GUYANA’S Low-Carbon Development Strategy (LCDS) and President Bharrat Jagdeo’s unrelenting lobbying for building this country’s low-carbon economic development thrust gained new ground at the United Nations climate change meeting which ended in Cancun, Mexico, yesterday.
The President’s stand in presenting Guyana’s case at the meeting was widely reported by mainstream international media, including Time magazine, The Economist, the Washington Post and the Guardian newspaper of London.
Guyana’s LCDS is pegged on reduced deforestation and forest degradation, also known as REDD+, a formula for action on the loss of forests in developing countries, some of which is to be paid for in various ways by the developed world.
REDD+ is among the issues Cancun reached agreement on. There is also a new fund for climate finance that will benefit from some of the US$100 billion in “long-term finance” that the agreements see flowing from north to south every year by 2020.
In a compromise between likely donors and recipients, this fund will not be directly under the control of the parties to the UN Framework Convention on Climate Change, but instead run by an independent board. The World Bank will function as a trustee for the fund, but in a way as yet to be fully defined.
On the penultimate day of the climate negotiations, Mr. Jagdeo highlighted the need for international mechanisms to facilitate the flow of climate finance from the developed world to the developing world.
He reiterated that having commitments of finance would be insufficient, if these were not matched by the mechanisms to intermediate them.
On a panel convened by the Avoided Deforestation Partners non-governmental organisation, which included Norwegian Prime Minister, Jens Stoltenberg, international philanthropist, George Soros, and President Barack Obama’s Adviser on Energy and Environment, Joe Aldy, President Jagdeo explained how Guyana and Norway’s experience could provide valuable lessons for how multilateral institutions like the World Bank could be modernised to provide the financial intermediary services required for climate finance.
The President said: “Having a generous donor and a progressive forest country is not enough. When payments are being made from the developed to the developing world, we need institutions that are able to move beyond the old-fashioned ODA (Official Development Assistance) thinking, which does not have a good track record of delivering timely solutions.”
He spoke of the difficulties experienced by Guyana and Norway in establishing the Guyana REDD+ Investment Fund (GRIF), and said that if Guyana and Norway could not make it work, nobody could.
President Jagdeo said that global institutions need to evolve quickly, if they are to play a critical role in helping countries to take action on climate change, adding that failure of these global institutions to act in a timely manner can undermine the political momentum and support for addressing climate change.
In the world’s second largest Reduced Emissions from Deforestation and Degradation (REDD+) agreement, Norway has paid US$30 million to Guyana for progress in protecting Guyana’s 16 million hectare forest. Norway will pay up to US$250 million by 2015.
Prime Minister Stoltenberg spoke of how there are three leading examples of REDD+ in the world, namely: Brazil, Indonesia and Guyana. Norway has bilateral agreements with all three.
Later in the day, President Jagdeo and Prime Minister Stoltenberg reviewed progress on the Guyana-Norway partnership.
President Jagdeo said the meeting was “very focused, and we will both keep a very close eye on progress in the months ahead.”
In the coming months, the first investments from the GRIF begin to action the priorities highlighted in the LCDS. The initial priorities are to progress Guyana’s low-carbon energy transformation, starting with the distribution of solar panels to indigenous communities; the acceleration of the land titling process for indigenous lands, in accordance with the goal set out in the LCDS to address all requests for titling by 2015; and support for vulnerable groups to participate in the new low-carbon economy.
President Jagdeo also held discussions with President Luis Alberto Moreno, the President of the Inter-American Development Bank (IDB).
After the meeting, President Jagdeo praised the IDB’s ability to “deal with challenges such as climate change in a way that is practical and implementable.”
Mr. Jagdeo and Moreno discussed progress on the preparations for the Amaila Falls hydro-electricity plant, which will catalyse in excess of US$400 million of private finance, and provide affordable, reliable and clean energy. The IDB is providing support to the Government of Guyana to develop the project.
Bryan Walsh, reporting for Time magazine, noted that the Guyana-Norway agreement was hailed as historic; “one that would slow climate change (12% to 17% of the planet’s carbon emissions now come from deforestation) and provide a model for how rich nations could help poor tropical countries hold onto their forests for the benefit of the planet.”
