Berkley Wendell Semple
Eltonsbrody (Secker and Warburg, 1960) is the eleventh novel by the distinguished Guyanese writer Edgar Mittelholzer. It stands as a literary horror classic in the vein of his better-known ghost story, My Bones and My Flute, a haunting and deeply unsettling tale. In that earlier novel, suspense is heightened by an oppressive Gothic atmosphere: creeping shadows, sudden darkness, inexplicable nocturnal sounds, and flute music without a visible flautist. Mittelholzer masterfully compresses these elements within tight parentheses of mystery and dread.
Eltonsbrody is brewed from a similar metemgee of Gothic ingredients. It is a macabre tale. At its centre stands one of Mittelholzer’s most grotesque and unforgettable creations: the death-obsessed Mrs Scaife, a matron saint of morbidity who takes mordant pleasure in the demise of others. She is a chilling presence, a character whose relish for death borders on the devotional.
The novel teems with strange figures, not least among them the unfortunate Malverne, an unapologetic exhibitionist who displays her perfect breasts to nearly everyone she encounters. Malverne serves as maid at Eltonsbrody, a large Barbados house presided over by the aforementioned harridan, Mrs Scaife. She is the widow of Dr Scaife—repeatedly described as “very ugly”, as though that single trait exhausts his identity. Mrs Scaife rules the house with a malevolent will. She has a son and grandson living in Bridgetown, the capital, though she harbours no affection for her son. Indeed, she would prefer him dead. She would prefer many people dead. When death does not arrive naturally, she conspires with a former servant, the sinister Borcham, to hasten its coming. Mrs Scaife has a philosophy of death that is quaint and underlies her violent tendencies.
Mittelholzer employs here a device that served him well in the acerbic and darkly comic Shadow Moves Among Them: the introduction of an English outsider into a Caribbean setting. In Eltonsbrody, that outsider is Woodsley, a painter and tenant of sorts at the house, who recounts the bizarre and increasingly horrifying events he witnesses. The novel is fiercely suspenseful and, at times, difficult to endure. Blood flows freely; there is a shocking death and a grisly dismemberment. The narrative occasionally veers towards excess, mirroring the extremity of its characters, yet it remains gripping entertainment—rich in mystery and propelled by mounting tension. Mittelholzer’s descriptions of the natural world are especially vivid. His island landscapes shimmer with metaphoric intensity; the environment feels mesmeric, lush, and faintly menacing. The story moves at breakneck speed towards a conclusion that is both dramatic and satisfying.
Yet an unfortunate aspect of Mittelholzer’s substantial oeuvre cannot be ignored: a palpable Negrophobia which, if expressed by a white writer, would likely be labelled racism. Black characters in his novels are frequently portrayed as ugly, ignorant, foolish, or—like Malverne in Eltonsbrody—hypersexualised. This tendency is troubling, particularly given Mittelholzer’s own racial background (though he resisted such designations). In his author biographies, his appearance or heritage is sometimes referenced in ways that seem unnecessary, as though to position him uneasily in relation to blackness itself.
This strain of racial discomfort is accompanied by an incipient colourism that mars some of his finest work. Characters are rarely described without reference to race and complexion, markers that in Mittelholzer’s fictional universe often double as indicators of class and worth. The pattern appears as early as Corentyne Thunder, his first published novel, and becomes especially pronounced in A Morning at the Office. In the opening volume of the Kaywana Trilogy, the suggestion that slave revolts were motivated by a desire for white women is particularly dismaying. Such moments of black contempt jar the modern reader. Moreover, the satirical “put-downs” often rely on a vocabulary and tonal register aligned with colonial sensibilities. In this, Mittelholzer occasionally resembles V. S. Naipaul, whose work can display a similarly uneasy, sometimes scathing, attitude towards blackness—an irony sharpened by their shared colonial inheritances.
Elements of this tendency appear in Eltonsbrody. Dr Scaife’s repeated reduction to “ugliness” diminishes him to a caricature. Malverne, too, remains insubstantial—a paper-thin figure whose exhibitionism is unexplored and whose purpose seems limited to comic spectacle before she is rendered broken and mute. Such portrayals weaken what is otherwise a compelling Gothic narrative.
Despite these flaws, Eltonsbrody remains a thrilling and fast-paced novel. It is dark, disturbing, and compulsively readable—another testament to Mittelholzer’s formidable storytelling power, even as it reveals the troubling contradictions embedded within his imaginative world.








