National Hardware wins 13-year legal battle over US$30M Liliendaal land

— High Court dismisses Beharry’s claims, orders G$400M refund by December 31

AFTER more than 13 years of litigation, National Hardware (Guyana) Limited has secured a major High Court victory against Edward B. Beharry & Company Limited in a dispute over approximately 15 acres of prime residential land at Demerara Estates, Liliendaal, East Coast Demerara, now estimated to be worth more than US$30 million.

In a 66-page ruling delivered on October 28, 2026, Justice Nareshwar Harnanan upheld National Hardware’s decision to terminate a 2012 sale agreement, dismissed all aspects of Beharry’s counterclaim, and permanently restrained the company from entering, occupying, or carrying out construction on the property.

According to a release from National Hardware, the court also awarded costs against Beharry, bringing a decisive end at the High Court level to a legal battle that began in 2013 over the company’s failure to complete payment for the land.

At the centre of the dispute was a G$523 million agreement under which Beharry was required to pay the outstanding purchase price and take transport of the property within four months.

Although the company paid G$400 million and took possession of the land, it failed to settle the remaining balance within the stipulated period.

National Hardware said it subsequently terminated the agreement in August 2013 and obtained an injunction removing Beharry from the property.

Beharry, however, maintained that it was entitled to withhold the outstanding payment until National Hardware completed essential infrastructural works, including roads, drainage, water and electricity throughout the housing development.

The company also argued that the contractual provision making time of the essence applied equally to National Hardware’s development obligations.

According to the hardware company, Justice Harnanan rejected that interpretation, describing the argument as “an artful distinction” and declaring that he was “not persuaded by that construction”.

The judge determined that while the agreement imposed a clear four-month deadline for Beharry to complete payment and take transport, no corresponding deadline existed for National Hardware to complete the infrastructural works.

Considering the extensive development required to transform the 103-acre property from raw land into a residential estate, the judge found that those circumstances “would militate strongly against” interpreting the agreement as requiring the works to be completed within four months.

The court further determined that the completion of those works was not a precondition for Beharry to fulfil its payment obligations.

The trial involved more than 20 days of evidence between 2020 and 2025, including 12 days of cross-examination of National Hardware director Claude Deygoo, also known as Eddie Boyer.

Evidence from Beharry’s own witnesses proved significant in the court’s assessment.

The hardware company said that architect, Deen Kamaludeen acknowledged under cross-examination that the concerns raised about the development amounted to “advisory recommendations” rather than contractual demands.

He also accepted that the agreement contained no deadline for National Hardware to complete the works, and identified no provision allowing Beharry to withhold payment.

The court additionally heard that specifications advanced by the architect, including provisions based on 12 occupants per luxury home and several swimming pools, were not contained in the sale agreement.

Edward Anand Beharry also acknowledged that the company had not produced contracts, receipts or proof of payment to substantiate expenditure it claimed to have incurred on the property.

In reaching its decision, the court accepted National Hardware’s position that Beharry’s insistence on additional infrastructural works, coupled with its intention to deduct their cost from the outstanding purchase price, amounted to a repudiation of the agreement.

The judge found that National Hardware was therefore entitled to terminate the contract.

The court also rejected allegations that National Hardware had breached its development obligations.

Taking into account “the complexity of the development” and the practical challenges of construction in Guyana, Justice Harnanan determined that approximately four years to substantially service the previously undeveloped land was reasonable.

Beharry’s claims for specific performance, damages and unjust enrichment were consequently dismissed, with the court finding that the company had failed to establish that it was ready and willing to complete the purchase on the agreed contractual terms.

The ruling also established that Beharry occupied the property only as a contractual licensee, meaning its right to remain ended once the agreement was terminated.

National Hardware was represented by attorney-at-law Devindra Kissoon of London House Chambers, while Beharry was represented by Senior Counsel Edward Luckhoo and attorney-at-law Robin Stoby.

Despite National Hardware’s success, the court ordered that Beharry’s G$400 million part-payment be refunded by December 31, 2026, consistent with the refund National Hardware had offered when the agreement was terminated.

The decision resolves the dispute at the High Court level, with National Hardware retaining control of the valuable Liliendaal property.

 

SHARE THIS ARTICLE :
Facebook
Twitter
WhatsApp
All our printed editions are available online
emblem3
Subscribe to the Guyana Chronicle.
Sign up to receive news and updates.
We respect your privacy.