– Says he concurs with Commissioner Burrowes’ findings
An alleged act of fraud at the City Hall, leaving millions of dollars unaccounted for, which, according to Commissioner of Enquiry into the Georgetown Municipality, Keith Burrowes, seems to be merely the tip of the iceberg of acts of forgery committed over an extensive period and probably involving other entities, such as the Deeds Registry, is under investigation by the fraud squad of the Police Force.
According to Commissioner Burrowes, the investigations of the Commission have been continuously uncovering dishonest and/or unprofessional conduct by employees of the municipality, and this is merely one instance that has been forced into the public domain before the official handing-over of the Commission’s report because of a property transaction that has reached the courts.
Mr. Anil Nandlall, lawyer for plaintiff, Ms Martina Bacchus, proprietor of Martina’s Cambio and employee of the Attorney General’s Chambers, has indicated that the property was co-owned by Clifford and Grace Hilliman, deceased siblings, and that their reputed spouses, Bibi Salima Hilliman and Wyatt Amsterdam, who are the current proprietors, owed $3M to the GNCB, and over $3.35M as rates and taxes to the Mayor and City Council, with an accrued interest of $220,000 owed to the latter.
According to Mr. Nandalall, the disputed property was in foreclosure, so Ms Hilliman obtained a Court Order granted in the High Court by Justice Ian Chang, which enabled her to enter into an Agreement of Sale with Ms Bacchus, who agreed to pay the balance owed to GNCB and the outstanding amounts owed the City Council in order to facilitate the issuance of a compliance before the sale could have been effected. On 17th February, 2009, her employee, Ms Kathleen Ramdin, paid to a clerk of the Council the sum of $3,348,209 and was provided a stamped manual receipt #097 from volume 1612 for the same amount.
Ms Ramdin was informed that a difference of $220,000 had to be paid, along with a compliance certificate fee of $8,000 before the requested compliance could be issued, which she paid later in the day, but was issued automated receipts for the outstanding amount and the compliance fee. Records indicate that the cashier for the latter amount was Charlene Gittens.
Mr. Nandalall said that the property, which would have been lost through foreclosure, was saved by Ms Bacchus’ timely disbursements. The Court Order allowed for half of the proceeds of sale, after deduction of expenses, to be given to the co-proprietor, Mr. Wyatt Amsterdam, who subsequently objected to the sale and had an injunction issued to halt the proceedings. He agreed to reimburse Ms Bacchus all monies expended, but the Council’s records showed no indication that the payment of $3,348,209 had been paid up to and at approximately midday on 2nd June 2009, and that Ms Gitten’s total cash receipts on 17th February reflected a total of $2.1 M.
However, after interest was generated in this case, sometime between midday and approximately 1700 hours on 2nd June, Ms Gittens’ cash receipts report for 17th February was amended with the following:
– The $220,000 payment with receipt #0906331 was deleted.
– A new amount, using the above receipt number, was added.
– Her total receipts for 17th February therefore increased to $5.25 M; but, as mentioned before, the Republic Bank had only received a deposit from this teller totaling $2.1M.
A demand notice generated sometime on 2nd June now indicated that the total outstandings on this facility as $4.7M.
The investigation by the Commission found unused duplicate copies of receipt #097 from volume 1612, while the original was missing. There were other unused duplicates with missing original receipts – the volume of which is yet to be determined.
Mr. Burrowes, after conferring with the Minister, sequestered the City Treasury Department and reported the incident to Messrs. Fordyce and Reid of the CID.
He delegated a representative of the Commission and requested the presence of Town Clerk, Ms Pluck, to meet with the criminal investigators on Thursday. Investigations are still ongoing and the Commissioner has indicated that he is devising a strategy to deal with the matter.
According to reliable sources, Mayor Hamilton Green was very angry when he returned from one of his periodic trips abroad to discover that the Commissioner had interceded in this matter. He considered that Mr. Burrowes had exceeded his authority and convened a meeting with the Deputy Mayor and City Councillors to deal with the issue; but, apparently under advisement, the Mayor reversed his position and at a Press Conference at City Hall yesterday he said that he concurred with what the Commissioner has said, but indicated that the duration of the report should not be elastic because persons are off the job, receiving full pay.
Mr. Burrowes, however, said that the work of the Commission does not revolve around two persons, but he is determined that his investigations would not remain static but would be a force for change.
He is adamant that this change could only be optimally effective if the status quo in management and the composition of the Council is changed, and the need for a continuance – an ongoing process of investigation simultaneous with implementation of more efficient and efficacious systems is addressed. The Commissioner is convinced that the extant dispensation of the Council and the anomalous factors currently existing cannot bring about or facilitate fundamental changes, but would instead stymie and severely inhibit the process.
As currently obtains, according to Mr. Burrowes, the system is open to manipulation by internal and external agents because there is no built-in audit trail that can determine and identify when, if, and by whom changes are made.
He said that, as an interim measure, he has had immediate steps taken by the IT Department to make the terminals more secure and to establish a firewall that would protect the software from external manipulation, even against the existing constraints.
Mr. Burrowes refused to comment on the Mayor’s proposition to contract an IT firm to install new software. He says that his position on the matter will be reflected in the Commission’s report.
The Mayor, during his press conference, said that his office is constrained from dealing condignly with employees committing misdemeanors because the authority of his office and that of the City Council is limited, and that he would welcome systems put in place where his office is vested with the relevant authority to effectively manage the City’s business.
A skeptical media operative, however, remarked after the press conference that the Mayor seems to go into defence mode after every public disclosure of a misdemeanor in the City Council.
Mr. Green informed the media that Mr. Burrowes had reported the matter of the fraud to the CID upon his advisement.
However, Mr. Burrowes refuted this, and said that he contacted the CID after a discussion with the Minister, long before he had engaged in any discussion of the matter with the Mayor.
This attempt by the Mayor to be agreeable and co-operative with Commissioner Burrowes is, however, a very welcome development. One hopes it will sustain and prevail over experiences of the past.
The Commissioner expressed appreciation for the co-operation that he has received from the staff of the Municipality and said that he could assure the public that the findings and recommendations in the report will significantly enhance transparency and accountability within the management structure of the Georgetown municipality.







