Chief Justice dismisses Mohameds substantive challenge to extradition law
Nazar and Azruddin Mohamed pictured with their attorneys, Siand Dhurjon and Damien DaSilva at the Georgetown Magistrates’ Courts (Delano Williams photo)
Nazar and Azruddin Mohamed pictured with their attorneys, Siand Dhurjon and Damien DaSilva at the Georgetown Magistrates’ Courts (Delano Williams photo)

–Attorney-General says court decision removes major barrier to the matter

THE High Court on Tuesday dismissed the bulk of a constitutional challenge filed by businessmen Azruddin Mohamed and his father, Nazar Mohamed, a ruling that Attorney-General Anil Nandlall, SC, says effectively reopens the way for extradition proceedings against the pair to continue.
Speaking outside of the court after the decision, Nandlall explained that Acting Chief Justice Navindra Singh delivered a 26-page judgment addressing claims by the Mohameds that several sections of Guyana’s Fugitive Offenders (Amendment) Act were unconstitutional.
According to Nandlall, the court rejected almost all of the arguments raised by the father-and-son duo, and upheld the legality of the extradition framework.
“The Chief Justice essentially dismissed the claim and ruled that almost all the sections that they challenged were consistent with the Constitution of Guyana and therefore did not violate the Constitution,” Nandlall said.
He noted that only one minor subsection of the Act was struck down, but stressed that the ruling has no practical effect on the extradition process.
“That minor subsection has no impact whatsoever on extradition proceedings,” the Attorney-General explained. He said the provision related to implied protection against extradition to a third country, an issue already settled by previous court rulings.
Those earlier decisions, Nandlall pointed out, confirmed that extradited persons are protected from being sent onward to another jurisdiction without proper authorisation from Guyana’s authorities.
He further disclosed that the United States had already given a formal undertaking that if the Mohameds are extradited, they will not be transferred to a third country.
“So, by and large, the ruling has cleared the way again for the extradition process to continue,” he stated.
The Attorney-General also highlighted that this constitutional challenge was filed well after proceedings had already begun in the Magistrate’s Court.
He contrasted the pace at which the High Court matter was resolved with what he described as prolonged delays in the lower court.
Despite extensive pleadings, multiple lawyers, and lengthy submissions, Nandlall said the constitutional case was concluded with reasonable speed. However, he criticised what he called deliberate tactics to stall the extradition hearing in the Magistrate’s Court.
“You’re hearing fabricated medical explanations proffered,” he alleged. “You’re hearing explanations that one person was admitted to the hospital when, in fact, the hospital records were checked, the person was never admitted.”
He also referred to claims about tyres being slashed and vehicles being broken into, describing them as “hair-raising tales” intended to slow the process.
“All these are deliberate, concocted stories to dilate and delay the matter,” Nandlall said.
The Attorney-General further criticised the scope of questioning being allowed during proceedings in the Magistrate’s Courts before Principal Magistrate Judy Latchman.
He argued that much of the cross-examination is irrelevant in extradition cases, which are largely determined by documentary evidence submitted by the requesting State.
He explained that the bundle of documents used in extradition proceedings originates in the United States and contains indictments, charges and supporting evidence prepared by foreign authorities.
“No permanent secretary in Guyana has knowledge or ought to have knowledge of that bundle,” he said. “It was not prepared in Guyana. It consists of the charge, the indictment, and the evidence, all of which took place in the United States.”
Nandlall said witnesses are being asked questions they cannot reasonably answer, under the guise of cross-examination, and that this runs contrary to the purpose of extradition hearings.
He compared the Mohameds’ case with another recent extradition matter involving Ronley Floyd Bynoe, which, he said, followed the same legal process but concluded without controversy.
In that matter, he explained, documents were transmitted through the proper channels from the United States to Guyana’s Ministry of Foreign Affairs, and then to the Ministry of Home Affairs. The accused was arrested, brought before the court, and remanded.
“This is how extraditions are done,” Nandlall said. “That entire process is going to be concluded in a matter of days.”
He noted that Bynoe was charged with what he described as a comparatively minor offence, yet was remanded and has reportedly signalled his intention to surrender to US authorities.
In contrast, he said the Mohameds are facing serious allegations involving international financial crimes and money laundering.
Despite this, Nandlall said the Mohameds’ case has attracted claims of political vendetta, persecution and international conspiracy, which he dismissed as attempts to undermine the legal process.
“They feel that they are special and therefore they must not be subject to any extradition process,” he said.
When asked whether the High Court ruling represented a victory for either side, Nandlall responded that the matter was not about winning or losing.
“It’s about the Rule of Law and the extradition process,” he said. “What the judge has essentially done is clear the way once again for the extradition process to continue.”
He added that Guyana has abolished oral committal hearings and now relies on paper committals, meaning proceedings should be guided strictly by the documents received from the requesting state.
Nandlall warned that unnecessary and irrelevant questioning risks bringing the administration of justice into disrepute, especially in the eyes of the public.
“People are watching. They may not understand all the legal technicalities, but they know when questions ought not to be asked and cannot be answered,” he said.
He concluded by stating that the Mohameds’ case has drawn unusual public attention compared to most extradition matters, which he said are normally handled quietly and efficiently.
“99.9% of extraditions are done that way, not only in Guyana but worldwide,” Nandlall said. “All of this noise about persecution and vendetta is simply to defeat the legal process — and unfortunately, it seems to be gaining ground.”
On the morning of October 31, 2025, both father and son were taken into custody in Georgetown in connection with the extradition request from the United States of America.
The Mohameds—owners of Mohamed’s Enterprise—remain on $150,000 bail each as the matter progresses. The next hearing is scheduled for February 26, 2026 before Principal Magistrate Judy Latchman.
Conditions of their bail required them to surrender their passports and report weekly to the Ruimveldt Police Station, measures intended to ensure their availability for ongoing legal proceedings.
The father and son have been hit with an 11-count indictment in the United States District Court for the Southern District of Florida. The pair face 10 counts jointly, while Azruddin is charged with an additional count related to the importation of a 2020 Lamborghini Roadster SVJ into Guyana.
Court documents alleged that Azruddin and his father conspired to commit wire fraud, mail fraud, money laundering, conspiracy, aiding and abetting and customs-related violations connected to an alleged US$50 million gold export and tax evasion scheme.
The indictment was issued by a grand jury in October 2025.
According to the filings, Nazar owns 90 per cent of Mohamed’s Enterprise, with Azruddin holding the remaining 10 per cent. The two face a maximum sentence of 20 years in prison for the most serious charge.
In June 2024, Nazar and Azruddin Mohamed, along with their business entities, were placed under sanctions by the United States Treasury’s Office of Foreign Assets Control (OFAC) over allegations of gold smuggling and large-scale corruption, including claims that more than US$50 million in taxes owed to the Guyanese state were evaded.
U.S. authorities are believed to have launched their investigation into the Mohameds in the mid-2010s, supported by intelligence sharing and law enforcement co-operation between Guyana and the United States that dates back to around 2016–2017.
The probe involved several U.S. agencies, including the Drug Enforcement Administration (DEA), the Federal Bureau of Investigation (FBI), and the Department of Homeland Security (DHS).

 

SHARE THIS ARTICLE :
Facebook
Twitter
WhatsApp
All our printed editions are available online
emblem3
Subscribe to the Guyana Chronicle.
Sign up to receive news and updates.
We respect your privacy.