He also observed that by choosing to try to preserve its forests through a REDD scheme, rather than cutting them down for logging or agriculture, Guyana was taking a risk, putting its trust that the international community would pay up.
“Every day that money was delayed, Guyana was taking a hit—and so was its president, who has been lauded for his environmental vision,” Walsh said.
He referred to President Jagdeo’s point, too, that REDD will only work if it can tap into a large pool of funds—which means that developed countries will need to take on deep carbon cuts and offset at least some of them through private sector offsets.
“Unless REDD could produce markets that would support carbon costs of at least $20- $25 a tonne, it wouldn’t make economic sense for tropical nations to protect their forests, rather than use them for logging or clearing the land for agriculture. (Jagdeo also noted that REDD had additional hurdles—while businesses involved in the forest trade would pay promptly, and wouldn’t tell countries like Guyana how to spend their money, REDD funds tended to come with significant strings, and delays.)”
In an address to the meeting, President Jagdeo said: “We can make progress on addressing deforestation and forest degradation; we can make progress on the mechanics of a green fund to help invest in mitigation and in adaptation to help the most vulnerable; we can make progress on technology transfer and we can make progress on financing.”
He noted that in South America, “our countries are leading the way towards this low-carbon future.”
The President added: “At the summit of South American Presidents in Guyana two weeks ago, at which Guyana assumed the Pro tempore Presidency of UNASUR (Union of South American Nations), we highlighted that industries in our continent are the world’s leaders in clean transportation and sustainable forms of agriculture. And through our stewardship of the Amazon and other forests, we provide the world with its largest climate utility. It would be a disgrace if the leadership shown by South American countries was not supported by meaningful international action.
“We in Guyana are already implementing our low carbon development strategy, which combines the preservation of our 16 million hectare forest with a reorientation of our economy onto a low carbon trajectory. We are seeing that it is possible to make combating climate change and securing national development complementary, not competing, objectives.
“So, I urge all the activists, the negotiators, the governments, the private sector and others who have contributed so much to the progress we have made thus far, to keep working.
“If you care about the future of our planet, you must not give up. The goals we aspire to are too important.”
The Economist reported that Mr. Jagdeo was keen to stress that his complaint about the delay in the flow of finance from Norway was not directed at Mr. Stoltenberg, with whom he enjoys a very good relationship.
“Norway paid the money in question to the World Bank a year ago for onward transmission. His irritation wasn’t even really aimed, Mr. Jagdeo later said, at Robert Zoellick, president of the World Bank, who was sitting in the front row of the audience, though it seems that much of the delay he objects to is due to passing the money through the careful checks and oversights of the World Bank system. The president wanted to communicate his frustration to the audience in general, which contained a lot of business people, politicians, policy makers and non-government types,” the magazine said.
It added: “What Mr. Jagdeo wanted to stress was that for a recipient country, REDD is not a simple matter of getting some cash and some invitations to speak to the great and the good. It involves spending political capital to get all sorts of interest groups on board. And anything that goes wrong and diminishes the charms of the project—such as the money to buy a host of promised solar panels for people’s roofs, which he says will be one of Guyana’s first investments—hurts the process.
“Mr. Stoltenberg, like many in the north, has developed a great devotion to `results-based’ development assistance, in which the donors see what they are getting. Mr. Jagdeo wants some results-based responses from the Bank. Both politicians know results are needed to keep the good work up, though they themselves may see little direct reward from their success: Mr. Stoltenberg said that Norway’s extremely high levels of development assistance (more than 1% of GDP) are not domestically popular, and that both main opposition parties would cut them; Mr. Jagdeo, term limited, is meant to have left the presidency by this time next year.
“Their message was that even when it seems simple, with all the money coming from a willing donor, halting deforestation is still a taxing political process. With its complex blend of emissions targets, counterfactual scenarios against which to measure them, attention to the livelihoods of those affected, conflation with other environmental goals, need for international financial flows and negotiated requirements for the monitoring and verification of the good that is done, the REDD process is, in a way, a microcosm of all the broader problems facing climate diplomacy.”







