Full Court overturns decision to strike out AG’s claim against CLICO Investment Bank
Justice Nigel Niles
Justice Nigel Niles

–remits case for full hearing

THE Full Court of the Supreme Court of Judicature has allowed an appeal by the Attorney General of Guyana and CLICO Life and General Insurance Company (South America) Ltd., overturning a High Court ruling that had struck out their claim against Clico Investment Bank Ltd. (CIB).

Both companies are presently in liquidation proceedings. In a decision delivered on April 8, 2026, by acting Chief Justice Navindra Singh and Justice Nigel Niles, the court found that the trial judge erred in concluding that the claim was barred by res judicata.

The original claim, filed in July 2024, had been struck out in September 2025 after the court accepted arguments that the issues had already been determined in earlier proceedings.

However, the Full Court disagreed, ruling that the current case was “differently premised” from the earlier matter.

The court noted that a previous case in 2009 focused on whether payments due under debentures were redirected to CLICO Life, a claim that ultimately failed.

In contrast, the present proceedings raise broader allegations concerning the relationship between CIB, CLICO Life, and their parent company, CL Financial.

Acting Chief Justice Navindra Singh

According to the ruling, the appellants are seeking to establish that the entities operated under common control and that funds were improperly transferred within the group.

They are asking the court to examine whether there was “improper diversion/transfer of funds,” and whether equitable remedies such as constructive trust, tracing, and restitution should apply.

The Full Court also addressed concerns raised by the trial judge regarding the lack of specific details in the pleadings, including allegations of conspiracy, breach of trust, and fraud. It held that in cases involving complex corporate arrangements, such details are often not fully available at the initial stage.

“As would be expected where a clandestine scheme between companies… is being alleged, the pleadings will most likely set out the general conduct of the companies involved,” the court stated, noting that fuller particulars could emerge during the discovery phase.

Importantly, the judges emphasised that courts should be cautious in striking out claims of this nature before the evidentiary process is complete.

They ruled that such an application “should not have been entertained… until after discovery was complete and witness statements filed.”

The Full Court further referenced a recent ruling by the Caribbean Court of Justice, underscoring that while courts are reluctant to pierce the corporate veil solely on the basis of shared control, they may intervene where corporate structures are used to facilitate improper diversion of assets.

In allowing the appeal, the Full Court ordered that the matter be remitted to the Chief Justice for assignment to a new trial judge. Costs were ordered to be in the cause.

The ruling effectively revives the claim and clears the way for a full hearing into the allegations surrounding the financial dealings within the CL Financial group.

Attorneys C. V. Satram and Ron Motilall appeared for the appellants — the Attorney General of Guyana and CLICO Life and General Insurance Company (South America) Ltd.

Senior Counsel Robin Stoby and attorney Michael Jagnanan represented the respondent, Clico Investment Bank Ltd.

SHARE THIS ARTICLE :
Facebook
Twitter
WhatsApp
All our printed editions are available online
emblem3
Subscribe to the Guyana Chronicle.
Sign up to receive news and updates.
We respect your privacy.