Magistrate commences paper committal in MV Barima murder case

 

MAGISTRATE Ravindra Mohabir on Monday commenced paper committal proceedings against three Transport and Harbours Department (T&HD) employees charged with murder following the July 18 MV Barima tragedy, with the prosecution beginning to tender witness statements at the Charity Magistrate’s Court.

The three accused are captain Kevin Price, 40, also known as “KP”, of Melanie Damishana, East Coast Demerara; goods superintendent Delon Granderson, 33, of Fellowship, West Coast Demerara; and chief mate Rondell Dwayne Roberts, 42, of Grove Public Road, East Bank Demerara.

Senior Police Legal Advisor Mandel Moore, who is prosecuting the case, began presenting the documentary evidence before Magistrate Ravindra Mohabir. Police ranks also brought exhibits to court as the proceedings commenced to determine whether the three accused should be committed to stand trial at the High Court.

Among the statements presented by the prosecution were those attributed to Price, Roberts, and Granderson. However, the defence challenged the admissibility of statements made by the accused, resulting in a dispute over the provisions of the Criminal Law Procedure (Paper Committals) Act and the Evidence Act.

The prosecution maintained that it was entitled to tender all statements disclosed to the defence, including those provided by the accused. Moore relied on Section 8 of the Criminal Law Procedure (Paper Committals) Act, arguing that written statements made by “any person” could be admitted once the requirements prescribed by the Act were satisfied.

In support of his position, Moore told the court: “Kevin Price is a person, and his statement, please, Your Worship, satisfy the requirements under the Act. Therefore, please, Your Worship, respectfully, we are saying that the position is that it is admissible.”

He further argued that whether a statement could ultimately be used against the individual who made it was a separate consideration from whether it could be tendered during the committal proceedings.

The defence rejected that interpretation, contending that the prosecution could not automatically introduce statements made by the accused without the court first determining whether they complied with the established rules of evidence.

Dr Dexter Todd, who leads the legal team representing Price and Granderson, questioned the prosecution’s reliance on an ordinary statement from one of the accused in a case where all three men face a joint murder charge.

“The court has to determine what is before it. What is before it? It is a joint charge of murder. And so, the court has to apply the rules in relation to that,” Todd submitted.
Attorney Glenn Hanoman, who appears for chief mate Roberts alongside Everton Singh-Lammy, also disputed the prosecution’s interpretation of the law, submitting that Section 25 of the Criminal Law Procedure (Paper Committals) Act does not supersede the Evidence Act or the established principles governing the admissibility of evidence.

He maintained that the magistrate had a judicial responsibility to examine the statements and determine whether they could properly be received, rather than accept the prosecution’s position that all disclosed statements should be tendered.

Hanoman said, “The purpose of the exercise at this stage, I believe, is for us to go through these statements. Decide what is admissible or not. That’s a judicial function that your worship has to go through.”

Hanoman further cautioned against treating the tendering of every statement disclosed to the defence as an automatic part of the proceedings.

Singh-Lammy also objected to the admissibility of a statement attributed to Roberts, pointing out that his client had been in police custody since July 21, while the document being presented was dated July 22 and did not indicate that he had been cautioned.

The attorney argued that the issue before the magistrate was not the weight to be attached to the statement but whether it satisfied the legal requirements for admission in the first place.

“It is extremely bold of the prosecutor to say that it is admissible. There’s a test that needs to be undertaken by a court for the state of admissibility. So, just on the face of that statement, it is not admissible,” Singh-Lammy submitted.

Moore rejected the defence’s objections, insisting that the law permitted the statements to be introduced during the committal proceedings, while maintaining that any decision on whether they could be used against their makers was a separate matter.

Magistrate Mohabir subsequently advised that the defence could challenge each statement as the prosecution sought to introduce it, with the objections being noted on the court record.
The prosecution then proceeded with other witness statements.

The defence has been given until Thursday to submit its written arguments challenging the admissibility of the ordinary statements provided by the three accused, following which the court will consider the objections.

The hearing was adjourned until Monday, November 23, when proceedings will resume with the further tendering of statements. The three accused were further remanded to prison.

BACKGROUND

The commencement of the proceedings follows an earlier ruling by Magistrate Mohabir rejecting a defence application to halt the criminal case because it was proceeding alongside a government-appointed Commission of Inquiry (CoI) into the disaster.

The defence had argued that conducting the criminal proceedings while the commission was investigating the sinking amounted to an abuse of process. However, the magistrate ruled that the parallel inquiry did not prevent the criminal case from continuing.

The three men were members of the MV Barima’s crew when the vessel sank on July 18, resulting in the deaths of dozens of passengers. They were jointly charged with murder following legal advice from Director of Public Prosecutions (DPP) Shalimar Ali-Hack, SC.

The accused first appeared before Chief Magistrate Judy Latchman at the Georgetown Magistrates’ Courts on July 28.

They were not required to plead to the indictable murder charge and were remanded to prison. The proceedings were subsequently transferred to the Charity Magistrate’s Court.

According to the charge, police alleged that the three men murdered 68 named persons and other persons unknown on July 18, at a location approximately 9.3 nautical miles off the Essequibo Coast near Devonshire Castle.

The allegations arise from the sinking of the MV Barima, an 87-year-old passenger and cargo vessel that was travelling from Georgetown to Port Kaituma in Region One (Barima-Waini).
The vessel departed the T&HD Kingston Goods Wharf in Georgetown at approximately 15:15 hrs on July 18. Later that night, the vessel encountered difficulties while travelling off the Essequibo Coast, near the mouth of the Pomeroon River, before eventually capsizing.
Approximately 179 passengers and crew were believed to have been aboard.

The disaster resulted in 73 deaths, while 76 people survived. Authorities have said approximately 30 people remain unaccounted for.

The incident triggered a large-scale search, rescue and recovery operation involving several state agencies and other responders.

The Guyana Defence Force Coast Guard, Guyana Police Force, Maritime Administration Department (MARAD), Guyana Fire and Rescue Service and Civil Defence Commission were among those involved. Local fishermen, private vessels, and international partners also assisted with the response and recovery effort.

Divers were deployed as part of underwater searches around the wreck, while search teams covered extensive areas in an effort to locate missing persons and recover victims.
The disaster also led to the establishment of a five-member Commission of Inquiry (CoI) by the Government.

The inquiry is tasked with examining, among other things, the circumstances surrounding the sinking, the seaworthiness of the vessel, regulatory oversight, and the emergency response.
It is also expected to make recommendations aimed at strengthening maritime safety and preventing similar tragedies.

The criminal proceedings against the three T&HD employees are continuing independently of the CoI. The DPP has previously indicated that the establishment of the inquiry does not prevent the criminal case from proceeding and that both processes can continue simultaneously.

A further issue arising from the aftermath of the disaster was the condition of members of the vessel’s crew. A day after the sinking, Prime Minister Brigadier (Ret’d) Mark Phillips disclosed that two crew members, including the captain, had tested positive for marijuana.

The Prime Minister subsequently said the accused continue to receive psychosocial support while the criminal proceedings remain ongoing.

SHARE THIS ARTICLE :
Facebook
Twitter
WhatsApp
All our printed editions are available online
emblem3
Subscribe to the Guyana Chronicle.
Sign up to receive news and updates.
We respect your privacy.