I WAS looking at an interview David Hinds did on his show with Gerald Perreira as his guest. He told Gerald that at the airport, an East Indian man approached him and though the man admitted he was a PPP he told David he loves him. David went on to say how he meets Indian people who show appreciation for his politics.
The question is not the veracity of David; why should we doubt him? The pertinent question here is whether David accepts that just as Indians show appreciation for him, African Guyanese admire and love Indian leaders in the PPP. Does he accept that African Guyanese in discernible numbers approach Indian ministers and openly embrace them?
If Indian people could display mental comfort with David why then was David fuming when Priya Manickchand went into Tiger Bay? He got on his programme and told Minister Manickchand to get out of Tiger Bay and go into an Indian area to test her presidential ambition.
If David meets Indian people who admire him, then does he agree that there are substantial numbers of African Guyanese who love President Ali? He has to agree because the logic is simply compelling. Hinds then jumped into a vortex of contradictions when he put his next question to Gerald. He rejects the theory that African Guyanese voted for an Indian man – Azruddin Mohamed.
Here laid bare before the eyes of the nation is the convenient politics of those that criticise the government every minute of the day. Hinds can tell Guyanese that Indians see him in a positive way, but he is not prepared to accept that African people chose two Indian leaders to vote for – President Ali and Mohamed.
My theory is that Mohamed is an ephemeral decimal. WIN will follow in the footstep of three famous men who entered politics, got an extensive welcome then faded – Raphael Trotman, Khemraj Ramjattan and Nigel Hughes. But whether we like or hate Mohamed, the political facts on September 1 were gargantuan – African people located in African areas voted for a rich Muslim, East Indian.
In theorising about Mohamed, we must keep in mind what Vice-President Jagdeo said – there were PNC supporters that didn’t want to vote for the PPP but they didn’t want to vote for the PNC either. Those African voters rejected an African woman – Amanza Walton-Desir; an African lawyer – Nigel Hughes; and a well-known African politician – Aubrey Norton. They gave 109,066 votes to a party dominated by an Indian man whose presence in his party took the form of a one-man show.
One can argue that African Guyanese chose WIN because it has some high-profile African names that have extensive credibility thus Mohamed was just another face. But WIN did not feature any huge African names in Guyana’s political economy and sociology that one can say was the reason why African people embraced WIN
Roysdale Forde, Amanza Walton-Desir, Joe Harmon, Carl Greenidge, Winston Jordan, Former Police Chief and PNC Minister, Winston Felix, former GDF head, Gary Best, Volda Lawrence former security adviser to President Granger, Eddie Collins who once headed the arm, well-known PNC city lawyer, Darren Wade, and famous African Lindener Vaness Kissoon did not join WIN. The enduring African personalities in Guyanese politics and social world kept their distance from WIN.
Now it would have been a reasonable conclusion to make that African Guyanese dumped the PNC for a party that had some prodigious African minds. Because of those faces, the inescapable analysis was that African voters chose another African party than the PNC.
But WIN attracted no such talent. WIN had a very wealthy Indian man that WIN promoted and no one else. And even if WIN wanted to promote two other leaders there were none to promote. The definitive analysis is that traditional PNC aficionados or die-in-the wool PNC hardliners voted for an Indian Muslim man.
Why David Hinds cannot accept that is because on the other side of the coin lies African rejection of him. Hinds, if he stays around to the 2030 election, will, continue to yell out from the rooftop that in voting for WIN on September 1, 2025, Africans did not choose for an Indian man.
The PNC leaders will go at bottom house meetings and tell the attendants that on September 1, 2025, Africans did not vote for an Indian man; they voted for a party named WIN and that was different from voting for an Indian man. They cannot admit to the reality that hit them on September 1, 2025 because it would be an acknowledgement that they were rejected by African Guyanese in large numbers.
DISCLAIMER: The views and opinions expressed in this column are solely those of the author and do not necessarily reflect the official policy or position of the Guyana National Newspapers Limited.








