Local media reported several cases of random police brutality, arrest, and interrogation prior to investigation,” the 2014 Report on Human Rights said, citing the case of Colwyn Harding, the baton-raped male, and Police Officer Franz Paul, who allegedly arbitrarily shot Alex Griffith, a 15-year-old, in the mouth.
There were no independent and transparent procedures for handling allegations of abuses by security force members. Prosecutions when followed were extremely lengthy, and convictions rare, leading to a widespread perception that security force members and government officials were enjoying impunity.
LIFE THREATENING
According to the report, “Prison and jail conditions, particularly in police holding cells, were harsh and life threatening. Overcrowding was a severe problem.”
The Guyana Prison Service (GPS) reported that as of 2011 (latest data available) there were 1,962 prisoners in five facilities with a combined design capacity of 1,580.
A total of 997 prisoners were in Georgetown’s Camp Street Prison, which was designed to hold 775 inmates. Overcrowding was in large part due to a backlog of pretrial detainees, who constituted approximately 39 per cent of the total prison population.
Prisoners had access to potable water, and government medical officers visited each prison on a monthly basis.
“In August, authorities found inmate Larry Victor dead in his cell in the Camp Street Prison. The media reported that Victor complained of feeling unwell for two weeks prior to his death, but the prison’s medical professional was absent during all of Victor’s visits to the infirmary,” the report said.
The escape of four female juveniles from the New Opportunity Corps because of allegations of sexual and physical assault at the hands of a senior official was also highlighted by the U.S. Government.
“The management of the New Opportunity Corps and the Ministry of Youth, Culture, and Sports, under which the New Opportunity Corps falls, initially denied the allegations, but a formal investigation into the allegations carried out under the auspices of the Child Care and Protection Agency implicated several staff members of the facility in sexual molestation and physical abuses of juveniles.”
Meanwhile, no information on the adequacy of prison record-keeping or the extent to which authorities used alternatives to sentencing for non-violent offences was available.
ROLE OF THE POLICE AND SECURITY APPARATUS
Inadequate training, poor equipment, and acute budgetary constraints severely limited the Guyana Police Force’s effectiveness, the report noted.
“According to the Caribbean Development Report commissioned by the UN Development Programme, public confidence in the Police Force was very low. There were reports of corruption in the Police Force. In 2011 (latest data available) authorities charged and brought to court 39 GPF members for various crimes, including robbery, simple larceny, bribery, and indecent assault. While Police Force abuses may be reported to the Police Complaints Authority (PCA), the PCA did not possess an independent investigative unit,” the report said.
In 2012, the latest year for available data, the PCA received 700 complaints, 106 of which were sent from the Commissioner of Police.
“Most cited police neglect of duties, unlawful arrest, and unnecessary use of force. The PCA recommended disciplinary action in 70 of those cases and criminal charges in five others. At the end of 2012, there were 91 cases outstanding. Lack of an investigative unit hampered the PCA’s efforts to conduct impartial and transparent assessments of the complaints it received. As of 2013, the PCA had a staff of six full-time positions, and requested an additional position be created to handle statement records. By law, the Police Commissioner must comply with the PCA’s recommendations on complaints, but the PCA relied on the GPF to conduct investigations into complaints against its own officers,” the report noted.
Long delays in receiving reports from the commissioner also thwarted the complaints process.
PRETRIAL DETENTION
Lengthy pretrial detention, due primarily to judicial inefficiency, staff shortages, and cumbersome legal procedures, remained a problem. Pretrial detainees constituted 39 per cent of the prison and detainee population in 2012 (latest data available).
The typical length of pretrial detention ranged from six to 18 months for those awaiting trial at a Magistrate’s Court or in the High Court.
CORRUPTION, LACK OF TRANSPARENCY
Although the law provides for criminal penalties for corruption by officials, the government did not implement the law effectively, and officials sometimes engaged in corrupt practices with impunity, the report said, as there were several reports of government corruption.
“There remained a widespread public perception of corruption involving officials at all levels, including the Police and the judiciary.”
The 2014 Human Rights report noted that the Constitution outlines roles for the Office of the Auditor General, the Public Procurement Commission (PPC), and the Integrity Commission in the area of governmental transparency and accountability.
No PPC, Integrity Commission
“The PPC and the Integrity Commission have not been established. The Office of the Auditor General scrutinises the expenditure of public funds on behalf of parliament and conducts financial audits of all publicly-funded entities, including donor-funded entities, local government agencies, and trade unions, and reports to the National Assembly.”
The effectiveness of the Auditor General’s office, the report added, was limited “since the government may or may not act on the discrepancies noted in its reports.”
“Observers noted that recurring discrepancies repeatedly were highlighted in the reports without officials taking appropriate follow-up actions to investigate and resolve the discrepancies.”
In the case of the PPC, there was significant public criticism of the system’s ineffectiveness in awarding government contracts in an equitable and transparent manner. The PPP administration had said that it would not establish the PPC.
RAPE AND DOMESTIC VIOLENCE
The report noted that the authorities seldom successfully prosecuted rape and domestic violence that were reported to law enforcement officers.
“Based on media reports and commentary, a high incidence of rape and sexual assault was not reflected in official statistics. Many survivors did not report rapes, presumably because of fear of stigma, retribution, or further violence.”
The report said too that “Domestic violence and violence against women, including spousal abuse, was widespread and crossed racial and socioeconomic lines. The law prohibits domestic violence and allows victims to seek prompt protection, occupation, or tenancy orders from a magistrate.”
Accordingly, court records showed that 279 domestic violence cases were filed during 2012, and 143 persons were convicted. Penalties for violation of protection orders include fines up to $10, 000 (US$49.50) and 12 months’ imprisonment.
“Survivors frequently were unwilling to press charges due to a lack of confidence in obtaining a remedy through the courts. Some of those persons preferred to reach a pecuniary settlement out of court. There were reports of Police accepting bribes and other reports of magistrates applying inadequate sentences after conviction. In addition, cases heard involving violation of a protective order tended to be categorised as assault cases,” the report added.
In most cases of domestic violence reports, it was observed that victims were not counseled in private but rather in open spaces at Police stations and the cases were not treated as a matter of urgency.

By Ariana Gordon

 

SHARE THIS ARTICLE :
Facebook
Twitter
WhatsApp
All our printed editions are available online
emblem3
Subscribe to the Guyana Chronicle.
Sign up to receive news and updates.
We respect your privacy.