Minister Teixeira wins defamation case brought by Vincent Adams
Minister of Parliamentary Affairs and Governance Gail Teixeira
Minister of Parliamentary Affairs and Governance Gail Teixeira

 

THE High Court has dismissed a $15 million defamation lawsuit brought by former Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) Executive Director Dr Vincent Adams against Minister of Parliamentary Affairs and Governance Gail Teixeira. 

The lawsuit stemmed from statements Teixeira made about Adams’ alleged connection to Guyana’s controversial 2016 Production Sharing Agreement (PSA) with ExxonMobil.

In a judgement delivered on October 15, 2026, Justice Jacqueline Josiah-Graham found that Teixeira’s statements carried a limited defamatory meaning but ruled that Adams had failed to prove that she acted with malice, allowing her defence of qualified privilege to succeed.

The case arose from statements Teixeira made on March 19 and 20, 2024, while answering questions from a member of the United Nations Human Rights Committee during its review of Guyana’s compliance with international human rights obligations.

During the exchange, Teixeira said Adams, as former EPA Director, had “oversaw” the 2016 PSA and was “part of the secret PSA”, referring to the agreement’s terms and the signature bonus that became public approximately a year after it was signed.

Dr. Vincent Adams

Adams argued that the statements falsely suggested he was involved in the agreement when it was negotiated and signed, and that he had participated in concealing financial information from the public.

However, Justice Josiah-Graham found that the statements did not establish that Adams personally negotiated or concealed the agreement, deposited the signature bonus, or was corrupt or dishonest.

“The sting is the suggestion that he had some unspecified involvement in or association with the secret arrangement during the period when its terms were not public,” the judge stated.

The court found that Adams had no role in negotiating, executing or publicising the agreement in 2016 and 2017. He joined the EPA in October 2018, approximately two years after the agreement was signed.

The judge ruled that Teixeira had failed to establish the substantial truth of the defamatory implication, noting that Adams’ political association with the Alliance For Change (AFC) and his subsequent regulatory responsibilities did not prove that he had prior knowledge of, or involvement in, the agreement’s secrecy.

Justice Josiah-Graham wrote, “The evidence proves a later regulatory connection, not a contemporaneous connection with the agreement’s non-disclosure.”

Nevertheless, the judge found that Teixeira was speaking in her official capacity as a government minister and head of Guyana’s delegation to the UN committee.

The committee had a legitimate interest in receiving information about the change in EPA leadership, while Teixeira had a duty to respond to its questions.

The judge held that the occasion attracted qualified privilege, shifting the burden to Adams to prove that Teixeira acted maliciously.

Although the judge found that Teixeira’s wording was inaccurate and that she could have clarified her remarks more precisely when the committee member questioned the timeline of Adams’ appointment, the court was not satisfied that she knowingly made a false statement or was recklessly indifferent to its truth.

“The inference was weak and her wording overbroad, but those are matters of accuracy and weight,” the judge stated.

The court also rejected the defence of fair comment, finding that the statements were assertions of fact rather than expressions of opinion. However, this did not affect the outcome because qualified privilege was established.

The court ordered that the claim be dismissed and that each party bear its own costs.

Had Adams succeeded, the judge said she would have awarded him $4 million in general damages, but declined to award aggravated or exemplary damages. No specific financial loss or lost professional opportunity had been established.

SHARE THIS ARTICLE :
Facebook
Twitter
WhatsApp
All our printed editions are available online
emblem3
Subscribe to the Guyana Chronicle.
Sign up to receive news and updates.
We respect your privacy.