Explaining post-2020 anti-government hate in Guyana

IN the industrial West (Western Europe, the US and Canada) political hate among competitors were always at a very low level from the 19th century to around the beginning of the 1990s. The reason for this was because the societies were abundant in resources and wealth. What happened then is that electoral competition was not based on venom and unmitigated spite.
Political parties were not fearful of losing elections forever because the incumbent will rule forever, because they will use society’s resources to share out goodies. Parties win and lose because of non-economic factors such as charisma, powerful educational backgrounds, persuasive reach in verbal deliveries, and family values. Pierre Trudeau won repeated elections in Canada in the 1970s because he was seen as the most charismatic man in Canada.
As Europe got older and resources dried up and as decreasing wealth could no longer sustain the American Dream, parties began to use the relentless declining economy as the main plank in election rivalry. To win an election, it was a dire requirement to speak of helping the nation out of poverty. From the beginning of the 21st century in the West, elections were no longer about which candidate was good looking and could speak brilliantly, but about who could save the country from economic decline.
This and only this factor explains the first-term victory of Donald Trump. Things are so dire in Europe today that it is easier for right-wing populists to win elections than to kiss the palm of your hand. In the American system and in Europe, political competition is characterised by the outpouring of hate and personal vendettas. It will get worse because Europe has no money, and what little they have of it they put in the arms industry where it becomes a drain on the economy.
The above explains the hate that is riveting Western politics. Is there any parallel with Guyana where the evil in Guyana’s politics is moving so fast that one fears the crescendo? How is Guyana different from the West in the existence of hate and what are the similarities?
First, the similarity. To understand the evil now present in anti-government activism, one has to go back to class struggle in Europe before the First World War. Classes’ antagonism was sharp, and working-class parties and trade unions were very angry actors in society. But as Europe and the US exploited the colonies and became richer, then, by the time the Second World War came, Europe was so wealthy that the capitalist state became realistic and decided it could blunt class struggle by distributing some of the wealth to the working people. Scandinavia created welfare states. Canada was close behind, and American wealth was so excessive that it created the American dream.
In contrast, in Guyana, class struggle was never blunted by the political leadership of the state because unlike homogeneous Europe, Guyana was a multi-racial polity. In Guyana, race and class merged in a deadly confluence. The people who inherited the state were the Mulatto/Creole class (MCC). But they could not distribute the wealth of the society because there was none to distribute. The post-colonial middle class inherited a country stripped of its resources through colonial rule.
The ruling class in Guyana then, unlike the industrialised West, was not prepared to be generous and accommodate the working class, but sought to strangulate the masses and there was also a complication that was frightening for the future of the country as the MCC saw it. The ruling MCC was saddled with Cheddi Jagan and the Indian population that it despised for eugenic reasons, but was afraid of the largeness of the Indian population and its incredible infatuation with Jagan. Class and colour then, in Guyana, morphed into political and race hate that, unlike in Europe, kept expanding.
Why anti-government evil is so pervasive in Guyana in 2026 and how Guyana is different from the West in this context: one has to understand that though class antagonism is still rising in the West, particularly in the US, it is not as trenchant as it is in Guyana. The reason being that in the West the relations of production have evolved in a dialectical way to accommodate sections of the working class (though not in the US) whereas in Guyana, classes have been intertwined with colour.
It is this complication that makes for the difference between Europe (not the US) and Guyana in the expansion of political hate. The post-colonial class, which took over the colonial state in Guyana, wanted permanent political power, which they saw as an entitlement, but their hold on state power has been short-lived, and they have lost it to what they always consider their nemesis – Indian people. The perpetuation of this hate has found a home in the political opposition. More later.
DISCLAIMER: The views and opinions expressed in this column are solely those of the author and do not necessarily reflect the official policy or position of the Guyana National Newspapers Limited

SHARE THIS ARTICLE :
Facebook
Twitter
WhatsApp
All our printed editions are available online
emblem3
Subscribe to the Guyana Chronicle.
Sign up to receive news and updates.
We respect your privacy.