CJ to rule on Granger Legal Challenge – Attorneys conclude arguments

CHIEF Justice Ian Chang is expected to give his ruling shortly as to whether there will be any restrictions on Governments spending based on the application for a Conservatory Order applied for by attorneys for Leader of the Opposition, David Granger. The Attorney General while addressing the media after the concluding arguments offered by Basil Williams for Granger said, “The Chief Justice has indicated that notices will be sent shortly informing us when he will be in a position to rule. I anticipate that it should not be long from now because the Chief Justice has indicated that this is a matter of national importance and he will do everything to ensure that he renders a decision as early as possible.”

Monday saw the end of submissions with rebuttal arguments being presented by the attorney for Granger, Basil Williams as he concluded arguments in the hearing which resulted from a legal challenge filed by Granger in his capacity as Leader of the Opposition, seeking the courts to find that Government’s spending on programmes not approved in the National Budget for 2014 were unconstitutional.
Speaking to the media after Monday’s hearing Attorney General, Anil Nandlall appearing for the Minister of Finance was of the view that Williams in his closing submission had “missed the bus,” explaining that this part of the proceedings was to determine if a Conservatory Order should be granted restraining the Minister of Finance from spending on programmes not approved in the 2014 budget.
The Attorney General said, “His (Williams) submission concentrated on the legality or lack of legality of the Minister’s restoration of the monies that were cut from the budget in 2014… the live issue before the court is whether a Conservatory Order should be granted in relation to the year 2015 prior to an Appropriation Act.”
Williams on the other hand said that he felt confident after making his rebuttal as the team for Granger had challenged and contradicted the Attorney General’s assertion that the court had no jurisdiction to grant a Conservatory Order in this matter. He said that they were also able to show that the Minister of Finance was properly joined as a defendant in the matter and they used supporting cases to show that when progammes were disapproved it fell into the category of “unauthorised. “There is no constitutional provision to change unauthorised to authorised,” he stated. Questioned on the Opposition approving the Statement of Excess presented to the Parliament by the Finance Minister for sums disapproved in the 2012 and 2013 budget, Williams argued that they were approved in keeping with the Chief Justice’s ruling that said that the budget could not be cut or reduced, only approved or disapproved, and that in 2014 they disapproved the programmes as against cutting or reducing the provisions as was done in 2012 and 2013.
Nandlall maintains that Williams had jumped ahead as his arguments would be better suited to the substantive case and that Article 219 and the Fiscal Management and Accountability Act together provide the constitutional and statutory framework for spending prior to the enactment of an Appropriation Bill for the current year. This he reminded is “one twelfth of the approved budget for the preceding year and that cannot be changed by the court. No court can interfere with the executive right to spend money in accordance with that formula for any given financial year prior to the enactment of the Appropriation Act and that narrow issue has not been addressed.” He further argues that the attorneys for the Leader of the Opposition have failed to show that the Minister of Finance has in previous years or currently has violated the constitution in the way money has been expended.
The combined Opposition with a one-seat majority in the National Assembly had cut $37.5B from the 2014 budget. The Minister of Finance had presented a Statement of Excess in July 2014 seeking approval for spending in excess of $6.B spent on some programmes not approved in the 20114 budget.
The National Assembly went into recess before that matter was considered for approval and in November 2014 the legal challenge was filed by Granger.
Following the ruling of the Chief Justice a date will be fixed to commence hearing on the substantive matter filed by Granger. That will determine the constitutionality of the Minister of Finance spending money on programmes disapproved in the 2015 budget.
Arguments were presented by Attorneys for the Leader of the Opposition who initiated the legal challenge and attorneys for the named respondents, Ashton Chase, who appeared on behalf of Attorney General, Anil Nandlall, who is appearing on behalf of the Minister of Finance and Khemraj Ramjattan for the Speaker of the National Assembly.

SHARE THIS ARTICLE :
Facebook
Twitter
WhatsApp
All our printed editions are available online
emblem3
Subscribe to the Guyana Chronicle.
Sign up to receive news and updates.
We respect your privacy.