Acting Chief Magistrate Faith McGusty has dismissed an abuse of process application filed by former Assistant Commissioner of Police (Administration), Calvin Brutus, clearing the way for criminal fraud and money laundering charges against him to continue before the Georgetown Magistrates’ Court.
In her ruling delivered on March 19, 2026, Magistrate McGusty found that the criminal charges currently before the court are fundamentally different from the disciplinary proceedings that led to Brutus’ dismissal from the Guyana Police Force.
According to a release from Special Organised Crime Unit (SOCU), the court held that the matters differed “in scope, nature, and penalty” and as such, the application “must fail.”
Brutus is currently facing 252 criminal charges linked to alleged money laundering, fraud, and other financial crimes, which were instituted in October and November 2024 and remain ongoing.
The abuse of process application, filed by the defence in January 2026, argued that the criminal charges were based on the same facts that had already been addressed through disciplinary proceedings under the Police (Discipline) Act, which resulted in his dismissal from the Force.
However, prosecutors rejected that position, maintaining that disciplinary and criminal proceedings serve different legal purposes and can lawfully run concurrently or sequentially.
SOCU stated that the prosecution argued the court’s power to stay proceedings “should be utilised sparingly” and that the circumstances did not meet the threshold required to justify such an intervention.
Further, it was contended that disciplinary matters are administrative in nature, while criminal proceedings are brought against the State, making the two processes legally distinct.
“The two processes were distinct in nature, purpose, and consequence, and their concurrent or sequential operation is fully consistent with Guyana’s statutory and constitutional framework,” the release noted.
Prosecutors also argued that the defence failed to demonstrate any real prejudice or oppression arising from the continuation of the criminal proceedings, describing the application as “ill-founded, misconceived, unmeritorious.”
The court ultimately agreed, dismissing the application in its entirety.
In a further development on March 26, 2026, Magistrate McGusty ruled that two indictable counts of money laundering against Brutus and his wife, Adonika Aulder, will proceed via paper committal.
The prosecution team includes attorneys-at-law David Brathwaite, Darin Chan, Muntaz Ali, and Natasha Backer, while Brutus is represented by attorneys Eusi Anderson, Yuborn Allicock, Earl Daniels, among others.
The case continues.







