President orders fresh appointments to constitutional commissions
President Dr Irfaan Ali
President Dr Irfaan Ali

— Nandlall says independent commissions operate free from gov’t control as terms of three key bodies expire

PRESIDENT Dr Irfaan Ali has ordered the commencement of the process to appoint new members to three key constitutional commissions, whose three-year terms recently expired, Attorney General and Minister of Legal Affairs Anil Nandlall, SC, has announced.
At the same time, Nandlall rejected claims that the Government controls the country’s constitutional commissions and the judiciary, insisting that the bodies operate independently under the Constitution of Guyana. He also accused some commentators of spreading misinformation about the country’s constitutional framework.
During a recent edition of his weekly programme Issues in the News, Nandlall said the terms of the Judicial Service Commission (JSC), Public Service Commission (PSC) and Police Service Commission (PolSC) expired on July 13. As a result, President Dr Irfaan Ali directed that the constitutional process begins for the appointment of new commissions.
The PSC is responsible for appointments, promotions and disciplinary matters involving public servants, while the PolSC oversees similar matters for police officers from the rank of inspector and above, excluding the Commissioner of Police.
Meanwhile, the JSC is responsible for the appointment and discipline of judges, magistrates and Commissioners of Title, except for the Chancellor of the Judiciary and the Chief Justice, whose appointments are governed by separate constitutional provisions.
He explained that while some existing members could ultimately be selected again, the Constitution requires the establishment of entirely new commissions every three years.
Nandlall explained: “The life of a commission lasts for three years as provided for by the Constitution. When those three years finish, or when that time expires, a new commission is appointed.”
According to the Attorney General, the appointment process is governed by the Constitution and involves the participation of the President, the Leader of the Opposition, the National Assembly and representative organisations, depending on the commission concerned.
He said these constitutional arrangements ensure that appointments, promotions and disciplinary matters involving public servants, senior police officers, judges and magistrates remain insulated from political interference.

Attorney General Anil Nandlall, SC

During the programme, Nandlall said the Public Service Commission, Police Service Commission and Judicial Service Commission are independent constitutional bodies with clearly defined responsibilities and that the Executive has no authority to direct how they carry out their functions.
He argued that many members of the public mistakenly blame the Government for decisions that are constitutionally vested in those commissions.
Against this backdrop, Nandlall dismissed claims that the Government exercises control over every arm of the State.
“When they say that we don’t have a democracy in this country and the government controls everything, it’s absolute untruth and crass ignorance,” he declared.
The Attorney General also sought to explain how each commission is constituted.
Using the Police Service Commission as an example, he said several members are nominated through the National Assembly following consultations with organisations representing police officers, while the chairman is appointed by the President after meaningful consultation with the Leader of the Opposition.
Nandlall clarified that the constitutional requirement for “meaningful consultation” does not amount to obtaining the Opposition Leader’s agreement but rather requires genuine engagement before appointments are made where the Constitution so provides.
He also outlined the composition of the Judicial Service Commission. According to him, the Chancellor of the Judiciary, the Chief Justice and the Chairman of the Public Service Commission serve as ex officio members. The remaining members are appointed through constitutional mechanisms involving the President and the National Assembly after consultation with representatives of the legal profession.
Nandlall maintained that Guyana’s constitutional arrangements provide stronger safeguards for institutional independence than many other jurisdictions within the Commonwealth.
“I’ve said repeatedly that our Constitution is more democratic and more advanced than most constitutions in the Commonwealth, including the Commonwealth Caribbean,” he said.
He challenged critics to compare Guyana’s constitutional provisions with those of other Caribbean countries, arguing that Parliament and other independent stakeholders play a significant role in the appointment of members to the commissions.
The Attorney General said he devoted a significant portion of his programme to explaining the constitutional framework because of what he described as persistent misinformation surrounding the country’s legal and political systems.
“I see the level of misinformation and erroneous information being peddled in the public domain about our legal system, about our constitutional structure, about our political system,” he said.
Without identifying anyone by name, Nandlall criticised some academics and commentators, contending that despite their professional credentials, they continue to make inaccurate statements about Guyana’s Constitution, the separation of powers and the operation of constitutional commissions.
He warned that such misinformation could mislead the public and erode confidence in democratic institutions, stressing that public discourse should instead be guided by an accurate understanding of the Constitution and the distinct roles assigned to the Executive and independent constitutional bodies.

 

SHARE THIS ARTICLE :
Facebook
Twitter
WhatsApp
All our printed editions are available online
emblem3
Subscribe to the Guyana Chronicle.
Sign up to receive news and updates.
We respect your privacy.