CLIMATE talks in Bonn, Germany ended Friday in disappointment as the negotiating text ahead of the yearend summit in Cancún, Mexico became more complicated rather than clearer. And experts are saying that a global binding climate agreement may not be possible before COP17 (Conference of the Parties) in South Africa next year.
Although head of the United Nations Framework Convention on Climate Change (UNFCCC) Christina Figueres remains hopeful, officials from developing countries doubt that any change from the status quo will come in a hurry.
She is urging that governments make the necessary compromises and narrow down the choices available. Those choices, however, have been ever-expanding, with the inclusion of more bracketed items in the negotiating text. The new climate text under discussion grew from 17 to 34 pages, with new proposals added, or old ones reinserted.
Charlie Parker, policy analyst of the Global Canopy Programme told the Guyana Chronicle that it has been a bad week for REDD (Reducing Emissions from Deforestation and Forest Degradation) and for the general debate on climate. He noted, however, that REDD was not even supposed to be on the agenda.
“The mitigation discussion even went backwards and became more polarised,” said Gordon Shepherd of WWF(World Wildlife Fund), one of the campaign groups that attended the meeting.
Artur Runge-Metzger, the European Union’s co-lead negotiator, accused some countries of adding text in a “tit-for-tat” manner, and said that it is important to turn that spirit around in Tianjin, China where the next round of climate talks will be held.
Further, experts believe that there will likely be at least three different agreements instead of one giant binding one that had been aimed for at Copenhagen and had been elusive, with the loose and non-binding Copenhagen Accord being arrived at disappointing smaller nations.
Government representatives in Bonn made no progress on emissions reduction targets, or on the shape of a new agreement to replace the Kyoto Protocol, which itself expires in 2012. Further, there has been talk of seeking an extension to the life of the Protocol for a further two years to allow enough time to work out an agreement for its replacement.
Some of the individual agreements that could be reached in Cancún include forest protection, financing for low-carbon development and for climate change mitigation.
But an overarching agreement must still be reached for any of the decisions made in Cancún to be implemented. The UN climate talks move on to Tianjin, China in October.







