The Government’s decision to retain international legal counsel in high-profile extradition matters is consistent with established international practice and has been endorsed by respected regional legal experts.
Extradition proceedings, particularly those involving cross-border financial crimes, sanctions regimes, or complex treaty obligations, are rarely routine.
Regional legal authorities say that this is in line with established Caribbean practice and treaty obligations that govern cross-border justice.
Senior Caribbean lawyers and extradition law experts say that hiring foreign lawyers for complicated international cases is seen as a protection rather than an unnecessary cost, especially when the cases involve more than one jurisdiction and diplomatic issues.
Political commentators, such as WIN parliamentarian and party General Secretary Odessa Primus on her Facebook page, have criticised the State’s spending on legal teams in cases involving businessmen Nazar Mohamed and Azruddin Mohamed.
Legal experts say that extradition cases are very different from regular criminal trials in that lawyers work at the crossroads of international treaties, foreign evidentiary standards, diplomatic relations, and domestic law.
This requires knowledge that is not always available in one place.
Attorney General Anil Nandlall has publicly said that hiring foreign lawyers was meant to make the proceedings more credible and independent, lowering the risk of claims of political interference, which is a common concern in politically sensitive extradition cases.
Legal sources said that perception is very important in extradition law. Courts in requesting states must be sure that defendants’ rights are protected and that the proceedings are fair.
They say that having independent regional counsel can help people trust the process more.
The prosecuting legal team from the Caribbean includes Jamaican King’s Counsel Terrence F. Williams, attorneys Herbert McKenzie and Celine Deidrick, and Trinidadian Senior Counsel Douglas Mendes.
Legal experts in the region say that these kinds of agreements are common when national courts have to deal with constitutional and human rights issues that cross borders or interpret extradition treaties.
EXTRADITION CASES WORLDWIDE
Governments in the Caribbean Community (CARICOM) have used foreign King’s Counsel many times to help them with complicated constitutional and extradition cases.
One of the most well-known cases happened in Trinidad and Tobago, involving former FIFA vice-president Jack Warner.
A large international legal team, including British barristers James Lewis and Robert Strang, was retained by the government to prosecute Warner.
Reports from the region said that between 15 and 18 lawyers were involved at different points in the case, which shows the complex nature of such cases, involving treaties and constitutional issues.
Similarly, outside of the Caribbean region, extradition cases have featured foreign lawyers representing the prosecution. The long extradition fight in UK courts over WikiLeaks founder Julian Assange drew teams of international human rights and constitutional lawyers who represented both British and American legal interests.
In Canada, Huawei executive Meng Wanzhou fought extradition to the United States with the help of well-known multinational lawyers.
The courts looked at sanctions law, diplomatic issues, and treaty obligations.
Other cases show that this is the norm around the world. Shrien Dewani, a British businessman, fought extradition from the UK to South Africa.
There, lawyers from different countries argued about protections and fair trial guarantees.
At the same time, internet entrepreneur Kim Dotcom fought extradition from New Zealand, with lawyers from different countries arguing about cybercrime jurisdiction and digital evidence standards.
When it comes to extradition, legal cooperation often goes both ways. The case of Marcus Bisram showed how legal representation across borders secured Guyana’s interests in other countries, showing that international justice systems are based on mutual respect.
Lawyers say these examples show that the need for foreign lawyers in extradition cases is less about politics and more about the technical needs of the case.
Shared responsibility in cross-border justice extradition cooperation often works both ways.
The stakes are very high in the Mohamed case because U.S. officials say he was involved in a multimillion-dollar gold smuggling, tax evasion, and wire fraud scheme.
Legal experts say that mistakes in the process could make Guyana vulnerable to claims that it didn’t live up to its treaty obligations.
One legal source in the region said, “Extradition is not optional litigation.”
“States have to follow the rules of treaties, and cases have to go through a lot of courts, sometimes even international ones,” the expert shared.
Other legal experts say that in the Caribbean region, cases with too few resources often fall apart after long arguments, causing much more damage to the public purse and reputational damage that outstrips the cost of hiring lawyers who specializes in extradition cases.
In that light, Guyana’s approach is in line with established practice in the region.
Legal experts say that the most important thing for the government to do is to make sure that fairness, credibility, and compliance with international law are all upheld, even if that means seeking foreign assistance.







