CARIBBEAN PERSPECTIVES : An in-depth focus on Caribbean issues : More political pressure and resources needed for… : BRITISH TAX LOBBY

CARIBBEAN tourism destinations are eagerly waiting to see whether the U.K. Government will conduct an economic review of its Air Passenger Duty (APD) which has led to a significant fall off in British visitors to the region and is squeezing the already thin profit margins of the hospitality industry. During a recent visit to the U.K., it was clear to me that the region’s Heads of Government need to be at the forefront of the APD lobby, that financial resources need to be made available to sustain the APD campaign and that one of the most effective strategies is to re-energise the Caribbean diaspora to rally around the issue and use their considerable voting clout.
Under the current four band system, passengers flying to the Caribbean pay 81 pounds sterling in economy class in B and C. The Caribbean is calling for a re-banding that will move the tax to B and B with a fee of 65 pounds, applicable to travel to the U.S.
According to CTO statistics,there was a 10.7 per cent decrease in passenger traffic between the UK and Caribbean between 2008 and 2001.
Noting that the Caribbean is the most tourism dependent region in the world, the CTO has stressed that at a time when the Caribbean is experiencing low GDP growth, high levels of debt and rising food and energy prices, “re-banding the Caribbean could provide a boost to the Caribbean economy in a way that is both valuable and effective.”
Research undertaken for the CTO shows that if the Caribbean alone were to be re-banded at the same level as the US, the cost to the UK Treasury would be 18.6 million pounds out of an overall APD take by the UK Treasury of 2.9 billion pounds in 2012.
Over the past month, there has been an intensification of the APD campaign on several fronts. Chairman of the Caribbean Tourism Organisation, United States Virgin Islands Commissioner of Tourism, Beverly Nicholson Doty, and a group of Caribbean Tourism Ministers had a series of meetings during World Travel Market in London with British Government and Opposition parliamentary representatives.  This included talks with the Shadow Economic Secretary, Cathy Jamieson and long-standing Opposition Labour MP Diane Abbott, who has Jamaican roots.
One of the critical meetings was with the new Economic Secretary to the Treasury, Sajid Javid, who has agreed to meet a delegation of MPs with interests in the Caribbean.  
The countries most affected by the APD in terms of a decline in U.K. market share from 2008 to 2011are Dominica (-33%), St. Lucia (-22%), Jamaica (-16%), Antigua and Barbuda
 (-15%) and Barbados (-14%).
 A recent House of Commons Debate on the APD was led by Conservative MP Priti Patel, who noted that 200,000 members of the public are calling for a review of the economic impact of the tax. Several British MPs pointed to the illogical nature of the tax noting that taxes on travel to U.S. destinations were less than that to the Caribbean, which was a shorter distance.
The Association of British Travel Agents (ABTA), which is supportive of the Caribbean position on the APD, is also pressing for an economic review of the tax, which it deems harmful to the British economy. Both ABTA and the all-party MPs group underlined that the APD is adversely affecting inbound tourismand investment in the U.K.
David Jessop, who heads the London-based Caribbean Council, retained by the Caribbean CTO to lead the APD lobby, told me that the case is being made that any APD review should include its impact on Third Countries such as those in the Caribbean.
ABTA’s Head of Public Affairs Luke Pollard advised me that the association has been highlighting the issue through ‘A Fair Tax on Flying Campaign’, which is an alliance of more than 30 airlines, airports, tour operators, destinations and trade associations who are uniting to call on the Government to make the system of aviation tax in the UK fairer.
“This is especially acute for lower socio-economic groups and ethnic minorities visiting friends and relatives abroad,” ABTA says in its APD campaign literature.
The Association is calling for the APD to be replaced with a per plane duty (PPD) which it regards as a fair tax based on the efficiency of the aircraft and would be more closely aligned to the distance flown.
For those passengers who want a little more leg room and book ‘Premium Economy’ the APD is 162 pounds.
Thomas Cook, the second largest travel group in the UK, has reconfigured its packages to the Caribbean and, among other things, removed premium economy seats.
ABTA is hoping that an APD review can be completed within three months and before the budget next March.
Hoteliers in Barbados are among those feeling the pinch. British visitors to the island, who account for close to 40 percent of overall arrivals, traditionally stay longer and spend more than other visitors.
Barbados High Commissioner in London, Hugh Anthony Arthur, observed that the Caribbean, which is challenged to maintain economic viability,continues to face punitive measures from Europe, noting the challenges which the sugar, bananas and rum industries in the region face.
He agrees that the Caribbean needs to keep the APD pressure up in the U.K., especially in the 45 marginal constituencies where the votes of the Caribbean diaspora are crucial.

While Guyana has not been adversely affected by the decline in British arrivals to the region, the country’s High Commissioner Laleshwar Singh has nevertheless been very vocal on the issue, meeting with the West Indian Community on the issue in several cities.
Singh says if the APD campaign is to be sustained and the momentum of two years ago regained, Caribbean governments will need to provide financial resources for the lobbying effort. His views are shared by other Caribbean diplomats in London.
The U.K. administration needs to honour its commitment “to continue dialogue with a view to mitigating the deleterious effects that the application of the tax may have on its economies.”
Caribbean leaders should seek an audience with British Prime Minister David Cameron  to drive home the message that steps to “establish a new and improved strategic partnership”, as agreed to at the U.K.-Caribbean Forum in Grenada last January, must include an overhaul of the APD that is clearly damaging already fragile Caribbean tourism dependent economies.
(Sandra Ann Baptiste is a Business Consultant and Specialist in Caribbean Affairs).

PULL QUOTE:
While Guyana has not been adversely affected by the decline in British arrivals to the region, the country’s High Commissioner Laleshwar Singh has nevertheless been very vocal on the issue, meeting with the West Indian Community on the issue in several cities.

 

SHARE THIS ARTICLE :
Facebook
Twitter
WhatsApp
All our printed editions are available online
emblem3
Subscribe to the Guyana Chronicle.
Sign up to receive news and updates.
We respect your privacy.