Happy Never After: Review of A Tall History of Sugar by Curdella Forbes

MOST good love stories are tragic. Indeed, they are often better when one of the lovers dies before reaching the promised “happily ever after”. Or, short of death, some catastrophe intervenes, a misunderstanding, a betrayal, or an accident of fate that separates them forever. Romeo and Juliet remains the archetype. Their love survives precisely because it is denied fulfilment. They never live long enough to become ordinary, never endure the disappointments of divorce, the melancholy of sitting across from one another on a veranda thinking, I could have done better, or the quiet despair of sleeping in separate rooms.

Perhaps one lover loses their memory and forgets the love of their life entirely, with no remedy for the amnesia. Perhaps they become like the couple in Ian McEwan’s On Chesil Beach, incapable of consummating their carefully nurtured love, condemned instead to a lifetime of regret and longing. Whatever form it takes, the obstacle is essential. Love stories thrive on impossibility.

Love, after all, is not a romance novel or a formulaic romantic comedy, where the ending is visible from the first page. In such stories, nothing short of reader fatigue can prevent the inevitable declaration of love, accompanied by tears, embraces and swelling sentiment. Every reader becomes a prophet upon opening a conventional romance; every twist of the narrative road is visible long before it arrives.

What truly makes a love story memorable is loss. Death casts a shadow over the lovers’ hopes and lends their passion gravity. Emily Brontë kills Catherine in Wuthering Heights; Erich Segal kills the beloved Jenny in Love Story; Tolstoy sends Anna Karenina beneath the wheels of a train. Even when death is absent, yearning serves the same purpose. Scott Spencer’s lyrical Endless Love sustains itself on obsession, separation and unattainability. The finest love stories rarely offer satisfaction. Instead, they leave behind hope, longing and an enduring belief in the impossible.

Curdella Forbes’s A Tall History of Sugar belongs to this tradition. Like On Chesil Beach, it is a sensitive and deeply affecting novel about the collision between love and reality. Its central concern is not romance fulfilled but hope frustrated. The novel understands that love often runs counter to circumstance and that the desires of lovers are frequently undone by forces beyond their control. Good love stories do not indulge the romantic fantasies of their protagonists; they subvert them. They reveal hope itself to be a form of blindness, corrected only by experience.

The gulf separating Forbes’s lovers is too wide to bridge. What remains is love, but not its fulfilment. Their affection persists, yet it cannot settle into permanence. One of the novel’s most compelling insights is that there is no perfect moment, no ideal set of circumstances that will resolve the impasse between them. More realistically, there never could be.

The novel’s historical backdrop is equally significant. Its narrative parallels Jamaica’s journey from the colonial era through independence and into the uncertainties of the post-imperial world. Forbes traces the social and political transformations that accompanied what she describes as “the fall of the empire”, connecting them to the anxieties and dislocations of the present. Through the lives of her protagonists, Moshe Fisher and Arrienne Christie, these sweeping historical changes become intimate and personal. Forbes pays careful attention to the markers of each era—the attitudes, aspirations, prejudices and contradictions that define everyday life. The result is a novel with a powerful sense of place. The Jamaica depicted here is vibrant, textured and fully realised.

At its heart, however, A Tall History of Sugar is a love story, one of the better recent examples of the genre, because it understands that love is not always rewarded. Sometimes it is simply experienced. It is, in many ways, a fairy tale without a happy ending. The lovers do not receive their forever after. Instead, they endure separation, disappointment and unforeseen tragedy.

The relationship between Moshe Fisher and Arrienne Christie unfolds over more than fifty years. They first meet as children in a rural Jamaican village. Moshe, an albino orphan found abandoned in a basket near a river and raised by an adoptive mother, occupies the margins of village life. Arrienne, by contrast, comes from a prosperous Jamaican family. From childhood, she became his protector, shielding him from ridicule, insults and physical abuse. Their bond is immediate and enduring.

Their story is, as the title suggests, “tall” in every sense. It spans decades of personal and political upheaval, tracing a stubborn, resilient love that survives despite overwhelming obstacles. The question that animates the novel is not whether they love one another—they clearly do—but whether circumstances will ever allow that love to flourish.

What makes the novel particularly engaging is the emotional investment it generates in its characters. Moshe and Arrienne are rendered with remarkable sympathy and complexity, and the reader becomes deeply invested in their fate. The narrative gains additional suspense from the possibility of a reunion after a separation spanning decades.

Forbes writes in lyrical prose distinguished by its careful attention to Jamaican patois and the rhythms of local speech. The dialogue captures the music, cadence and texture of everyday language without sacrificing accessibility. Her descriptions of the island are vivid and evocative, and her characters possess the kind of authenticity that makes them linger in the mind long after the novel has ended.

A Tall History of Sugar succeeds because it understands a fundamental truth about love stories: fulfilment is often less interesting than longing. The novel leaves its readers with neither certainty nor satisfaction, but with something rarer: a sense of love’s endurance in the face of time, history and impossibility.

SHARE THIS ARTICLE :
Facebook
Twitter
WhatsApp
All our printed editions are available online
emblem3
Subscribe to the Guyana Chronicle.
Sign up to receive news and updates.
We respect your privacy.