IF there is any historic statement that is 1,000 percent irrefutable is the one that goes like this – “the more you live, the more you learn.”
I had a close friend, Dennis Canterbury, when we were youthful activists in the WPA. Then we became UG academic staff members around the same time. One memory of Dennis will never die.
The House of Israel thugs were chasing WPA supporters after the adjournment of the court case whereby some of the WPA leaders were charged with burning down the Ministry of National Development.
The thugs pursued us on Manget Place where we ran into First Federation Building. They came into the building and we locked ourselves in a dark room. I was breathing too heavily so Dennis told me to ease it because they were outside the room.
When we came out, we heard the news that Father Andrew Morrison of the Catholic Standard was killed by the thugs. In fact, the goons mistook Father Bernard Darke for Father Morrison
Dennis migrated a long time ago and I completely lost contact with him. I didn’t know if he lived in India, Timbuktu or San Marino or right here in the Caribbean. What I do know is that Clive Thomas protégéd him and he regards Clive as his hero.
By surprise, I read a letter by Dennis in the Kaieteur News yesterday (Thursday) in which he stated he was retired. I now comment on two statements he made.
He noted that the government is rejoicing that there will be no more Eusi Kwayana to check their conscience and rebuke them.
Indeed, Eusi excelled in the role of a critic of power and maybe Bob Marley should have written a song about Eusi. But please note that Eusi migrated from Guyana in 2005. So, he didn’t ground with the people of Guyana since then.
The second statement is worth confronting Dennis on. I quote him: “The rulers may believe the freedom is theirs to set new degenerate moral standards in parliamentary and political behaviours without having to look over their shoulders for any rebuke from an elder like Baba Kwayana.”
When did the state become degenerate? Can Dennis give us a time frame? Did this degeneracy take place under the government of 2015-2020 when three founding members of the WPA were top members of the government including Clive Thomas?
I was partially protégéd by Clive. His book, “The Rise of the Authoritarian State in Peripheral Societies” contributed to my political education.
Clive Thomas embraced the theory of Pakistani political theorist, Hamza Alavi that in peripheral societies, the state is overdeveloped. Alavi attributed this to the necessity of the use of state violence under colonialism. Alavi went on to argue, which Thomas accepted, that after Independence the overdeveloped state remained intact.
WPA leaders in the APNU+AFC government lived with the overdeveloped state. Thomas himself was publicly accused of condoning the economic brutalisation of all people – sugar workers – by Andaiye, Kwayana and Moses Bhagwan. Thomas gave an unapologetic response to them.
When the workers of the closed estates were picketing the Office of the President, they were standing near to the wide trench to the east.
The police kept pushing them into the trench. The sugar industry (GuySuCo) at that time was headed by Clive Thomas.
Finally, as a retired professor, Dennis should avoid the jejune pathway that many of his WPA colleagues, especially Nigel Westmaas, have taken: just bandy words about “autocracy,” “degeneracy” in Guyana without the accompanying analysis.
An academic is not a street labourer who is entitled to bandy words and is forgiven for not elaborating. Academics have to educate people and you do not do that by saying the world has collapsed without an accompanying description.
How and why is the state in Guyana degenerate in 2026? What are the contents of this degeneracy? One year and one month ago, Guyana had general elections. The traditional PNC and WPA parties lost heavily.
Why did someone like David Hinds and Tacuma Ogunseye not generate substantial votes for APNU? The GECOM database shows President Ali picking up votes in African areas that the PPP failed to secure in previous elections.
I firmly support the right of anti-government critics to make accusations against the ruling party. If a society doesn’t have that type of life, then it will wither away. But anti-government critics have an obligation to educate those who support them.
If Dennis is a retired professor, then he is intellectually equipped to argue that he believes the state in Guyana is degenerate. Anyway, welcome back to Guyana through your pen but avoid the pitfalls of your WPA colleagues.
DISCLAIMER: The views and opinions expressed in this column are solely those of the author and do not necessarily reflect the official policy or position of the Guyana National Newspapers Limited.








