The Attorney-General confronts autocratic journalism

IN my piece yesterday (Wednesday) I offered part one of my analysis of a letter the AG had published in Sunday’s Stabroek News (SN) in which the AG pontificated on the politicised journalism of SN.
Part one looked at the editorial note attached to the AG’s letter. Today I am going to look at the contents of the AG’s submission and delve in the autocratic journalism contained in SN’s editorial attachment.
The AG questioned the convenient way in which SN treated his difference with High Court judge, Justice, Gino Persaud. I quote the AG: “I am aware of two commentators who recently wrote letters for publication in the Letters Column of Stabroek News, critical of Justice Gino Persaud’s pronouncements.

“These letters were never published by Stabroek News. Yet, I have seen at least one letter published by Stabroek News in support of Justice Persaud. I have issued a public statement comprising of over 1,200 words trying to explain for the reading public the legal issues that were before the Court. I am again unsurprised that in its elongated Editorial, the Editor generously quotes from the Judge but mentions not a word of my response.”
Now here is SN’s direct response to the AG’s accusation. I ask readers to note both the banal and the dangerous which I will expand on after the quote: “As it relates to letters about the decision by Justice Persaud that were not published, as Leader of the Bar, the Attorney General would be aware that attempts to scandalize or bring the court into disrepute will not be tolerated.”
But readers, and the Guyanese people by extension, do not know what “attempts to scandalize means.”

It is easy to shut out the views of someone by interpreting their points as scandalous. And in my long experience in journalism, I know that the role of the editor is to delete unsavoury words and substitute more palatable ones but never to shut out people’s views.
I did a stint both as the letters editor of Kaieteur News (KN) and the Catholic Standard so I know what functions an editor performs, one of which is never to shut out views the editor does not agree with. You have to take time and remove libellous and unpleasant adjectives, one reason being that a letter-writer is not trained, editors are, so their function is to sanitise what is submitted to them.

It is clear from the AG’s letter that SN established a preference for the judge’s remarks against the AG and comes up with the banal and the dangerous. The banal meaning that you close the case by saying the comments on the person was scandalous. The dangerous is seen in the direction of autocratic journalism in which a media house decides how people must express themselves. In this case, the SN has a definitive position on the use and meaning of words.
Here now is a pyrotechnical example of autocratic journalism, I return once more to the banal and the dangerous. I quote SN once more: “Mr Randy Persaud was told by this newspaper that ad hominen attacks on civil society organisations would not be tolerated.” This is the second time SN uses the words, “would/will not be tolerated.”

The banal is that it is a jejune excuse for not allowing criticism of persons and organisations that SN feels should not be put under the search light. The dangerous element is that autocratic journalism has now embraced censorship. It is an accusation I have long used against both KN and SN. But wait there is more examples of autocratic journalism to come.

First let’s quote the AG once more; “Stabroek News runs a blog online which preponderates with commentaries critical of the PPP/C and the PPP/C Administration. This blog publishes the most toxic and unwarranted criticisms of our Government and its officials by anonymous bloggers. I know of dozens of persons who made innumerable attempts to get their views published on this blog in response to this daily tirade of baseless and malicious attacks but were never able to get past the Editor’s guillotine.”
Here for the third time is an example of the banal and dangerous. I quote SN’s response to the AG’s accusation: “The reported difficulties in posting comments to the Stabroek News website could only mean that the prospective commenters have run afoul of the rules governing commenting.”

The banal is the perennial, stupid excuse for rejecting comments the editor is not politically pleased with. The dangerous thing is that the public does not know about these rules by the newspaper. I close by asking the Government of Guyana, do they have a set of rules where the media’s scandalisation of an elected government should not be tolerated. I hope so.

DISCLAIMER: The views and opinions expressed in this column are solely those of the author and do not necessarily reflect the official policy or position of the Guyana National Newspapers Limited.

SHARE THIS ARTICLE :
Facebook
Twitter
WhatsApp
All our printed editions are available online
emblem3
Subscribe to the Guyana Chronicle.
Sign up to receive news and updates.
We respect your privacy.