Magistrate McGusty dismisses Brutus’ Abuse of Process application – SOCU
Former Assistant Commissioner of Police, Calvin Brutus
Former Assistant Commissioner of Police, Calvin Brutus

ACTING Chief Magistrate Faith McGusty on Thursday dismissed former Assistant Commissioner of Police (Administration), Calvin Brutus’ Abuse of Process

Application on the basis that the extant fraud charges, when compared to the

previously determined disciplinary charges were different in scope, nature, and penalty.

 

This disclosure was made by the Special, Organised Crime Unit (SOCU). In a press release, the SOCU also stated that the court found that Brutus’s application Abuse of Process Application must fail.

 

In October and November 2024, Brutus was charged with 252 counts of criminal offences relating to money laundering, fraud, and other serious, related financial crimes, which are extant

and ongoing in the Georgetown Magistrates’ Court.

 

On December 4, 2025, the defence filed an application seeking orders of the Magistrates’ Court for the joinder of various categories of fraud charges against Brutus and for the consolidation of several offences into single omnibus counts.

 

SOCU said that the prosecution contended that it was not averse to the joinder of several offences, where it is justified by law and promotes the fair and efficient administration of justice.

 

On January 22, 2026, Brutus filed another interim application seeking an order of the

Magistrates’ Court to stay certain fraud charges on the ground of abuse of process.

 

“The defence submitted that the criminal fraud charges amounted to an abuse of process since the said charges were premised on the same facts which were the subject of two disciplinary charges instituted against Mr Brutus pursuant to Section 4(z) of the Page 1 of 2

Police (Discipline) Act, Cap 17:01, and which resulted in his subsequent dismissal

from the Guyana Police Force.

 

“The prosecution, however, argued that though the Honourable Court was undoubtedly

possessed an inherent jurisdiction to protect its process from abuse by granting a stay,

the power of the magistrate to stay proceedings for abuse of process should be utilised

sparingly and that, in any event, the current circumstances did not warrant the court

exercising its discretion since it is trite law that disciplinary proceedings do not, without

more, bar the institution or continuation of criminal charges as they are administrative in

nature, while criminal charges are in persona, against the State.

 

“The prosecution argued that the two processes were distinct in nature, purpose, and consequence, and their concurrent or sequential operation is fully consistent with Guyana’s statutory and constitutional framework.  With this, the prosecution reasoned that Mr Brutus’s application does not meet the high legal threshold required to invoke the Court’s inherent jurisdiction and that the continuation of the present proceedings would neither undermine fairness nor bring the administration of justice into disrepute.

 

“Essentially, the prosecution argued that the defence had failed to establish any real

prejudice, oppression, or abuse of process on the part of the prosecution in instituting the

extant criminal charges and that the said abuse of process application was ill-founded,

misconceived, unmeritorious, and ought to be dismissed in its entirety. The court,

accordingly, agreed with the Prosecution and dismissed Brutus’s Abuse of Process

Application,” SOCU said.

 

The release added that on Thursday, Magistrate McGusty ruled that the two counts of

money laundering laid indictably against Brutus and his wife, Adonika Aulder, will

proceed indictably via paper committal.

 

The prosecution is being represented by Prosecutors and Attorneys-at-Law, David Brathwaite, Darin Chan, Muntaz Ali, and Natasha Backer, while the defence is represented by Attorneys-at-Law, Eusi Anderson, Yuborn Allicock, and Earl Daniels, among others.

 

SHARE THIS ARTICLE :
Facebook
Twitter
WhatsApp
All our printed editions are available online
emblem3
Subscribe to the Guyana Chronicle.
Sign up to receive news and updates.
We respect your privacy.