– High Court rejects opposition leader’s challenge to magistrate’s ruling in cybercrime case
Justice Priscilla Chandra-Hanif has dismissed Azruddin Mohamed’s application for judicial review of the refusal of bail, leaving him remanded in custody following Magistrate Abigail Gibbs’s decision on a cybercrime charge.
The court’s review focused on whether the magistrate had exercised her discretion lawfully, rather than rehearing the bail application. It said pending allegations could inform an assessment of risk if supported by a rational, factual basis, but must not be treated as proof of guilt.
‘A superior court ought not [lightly] to interfere with the exercise of that discretion; the supervisory jurisdiction of this court is not intended to provide an opportunity for the court to substitute its own opinion for that of the judicial officer upon whom statutory discretion has been conferred,’ Chandra-Hanif said during her ruling.
The court’s central question was whether the magistrate had acted within the authority granted by the Bail Act 2022, applied the correct legal principles and based the refusal on a rational and sufficiently grounded assessment of risk. The judge said the applicant had to establish a reviewable error before the High Court could intervene.
Justice Chandra-Hanif considered the balance between an accused person’s right to liberty and the presumption of innocence, and the public interest in preventing further offending and protecting the administration of justice. She said bail proceedings are often heard at an early stage, before a trial or formal evidence-taking, and should not automatically require witnesses to be called or allegations proved through sworn testimony.
But the court also cautioned that practical considerations do not permit unsupported claims to justify detention. A magistrate must have a rational, factual foundation for finding that a statutory ground for refusing bail exists; merely repeating the wording of the Bail Act is not enough.
The judgment drew a distinction between considering pending charges as part of a prospective risk assessment and treating those allegations as proof of guilt. Mohamed remains presumed innocent of the charges unless and until they are proved, the court said. At the same time, properly supported information about the circumstances of other proceedings may be relevant to assessing risk in a bail application.
The judge also distinguished the alleged risk of further offending from the risk of witness intimidation or interference with the administration of justice. She said concerns about interference, if supported by material before the magistrate, may raise a distinct threat to the integrity of criminal proceedings. The absence of a pattern of previous convictions, the court said, is not an absolute bar to refusing bail – but the assessment must be individualised and grounded in the circumstances.
During previous arguments on Tuesday, Attorney-at-Law Roysdale Forde, SC, who represented Mohamed, argued that the magistrate had erred by relying on the existence of other criminal charges without sufficient evidence to establish that his client posed a genuine risk of committing further offences if granted bail.
Forde submitted that the Bail Act requires the prosecution to establish substantial grounds for believing that an accused is likely to commit another offence while on bail, contending that pending charges alone cannot satisfy that requirement.
Attorney General Anil Nandlall, SC, had argued on Tuesday against reviewing the refusal of bail for Mohamed, telling the court that judicial review is not an appeal on the merits of a decision.
The attorney general also adopted submissions previously made by King’s Counsel Darshan Ramdhani, who represents the director of public prosecutions.
Nandlall noted in his submission that the court’s role was limited to determining whether the magistrate acted unlawfully, irrationally or with procedural impropriety.
He argued that refusing bail was an order the magistrate was authorised to make, and said the decision should not be overturned simply because a reviewing judge might have reached a different conclusion.
The High Court found that the magistrate was entitled to consider related pending proceedings when assessing the risk of further offending, while stressing that the allegations remain unproven and do not determine Mohamed’s guilt. It also rejected the challenge to the magistrate’s decision, finding that the applicant had not established grounds for judicial review.
‘The statutory discretion to refuse bail was exercised in accordance with the governing legal principles and upon a rational and legally sufficient foundation… the High Court must therefore accord proper respect to the magistrate’s institutional competence, practical experience, and statutory responsibility in assessing the competing considerations relevant to the liberty of an accused and the administration of justice,’ Justice Chandra-Hanif said.
The judicial-review proceedings were filed by Mohamed’s mother, Bonita Mohamed, challenging the magistrate’s 30 October decision to remand him.
Mohamed was arrested and charged in connection with the alleged unauthorised access to and transfer of footage from the Guyana Police Force’s Safe Country surveillance system.







