AG defends extradition advice given to Home Affairs Minister
Attorney General Anil Nandlall, SC
Attorney General Anil Nandlall, SC

–rejects bias claims at CCJ, outlines Mohameds ‘rap sheet’ of international indictments
–regional court to deliver decision ‘as soon as is reasonably practicable’

ATTORNEY General and Legal Affairs Minister, Anil Nandlall, SC, on Tuesday defended the legality and fairness of advice he provided to Minister of Home Affairs Oneidge Walrond in extradition proceedings involving United States-sanctioned businessmen, Opposition Leader Azruddin Mohamed and his father, Nazar Mohamed.
He also rejected allegations that his public statements concerning them amounted to bias against them while making submissions before the Caribbean Court of Justice (CCJ).
The submissions were made in ongoing extradition proceedings concerning the pair, who face an 11-count US indictment including conspiracy, fraud, and money laundering, following a request by the United States for their extradition from Guyana.
The case has moved through the issuance of an Authority to Proceed (ATP), the granting of arrest warrants, and ongoing committal proceedings, alongside unsuccessful judicial review challenges. The judicial review matters are now before the CCJ for a final determination.
The Mohameds are challenging the validity of the ATP, arguing that Minister Walrond should not have issued it and ought to have delegated the power to another public officer, on the basis that she was affected by political bias, given that Azruddin is her political opponent.
They further claimed that the process was affected by the Attorney General’s legal advice and public statements concerning them.
Appearing before the apex court, Nandlall stressed that the ATP function, carried out by Minister Walrond, is a special gateway administrative function.
In setting the stage for his presentation, the Attorney General referred to his role as legal adviser to the Government of Guyana under Article 112 of the Constitution of Guyana.
He told the court that he was not arguing that the ATP is not reviewable by a court of law, adding that this point had already been conceded, while asking on what grounds it is reviewable.
Nandlall said the court must consider the “peculiar nature” of the ATP function, arguing that established authorities confirm that certain principles of fairness do not apply in the same way.
The Attorney General also pointed to Guyana’s longstanding position on international treaty obligations and extradition practice, stating that requests have historically been granted once statutory requirements are met.
“As a country, Guyana has taken a position since independence in relation to treaty obligations… and as a matter of policy, once the statutory criteria have been satisfied, requests have been consistently granted,” he told the bench of seven judges.
He related that his function is to advise the government and ministers on legal matters.
“In this particular case, two matters came… one was in relation to what is the position in relation to our extradition treaty and its provisions regarding extradition to a third state… and the second issue had to do with whether the form was filled out properly,” he said.
Nandlall added that in relation to the first issue, advice was given due to conflicting legal authorities on extradition law, referencing prior case law, while the second matter related to procedural compliance.
However, he clarified: “I don’t want to advise the minister… in this particular case, that [advice] was not requested.”
Another aspect the hearing was whether Nandlall’s public commentary during ongoing extradition proceedings created a perception of bias.
One judge, Chile Eboe-Osuji said that the Attorney General may have “cast criminal aspersions” and made comments suggesting a view on the outcome of the case, including remarks about Principal Magistrate Judy Latchman’s handling of the committal proceedings.
Justice Arif Bulkan added that the issue was not general political commentary but whether statements directly relating to the extradition process compromised fairness.
“It’s not just about political rivalry in the air… but concerning specifically the subject of this case,” the judge said.
The Attorney General rejected the allegation that he had prejudged the matter.
“I can’t recall ever projecting the outcome,” he said, adding: “What I have said… I have spoken about the extradition proceedings, and I’ve expressed concerns about the time that it was taking.”
He also said that information he referenced was already in the public domain, including sanctions and international reports.
RAP SHEET
In a more contentious exchange, Nandlall referred to a series of allegations involving the Mohamed family, which he described as part of a widely reported public record.
He told the court there were “indications in the public domain” including Office of Foreign Assets Control (OFAC) sanctions and a report identifying Azruddin and Nazar in connection with investigations by United States agencies.
“You had the fact that there was a Reuters special report… that identified them,” he said, referring to claims involving investigations by the Drug Enforcement Administration (DEA), Federal Bureau of Investigations (FBI) and Department of Homeland Security (DHS).
Nandlall added that the report referenced suspicions of “smuggling Colombian cocaine and illegally mined Venezuelan gold,” as well as allegations of money laundering involving sanctioned individuals.
“This is what we have to speak about,” he said, adding: “This is their rap sheet.”
The court also engaged the Attorney General on the appropriate legal test for bias in administrative decisions.
He accepted that the decision in question is subject to judicial review but argued that bias must be assessed in context.
“If the test applies, bias is not a factor,” he said, noting “Did the minister act fairly? Did she follow the statutory conditionalities? Was she influenced by something irrelevant?”
When pressed on the correct legal standard by Justice Peter Jamadar, Nandlall accepted that the Porter v Magill test applies, describing it as the view of a “reasonable, well-informed observer,” but maintained that context must be considered.
He also relied on earlier authorities, including the Privy Council’s decision in Warner, to argue that the ATP function is administrative and does not attract full natural justice protections.
CCJ President, Justice Winston Anderson, however, questioned whether Nandlall’s dual role as chief legal adviser and political figure required greater caution in public commentary.
He noted the need to distinguish between statements made by ordinary ministers and those made by the Attorney General.
“There is a difference between other ministers making statements and the Honorable Attorney General… making statements,” the judge observed, questioning whether such commentary was appropriate during ongoing proceedings.
The judge added: “We are just wondering whether the Attorney General making those kinds of statements, which the appellants refer to, is the best practice for the kind of society and democracy that we seek to encourage in Guyana.”
The Attorney General maintained that no improper statements were made and insisted that all comments were within the bounds of lawful public discourse.
After hearing extensive arguments from each party, the judges took a brief recess to confer before returning to announce that the court was reserving its decision. Justice Anderson said the court will deliver its decision “as soon as is reasonably practicable.”
Meanwhile, the CCJ President noted that a stay previously granted by the court suspending the committal proceedings remains in effect pending the decision.

SHARE THIS ARTICLE :
Facebook
Twitter
WhatsApp
All our printed editions are available online
emblem3
Subscribe to the Guyana Chronicle.
Sign up to receive news and updates.
We respect your privacy.