— paper committal to begin November 16; decision on whether accused will face trial set for December 14
MAGISTARTE Ravindra Mohabir has cleared the way for the murder case against three Transport and Harbours Department (T&HD) employees to proceed, dismissing a defence challenge over the handling of the MV Barima disaster.
He ruled that the ongoing Commission of Inquiry (CoI) into the tragedy does not constitute an abuse of process that would prevent the criminal proceedings from continuing.
The decision clears the way for the paper committal to commence at the Charity Magistrate’s Court on November 16, 2026, at 10:00hrs. The magistrate has scheduled December 14 for his decision on whether the accused should be committed to stand trial or be discharged.
“I say therefore, and this is my ruling, that it is not an abuse of process to have these proceedings conducted in this court,” Magistrate Mohabir declared.
The application was advanced by attorney-at-law Dr Dexter Todd, who represents captain Kevin Price, 40, of Melanie Damishana, East Coast Demerara, and goods superintendent Delon Granderson, 33, of Fellowship, West Coast Demerara.
He contended that the existence of a parallel investigation into the circumstances surrounding the July 18 disaster raised concerns about the propriety of continuing the criminal proceedings.
Dr Todd argued that the legislation governing the investigation of incidents of this nature provided for a specific statutory mechanism, including an inquiry conducted by a board established under the relevant law.
He maintained that the statutory framework contemplated one investigative process or forum at a time, arguing that the matter should either have been constituted as an inquiry before the board provided for under the legislation or dealt with through a CoI established by the president.
On that basis, Todd argued that continuing the murder proceedings before the magistrate while the government-appointed commission investigated the disaster amounted to an abuse of process and warranted a stay of the case.
However, the prosecution opposed the application, maintaining that the Shipping Act did not prevent the Director of Public Prosecutions (DPP) from instituting criminal proceedings against the accused.
Meanwhile, Senior Police Legal Advisor Mandel Moore, who represented the prosecution, argued that the DPP derived constitutional authority to institute criminal charges and that the decision to prosecute the three men was within those powers.
The prosecution further contended that the magistrate was bound by the provisions of the Criminal Law Procedure (Paper Committals) Act under which the proceedings were instituted.
In delivering his ruling, Magistrate Mohabir explained that the issue before him was whether the prosecution had presented sufficient evidence to justify committing the accused to stand trial for murder, rather than determining their guilt or innocence at this stage.
“What this court is concerned with at this time is to determine based on what is presented by the prosecution, whether there is sufficient evidence to permit these accused persons to stand trial for the offence of murder,” he said.
He also made clear that the court would have to discharge the accused if the evidence presented was insufficient to justify committing them to trial.
The magistrate subsequently confirmed that the proceedings would continue, setting November 16 for the commencement of the paper committal.
“So, in the circumstances and based on the ruling, I will move forward and we are going to return on the 16th of November, 2026 for the commencement of the paper committal,” he said.
The court later confirmed that the proceedings would begin at 10:00hrs.
Following the ruling, the court established a timetable for written submissions after the evidence has been presented during the paper committal process.
The defence is expected to submit its arguments on November 23, while the prosecution, through Moore, is scheduled to respond on December 7. Magistrate Mohabir fixed December 14 for his decision on whether the three accused should be committed to stand trial or be discharged.
The magistrate also confirmed that the men would remain in custody, ordering that they be further remanded to prison until the November 16 hearing.
With the magistrate having dismissed the abuse of process argument, the next stage of the criminal case will be the paper committal, during which the court will examine the prosecution’s evidence to determine whether the accused should be sent to the High Court for trial.
Unlike a preliminary inquiry, the paper committal does not involve witnesses giving oral testimony or being cross-examined.
BACKGROUND
Chief mate Rondell Dwayne Roberts, 42, of Grove Public Road, East Bank Demerara, is represented by attorney Everton Singh-Lammy, who did not file an abuse-of-process application.
The three men were jointly charged with murder following legal advice from Director of Public Prosecutions Shalimar Ali-Hack, SC.

The police have alleged that Price, Roberts, and Granderson murdered passengers aboard the 87-year-old ferry when it capsized on July 18, approximately 9.3 nautical miles off Devonshire Castle on the Essequibo Coast.
The MV Barima had departed from the Transport and Harbours Department’s Kingston Goods Wharf in Georgetown around 15:15hrs on its scheduled journey to Port Kaituma, Region One (Barima-Waini).
At approximately 23:01hrs, the vessel transmitted a distress signal after encountering difficulties near the mouth of the Pomeroon River.
There were 179 people aboard the ferry, including 18 crew members. The disaster claimed 73 lives, while 76 people survived. Approximately 30 others remain unaccounted for.
Following the tragedy, Prime Minister Brigadier (Ret’d) Mark Phillips disclosed that two crew members, including the captain, had tested positive for marijuana during medical examinations. He also confirmed that the accused crew members were receiving psychosocial support while in custody, as they too had survived the disaster.
The criminal proceedings are continuing alongside a separate five-member CoI appointed by the government to investigate the circumstances surrounding the sinking.
The DPP has maintained that the commission and criminal proceedings can proceed simultaneously because the two processes serve different legal purposes.
The commission is tasked with examining the events leading to the disaster, regulatory oversight, the emergency response, and measures that could prevent a similar tragedy in the future.







