A JUSTICE system is only as strong as the courage of those who serve it. That is why the Bar Council of the Bar Association of Guyana was right this week to condemn the public attacks on Director of Public Prosecutions Shalimar Ali-Hack, S.C., Deputy Solicitor General Shoshanna Lall and Assistant Solicitor General Ronetta Sargeant.
The Council’s message was plain: lawyers, including those in public office, must be able to do their jobs fearlessly and independently, free from personal attacks, public vilification and intimidation. Every Guyanese who values the rule of law should stand behind that principle.
The facts as the Attorney General has set them out are troubling. On November 12, judicial review proceedings involving Opposition Leader Azruddin Mohamed came up in the High Court. According to Attorney General Anil Nandlall, the judge had to admonish a member of the Mohamed family more than once for loud outbursts, and even the family’s own lawyers had to caution her. After the court adjourned, he says, insults were hurled at the two State attorneys. When Ms Sargeant replied that they were “simply doing our jobs,” she was reportedly spat at.
The next day came a Facebook post by Hana Mohamed, the Opposition Leader’s sister, accusing the two women of professional misconduct. The Attorney General has called the post “malicious, false and defamatory” and warned of legal action. It has since drawn a flood of vitriolic comments.
Let us be clear about what happened here. Two of the most senior professionals in the Attorney General’s Chambers walked into a courtroom to represent the State. That is their duty, not a political act. If any litigant believes State counsel behaved improperly, there are proper places to say so: the presiding judge, the Legal Practitioners Committee, the courts themselves. Facebook, where an accusation can spread in minutes and harden into “truth” before anyone checks it, is not one of them.
There is also a worrying idea behind these attacks: that because public lawyers are paid from public funds, they are fair game. The Attorney General answered it well. Being paid by the State does not take away anyone’s right to dignity, personal safety or a good name. Public officers should not have to put up with abuse as the price of serving the country. If we accept that idea, we tell every talented young lawyer that public service means having your reputation thrown to the online mob whenever a powerful family loses patience in court.
Nor is this a new fight. The Bar Council spoke out in 2020, when lawyers in the elections cases were vilified. It spoke out again in 2024, when judicial officers were targeted on social media. Its warnings have been consistent and non-partisan, and that is what gives this latest statement its weight. When the profession’s own governing body sounds the alarm repeatedly, the country should listen.
The people involved in this matter are entitled to their day in court, and nobody’s legal rights should be cut short. But defending yourself in court is very different from trying to intimidate the lawyers on the other side. Courtrooms are not arenas for personal grudges, and the corridors outside them are not places to settle scores.
Guyana’s democracy rests on institutions that work without fear or favour. The DPP, Ms Lall and Ms Sargeant deserve the nation’s support, and those who would bully them deserve the nation’s firm rejection. Let the lawyers work. Let the courts decide.








