Ralph Ramkarran
DURING the course of the debate leading up to the election of the Speaker of the National Assembly, there were references to the parliamentary agenda and the exercise of control over it by the Speaker.
The National Assembly’s business for each day is set out in the Order Paper for that day. The Order Paper is in fact the agenda. The Order Paper is required, under the Standing Orders, to list various subject headings and the specific matters under those headings that the National Assembly will be dealing with on that day.
The Order Paper is made up by the Clerk and he includes in it matters which are pending and new matters. The new matters are mainly bills, motions and questions, although other matters such as petitions, are included when tabled. The Speaker notionally approves the Order Paper, but in practice it is not controversial. Portions which may attract controversy, such as motions and questions, are approved when tabled, which is long before they go on the Order Paper.
In practice, most of these are not controversial and are recommended for approval by the Clerk which recommendation the Speaker normally accepts. Where there is doubt about a matter, the Clerk, in referring the matter to the Speaker, would quote the Standing Order which applies and give his opinion. The Speaker then makes a decision.
The practice which has developed over the past two decades is that all members of the National Assembly are entitled to be heard within the rules. Where a question is not properly framed, or violates a Standing Order, as is often the case, an alternative draft is offered to the member. It is invariably accepted. The same practice applies to motions.
Once approved, certain matters are required to go on to a notice paper for a certain period, and when that period expires, the matter goes onto the order paper for the next sitting of the National Assembly. For this reason, the order paper attracts no controversy.
The end result of all this is that more than 99.9 percent of all matters tabled by members are automatically placed on the order paper, or the agenda of the National Assembly. Under these practices, it is the members of the National Assembly who determine its agenda, not the Speaker.
When one side of the House has matters on the order paper, as is usually the case, it does not require the Speaker or any other person to “push” that agenda. In fact, the Speaker has no power to “push” anyone’s agenda. It is the members of the National Assembly who are in control and have the responsibility to “push” their own agenda. The Speaker cannot do it for them and ought not to take any steps which would have the colour of so doing, because he would jeopardize the traditional impartiality of the role of Speaker.
The Parliamentary Management Committee (PMC) has taken a decision in the past that every fourth sitting of the House would be held on a Wednesday when opposition business would be given priority. The Opposition had asked for this and after discussion in the PMC, it was eventually agreed. Unfortunately, after one or two occasions, opposition business was so modest that it was normally accommodated in the regular sittings and there was no need to have Wednesday sittings.
Like the National Assembly, the PMC also has a fixed agenda relating to the business of the National Assembly. However, that fixed agenda is by agreement and, of course, can be amended. One regular feature of debates at budget times when the work of the National Assembly comes under focus is complaint that the PMC is not meeting. Reference is never made to the regular letters written to the members in charge of the work of the PMC on both sides of the House, as to whether they have matters to raise and the lack of responses thereto.
No doubt, in the new dispensation, the PMC will return to the decisive role it played in the years after it was established and before MPs became jaded. It was structurally designed to ensure that bipartisan consensus would prevail. It has five members from each side of the House and is chaired by the Speaker who has neither an original nor a casting vote.
The PMC can take on any role that its members wish it to do, and can therefore be a useful instrument for engagement by the political parties represented in the National Assembly, having regard to the needs of the times. There is no other committee or forum in National Assembly which can serve a similar purpose or objective. (www.conversationtree.gy)







