KINDLY permit me a space in your newspaper to ask a few questions which I think we need to answer, first to ourselves before we continue willy-nilly on the subject of ‘Race’.
There is the popular adage, “if you don’t use it you will lose it” which may be relevant to the discourse here. In Guyana everyone think they know that we have a racial problem but it is impossible to get a clear definition of what constitutes a ‘race’. Let us begin with the question; what is the meaning of race? Why do Social Scientists, journalists, political commentators and even politicians in Guyana employ the use of the word ‘race’, when scientists-physiologists, anatomists, biologists, physical anthropologists and geneticists have long concluded that the word has no scientific basis for its usage?
What nomenclature or classification, do we use to define someone’s racial category? Is it based on their genotype (genetic make-up) or is it their phenotypic construct (features/looks)? Are all those individuals with brown skin and long straight hair “Indians” and all dark skinned people with curly hair are “Africans”?
Having lived in West Africa for seven years and travelled through most of the continent the phenotypic variation within the population is extremely diverse and by no means unified or homogeneous, while the cultural differences are even far more complex. In India, the phenotypic characteristics are even more diverse-with the “African” features among the Andaman Islanders in the South, “Mongol” features in Assam in the North East and a vast array of shades and features in between. Are our Indian and African features the basis for our identity and the basis for classification?
If so GOOD, but certainly that is not our “racial” type. Or, is it? For if it is, then our classificatory scheme in the world would run in the thousands.
Racial classification from the very onset – beginning with the Europeans -has been flawed. It served a political purpose during the early years of contact, the enslaving period, the colonizing period and thereafter. In the reading of U.S. history we become all too familiar with Jim Crowism. If the concept race and its dehumanizing tendencies has been a flawed colonial construct why then do we continue to employ it? Is it because the word race serves some political/ideological purpose? Morten Fried has argued that ” to take away this four-letter word (race) from some would be like taking away candies from babies”, you are bound to hear howls, screams and shrieks.
Over the last 50-60 years Guyanese have developed a set of ethnic stereotypes and seemed to have fossilized them. In this our stereotype nothing seemed to have changed. Yet we know everything changes – for nothing remains static. This stereotype is especially true with reference to Party Politics. Whenever an Indo Guyanese disagrees with the PPP he or she is an “arkhati”, a turn-coat, or a “neemakharam”(turning against the salt one has eaten).
Conversely, when an Afro Guyanese supports the PPP he or she becomes a “house slave” or “Uncle Tom”. Why such name calling? This seems more like the emergence of a healthy democracy when individuals can move freely across the ethnic/party stereotype to meet their personal, political and ideological satisfaction.
Was Jessica Burnham a “house slave” when she supported the PPP or was it fundamental differences with her brother because, according to her, of his Machiavellian views? Were Chandisingh and Teekah ‘neemakharams’ when they joined the PNC? Are we (Guyanese) so narrow and myopic in our political opinions, that we overtly and covertly try to deny others the right and freedom to think and act according to their personal yearnings?
‘Race’ is an emotionally charged term and invokes all kinds of negative images. A linguist hypothesis suggested that, language by habitual grooves of expression predisposes us to see the world in a certain way and, as a result, act in that manner. Language in this case mediate between thought and action. If so, does not the continued use of the word ‘race’ (and by extension racist) mitigate against social civility? If, in our discourse, we cease to use the four-letter word, (race), would this in any way undermine our identity-individually or collectively?
We do not need any formal education to understand that our survival depends on our respect for the other, whoever he, she or it may be, regardless of gender, ethnicity, social class, sexual or spiritual orientation. We are nearing fifty years of nationhood we must demonstrate some maturity.
Thank you in advance for publishing this.








