ACTING Chief Justice Navindra Singh, on Thursday, dismissed applications by the State to strike out legal proceedings brought by relatives of children who died in the 2023 Mahdia Secondary School dormitory fire, paving the way for the matters to proceed to a full hearing.
The cases were initiated by family members of some of the victims, who are pursuing constitutional damages alongside negligence claims.
The State had not filed affidavits in defence but instead applied to have the Fixed Date Applications (FDAs) struck out, arguing that the issues raised had already been settled through compensation agreements signed with the claimants in July 2023.
The Attorney General argued that the claims were barred by settlement agreements entered into after the tragedy, under which each family accepted $5 million in compensation from the State.
In response, the applicants contended that the settlement agreements should not bar the proceedings because they were entered into before the signatories had obtained legal authority to represent the estates of the deceased children.
They also argued that the negotiations were unfair and that they were not afforded the opportunity to obtain independent legal advice before signing the agreements.
In delivering his ruling, the Acting Chief Justice said several substantial legal and factual issues arose from the applications, including whether the individuals who signed the agreements had the legal capacity to settle claims on behalf of the estates of the deceased children and whether any causes of action survived the execution of those agreements.
The court also examined whether the settlements were capable of resolving constitutional claims, as distinct from negligence and wrongful death claims, and whether persons signing in their personal capacities could legally bind themselves in their later roles as administrators of the estates.
After reviewing the applications and the issues raised, Justice Singh concluded that the matters involved significant questions that could not be determined solely on the basis of the settlement agreements.

As a result, he refused the State’s applications to strike out the proceedings and ordered that both matters be converted into claims.
While declining to dismiss the lawsuits, the Acting Chief Justice noted that the settlement agreements remain relevant and may provide the State with a substantive defence as the matters progress.
In refusing the State’s strike-out applications, Acting Chief Justice Singh ordered that the matters be converted into civil claims, allowing the parties to fully litigate the disputed issues through the filing of Statements of Claim (SoCs) and defences.
The cases will next come up for a Case Management Conference (CMC) in November 2026.
Attorney-at-law Darren Wade is representing the applicants.
The ruling stems from a legal challenge brought by relatives of victims of the devastating Mahdia Secondary School dormitory fire, which occurred in May 2023 and claimed the lives of 20 children.
The challenge focuses on compensation agreements signed between the State and families of 13 girls who died in the blaze. Compensation was paid and accepted under those agreements, but the applicants are now seeking to challenge their validity.
The families contended that the agreements were signed under duress and without independent legal advice.
They argued that the circumstances surrounding the signing of the agreements, particularly involving Indigenous families from hinterland communities, were coercive and raise constitutional concerns.
Their claims also alleged negligence and wrongful death, contending that failures in the duty of care contributed to the deaths of the children.
The State has maintained that the agreements are legally binding, arguing that compensation was offered and accepted and that there is no legal basis for setting aside the settlements. It has also argued that allegations of duress have not been sufficiently established.
The fatal dormitory fire was allegedly set by a student following the confiscation of a mobile phone. The teenager was subsequently charged as an adult with 20 counts of murder and remains before the High Court awaiting trial.
The 20 victims of the 2023 Mahdia Secondary School girls’ dormitory fire ranged in age from five to 18 years old.
Those who lost their lives in the tragedy were Subrina John, Belnisa Evans, Loreen Evans, Bibi Rita Jeffrey, Lisa Roberts, Tracil Thomas, Delecia Edwards, Lorita Williams, Natalie Bellarmine, Arianna Edwards, Cleoma Simon and Martha Dandrade.
The other victims were Mary Dandrade, Omerfia Edwin, Nickleen Robinson, Sherlyn Bellarmine, Eulander Carter, Andrea Roberts, Sherana Daniels and Adanye Jerome.







