Guyana’s inexplicabilities: Banks DIH versus Beharry company

LET me say upfront I have no interest in any dispute between super-rich companies in and outside of Guyana. I do not see my role as taking sides in such disputes because my interest is to protect the class I belong to.

I am a UG pensioner. I told Joel Bhagwandin on the Freddie Kissoon Show last Friday evening that after 26 years as a lecturer, my pension was $52, 000 yearly. I think it still is. I have absolutely no job or property in Guyana except my home.

My purpose in life in this country then was to safeguard the well-being of the social class I come from. I would put my economic standing in Guyana as upper working class or lower middle class although I fit more into the former than the latter. So, I am not interested in the fight among rich giants in the corporate world.

Secondly, I do not know any person in the management of Bank DIH or any member of the Board of Directors. Only twice in my life did I say hello to Banks DIH’s head, Mr. Clifford Reis. Once it was on the second level of the New Thriving Restaurant and years after, it was outside Massy Supermarket.

I have never seen in the flesh any member of the Beharry aristocracy. I would not know what they look like. Therefore, it is none of my business to comment on the rights and wrongs in a business dispute between Banks DIH and the Beharry company. My role as an opinion-maker is to ensure that wrongs are righted and thus my pen will have to enter any fray once justice, equality and fairness are tossed aside by any government, any political party, any business company, any organisation, any individual.

The current legal dispute between Banks DIH and the Beharry Group of Companies should catch the eyes of every citizen because some parts in the decision of Justice Sandil Kissoon appear strange. Two aspects of the legal matter have been made public. Both dimensions are associated with Banks DIH, so one has to be careful in just openly accepting what Banks DIH says.

Banks DIH’s CEO, Mr. Clifford Reece told the annual shareholders’ meeting last week that Beharry Stockbroker Limited that filed the writ against Banks DIH in relation to the 15 per cent limit of the amount of shares for a shareholder and the 15 per cent restriction on voting power by any shareholder is not a Banks DIH shareholder. I am not a lawyer, but I believe a large amount of persons in Guyana knows about the legal term – locus standi.

After 57 years in politics and 37 years in the media, I know what locus standi is. It means that you have to have some connection with a matter that you want the court to pronounce on. I cannot file a writ in court compelling the Bank of Berbice to forward a yearly Christmas calendar to its customers if I am not a customer. I do not have locus standi. I can only ask the courts to intervene with my bank where I am a depositor.

I write about this so I can get information on the subject assuming that Banks DIH is telling the truth. If Banks DIH is correct, then how does the court define locus standi? Secondly, Bank DIH said that Justice Kissoon arrived at his decision in favour of Beharry because he quoted from the Article of Association in the constitution of Banks DIH.  But Banks DIH is saying there is no Article of Associations in the company’s constitution. Again, if Banks DIH is telling the truth, then the ordinary person is forced to ask, where did the judge get that part of the company’s constitution from?

Finally, in the almost four decades as a public-opinion maker, I have never accepted an injunction from the courts without the other side being given a hearing. This is a pregnant situation with a gargantuan miscarriage of justice. The court then makes decisions hearing one side only. There are literally millions of examples that can be cited to demonstrate how ignorant this process is.

The court grants an injunction barring a house owner from preventing his neighbour’s cement ransom from parking on the parapet. But the house owner should be given the right to an explanation. Suppose the ransom on the parapet is jutting onto the entrance of the house owner’s yard so his car will touch the ransom when he drives in? The fair way to go is to give both parties a hearing.

DISCLAIMER: The views and opinions expressed in this column are solely those of the author and do not necessarily reflect the official policy or position of the Guyana National Newspapers Limited.

SHARE THIS ARTICLE :
Facebook
Twitter
WhatsApp
All our printed editions are available online
emblem3
Subscribe to the Guyana Chronicle.
Sign up to receive news and updates.
We respect your privacy.