Faulty filing by Mohamed’s lawyers delays bail review hearing
Defence attorneys (from left to right) Siand Dhurjon, Damien DaSilva and Roysdale Forde, SC at the High Court on Wednesday (Elton John photos)
Defence attorneys (from left to right) Siand Dhurjon, Damien DaSilva and Roysdale Forde, SC at the High Court on Wednesday (Elton John photos)

– AG challenges evidence filed by defence, describes affidavit as ‘one of the worst’ he has read

THE High Court’s review of the decision to deny bail to Opposition Leader Azruddin Mohamed was delayed on Wednesday after Justice Priscilla Chandra-Hanif identified deficiencies in an affidavit submitted by his legal team, prompting Attorney General and Minister of Legal Affairs Anil Nandlall, SC, to challenge its admissibility.
Nandlall asked the court to strike out the affidavit, sworn by Mohamed’s mother, Bonita Mohamed, or remove several of its paragraphs, arguing that it contained hearsay, opinion, irrelevant material and allegations against State officials and agencies that were not supported by evidence of the deponent’s personal knowledge.

Describing the document as “one of the worst affidavits I have ever read”, the Attorney General said affidavits must comply with established rules governing admissible evidence and must not contain matters outside the knowledge or competence of the person swearing them.
The defence, however, accused the State of relying on technical objections to delay consideration of the substantive question of whether Mohamed should be granted bail.

A photograph of the cell at Lusignan Prison where Opposition Leader Azruddin Mohamed is being held, presented by Attorney General Anil Nandlall during Wednesday’s High proceedings

Justice Chandra-Hanif allowed the defence additional time to address the deficiencies and granted permission for a further affidavit to be filed by Mohamed himself. She emphasised that the evidence must comply with the rules of admissibility and relate directly to the bail proceedings.
The matter is scheduled to return to court on November 12 for consideration of the objections to the affidavit, while the substantive hearing is set for November 23.
During the proceedings, Nandlall also rejected allegations about Mohamed’s conditions of detention, including claims that he was being held in solitary confinement, exposed to bright lighting continuously and allowed only limited time outside his cell.
He told reporters that the Prison Service had repeatedly issued statements disputing those claims and confirmed that Mohamed had provided the authorities with the names of three persons he wished to receive as visitors, all of whom had been allowed access.
Nandlall further said Mohamed received meals from relatives and had been visited by his attorneys, adding that his lawyers had spent two hours with him on Sunday.
The Attorney General presented a photograph of the cell in which Mohamed is being held, saying it had been supplied by the Director of Prisons and that he intended to include it in his affidavit. He also referred to international standards governing the treatment of prisoners, arguing that the Lusignan facility was constructed in accordance with those requirements.

Attorney General Anil Nandlall, SC, arrives at the High Court on Wednesday for the hearing of Opposition Leader Azruddin Mohamed’s bail review application

“Some people may not want to accept it or not, but the place at Lusignan is not a five-star hotel. At the end of the day it is a prison,” Nandlall said, maintaining that the facility must conform to prison standards.
The proceedings are a judicial review of Magistrate Abigail Gibbs’ decision to refuse bail to Mohamed. He was remanded alongside Police Constable Ryan Greene after both men were charged over allegations that they unlawfully obtained footage from the Government’s Safe City CCTV initiative in exchange for $800,000.
The charges were brought before the Sparendaam Magistrates’ Court, where Magistrate Gibbs denied both men bail.
Mohamed subsequently initiated the judicial review proceedings through an application filed by his mother, seeking to have the magistrate’s decision quashed and bail granted.
He is also facing separate extradition proceedings in the United States, in which he remains on bail.

SHARE THIS ARTICLE :
Facebook
Twitter
WhatsApp
All our printed editions are available online
emblem3
Subscribe to the Guyana Chronicle.
Sign up to receive news and updates.
We respect your privacy.