I CANNOT believe how the world I grew up in as a student at UG disappeared so quickly. Where did that world go? I quote from the second-to-last editorial of the now defunct Stabroek News (SN). This was the last fling of imperialist political theory of SN before its demise.
Here is what SN wrote the day before it went out of existence: “Democratic governance, in its fullest philosophical sense, requires more than elections and constitutional procedures. It demands a culture of participation, where citizens and communities feel that their voices matter in shaping national development. Yet, perceptions are growing that the current political climate offers little room for genuine inclusion. Consultative processes are often limited, contrarian perspectives are treated with hostility, and the distance between decision-makers and ordinary citizens widens rather than narrows.”
Here is what one of Guyana’s most accomplished intellectuals known in the Caribbean and in the global academic world wrote to me about that editorial. I have redacted the name of the country because he did not want to be quoted. He emailed me with these words: “What idealistic utopian nonsense! I live in (redacted), the Government of the (redacted) don’t give a damn for my opinion. Unless we riot. Only at Election Time do politicians push manifesto through my door!”
Now here is the part that will make you laugh, but it should make you sad to see how the political spirit and intellectual vision of the Guyana I belonged to in the 1970s have disappeared. Both owners of the now defunct SN – Isabelle DeCaires and Brendan DeCaires – know this man personally and respect his talent. Every middle class, Mulatto/Creole intellectual that deluged SN with sycophantic praise of the democratic credentials of SN either knows this man personally or respect his intellectual ability. He is an iconic citizen of Guyana.
If he was willing to be identified then because of his iconic status, he would have been able to instill in younger Guyanese just how imperialist narratives live on in Guyana and the vehicles through which they thrive. I spoke with him again for permission to name him. He said he will state his name after he reworded his outline. I suggested he not do so because the potency of his brief exclamation will be lost.
For decades SN has been the main vehicle, and the only vehicle for saturating Guyana with Western political theory handed down by the colonials and broadly accepted by not only the country’s academic society but people in the colony in general. These political theories were designed to play with the mind of the colonial subject – to make us think Western practice of politics was democratically superior to the rest of the world.
In the 1970s, a generation of iconoclastic scholars not only in the post-colonial world but in Europe began to dismantle the misleading political theories imperialist empires forced down the throats of the non-White worlds. In Europe, you had the Frankfurt School of Philosophy of which two names stood out – Herbert Marcuse and Jurgen Habermas. The latter died last week at 93.
In the UK, a penetratingly influential left-wing journal was born titled New Left Review. Together with another journal named Third World Quarterly, they literally demolished the traditional Western approach to politics and economics that post-colonial people had to live with. There were some outstanding individual scholars like Nicos Poulantez from Greece and Louis Althusser in France that adumbrated a new perspective on liberal, bourgeois society.
In the post-colonial world, there was Dependency Theory that literally took over the Economic Departments of global academia. The West Indies produced two fantastic dependency theorists, Clive Thomas in Guyana and Norman Girvan in Jamaica.
One can date the 1970s as the period in which traditional Western approach to understanding how democracy works was brilliantly attacked and rubbished. Today, very few Third World sociologists have any respect for something called Liberal Democratic Society. There is no such process in any Western country. The only set of people who believe in this deception was SN in Guyana.
I need to mention that I was fortunate to have as a classmate at the University of Toronto, a Jamaican philosophy student, Charles Mills (deceased) that has written perhaps the best philosophy book of the 20th century – “the Racial Contract.” This book is brilliant stuff that exposes the pseudo-political theory that Western imperialism forced upon us.
For decades, Stabroek News has literally been the ubiquitous platform, especially through its daily column titled, Project Syndicate, for keeping alive what Charles Mills has exposed as brain-washing. I am not finished with what SN did to young minds in this country. This once great newspaper became a neocolonial servant of a dying imperialism. Those who cannot see that are morally unfit people.
DISCLAIMER: The views and opinions expressed in this column are solely those of the author and do not necessarily reflect the official policy or position of the Guyana National Newspapers Limited.








