IN part 2, I ended with these words: “In part 3, I explain why the people I so admired supported rigged election in 2020. Class and race are the answers.” Here is the analysis. The tampering with the 2020 election results is the largest assault on a national election in the history of Guyana.
People who struggled for free and fair elections went into self-destruction mode in March 2020. Great friendships were shattered when comrades who stayed in an enduring friendship over decades took different positions on the election. But there was only one position to have been taken – the denunciation of rigged elections and its Macbethian consequence of permanent power.
There were three broad categories of support for the five months of conspiracies to reshape the election results to keep APNU+AFC coalition in government. A caveat is in order at this point. This has to be a very abbreviated analysis because the material cannot fit into one column. The first sector was the intellectuals in the WPA. Rupert Roopnaraine, Moses Bhagwan and Eusi Kwayana were driven by overpowering Freudian instincts against the PPP.
Each of these individuals harboured a long resentment of Cheddi Jagan. Although Jagan was not leading the PPP in 2020, for these three gentlemen, a victory of the PPP was a victory for Jagan. Kwayana hated Jagan. Bhagwan hated Jagan, and Roopnaraine was contemptuous of Jagan as an Indian leader whom he felt was culturally inferior to lead a Mulatto/Creole Caribbean country. Roopnaraine felt he was better suited to lead Guyana after Walter Rodney died.
These three individuals, along with a few others like Clive Thomas, Maurice Odle, Desmond Trotman, Bonita Bone, Joycelyn Dow, among others, did not want the return of the PPP to power. They felt history had moved decisively in 2015 and had swept the PPP out of Guyana’s life. The election results favouring the PPP in 2020 were too much of a mental burden for these people.
The second category involved the entitlement school. These were Afrocentric personalities from the WPA like David Hinds, Tacuma Ogunseye, ACDA, and others in that same vein. Their position on Guyana is that African people came here as slaves and saved Guyana and thus are entitled to own the state after the colonials left.
At this point, the relevance of an incident involving Deputy Vice-Chancellor of UG, Melissa Ifill is extremely relevant. It shows vividly how this category sees Guyana. Dr Ifill, Leonard Craig, and a number of us became close friends after we founded a grassroot movement named People’s Parliament which came out of the Linden shooting incident in 2012.
During the 2020 election disaster, Dr Ifill wrote that in life she sees herself firstly as a Black woman, and her thoughts in life stem from that instinct. Had I known this was the way Dr Ifill thought of herself, I would never have cultivated a friendship with her. In the People’s Parliament, I thought we were all activists in search of people’s liberation, and we saw life through the lens of human liberators.
They rejected the continuous electoral success of the PPP since 1992. The 2015 victory of the PNC, they saw as the overjoyful moment where Guyanese history had recognised the entitlement claim. There was no way these people were prepared to let the PPP rule again after 2020.
The third group that gave support to the attempt to derail the election came from the Mulatto/Creole class (MCC). This school included the Guyana Human Rights Association, Red Thread, MCC elements in the WPA and Alliance For Change, Guyana chapter of Transparency Institute, certain women’s groups, and the Stabroek News (don’t be fooled, yes, the Stabroek News) among others. There are so many famous names in this ensemble, but I think Guyanese know who they are. This entire group of MCC personalities is against oil production because it brings immense political capital to the PPP.
The return to power by the PPP was a deeply traumatising moment for the MCC. This class in Guyana’s social structure despised the PPP historically. The contempt sprung from eugenics, cultural superiority, and anthropological perceptions. The MCC never accepted the PPP as part of the claim to power before and after colonialism. Their position was extremely simple to understand. It argued and continues to argue that Indians in Guyana are not culturally suited to politics and should remain in business.
The MCC was betrayed by Forbes Burnham, whom they trusted. They founded the WPA and the AFC. They felt that the APNU+AFC in government was the eventual vindication of the MCC, and the thought of the PPP returning to power was a personal nightmare for each member of the MCC. Part 4 is coming up.
DISCLAIMER: The views and opinions expressed in this column are solely those of the author and do not necessarily reflect the official policy or position of the Guyana National Newspapers Limited.








