Understanding measurements of development in Economics

Dear Editor,
THE Human Development Index is a good measurement for development, and I commend DeLisle Worrell for explaining its components.
What is HDI and what is Guyana’s HDI? How does the country measure up against some other CARICOM nations?

In examining HDI, one must not ignore Gross Domestic Product (GDP) per capita (person) or annual GDP or GNP [Gross National Product] growth. HDI measures economic progress by combining growth, education, and health indicators.

The missive suggests that the writer actually studied and understood development economics as opposed to others who purport to be economists but never took an economics course.
The writer is spot on in stating that HDI is increasingly used to measure development post-1990, when the concept was created. HDI has not replaced or supplanted other socioeconomic indicators, but merely supplemented them. And it may not be a perfect measurement of development, but it is a good one.

HDI is a relatively new concept in measuring human development. After 1990, students of economics have been introduced to this new concept of measurement of human development which gives a ranking between zero and one.

The higher the number generated, after considering a number of features of an economy, the greater is the development and standard of living of the territory.
The social welfare states of Europe and the G7 [Group of Seven] nations, as well as Australia, New Zealand, and Singapore (developed economies), have the highest HDI. Guyana is listed as a middle-range HDI country.

Guyana’s HDI in 1990 was 0.548. As reported recently, between 1990 and 2019, Guyana’s HDI value increased from 0.548 to 0.682, a significant improvement. It should be noted that it happened under democratic governance.

The HDI value in 2020 slightly went down to 0.645 under questionable governance. Guyana is average compared to other CARICOM nations, edging out Belize and Suriname. This country is listed in a cluster of Caribbean and Latin American nations. African nations are at the bottom of HDI.

Those of us who studied economics pre-1990 learn about GDP and GNP per capita and other indicators of an economy like life expectancy, years of education, per cent of budget devoted to healthcare, income of top 10 per cent of the nation, income of bottom 20 per cent, etc.

Those measures were used to measure human development and economic progress of a territory. Per capita measurement, and other socio economic indicators, does not give an accurate picture of standard of living and quality of life, however, they provide economists and policymakers with a general understanding of the life of society.

The general trends are used to guide policy. HDI captures several indicators like GDP, healthcare, and education, as Worrel explained. Although not perfect, it is a better measurement than GDP or GNP per capita in terms of human development and standard of living.

The other indicators are still used to understand national development and economic progress of a nation, giving an indication of how much resources are directed towards people, the poor in particular.
The GINI coefficient also gives a good measurement of standard of living and economic means of a territory’s population — measurements on poverty and variation or disparities in income.

The GINI index serves as a gauge of economic inequality in a territory, measuring income or wealth distribution among a population of a territory. The lower the GINI, the less inequality in a society.
The social welfare nations of Europe and the G7 outperforms most nations. Guyana had a GINI index of .542 in 1990 that declined to about 0.451 from 1998 onwards. Guyana’s GINI index is average in terms of CARICOM nations, and is midway in terms of the 190 territories for which data is available.

Yours truly,
Vishnu Bisram

SHARE THIS ARTICLE :
Facebook
Twitter
WhatsApp
All our printed editions are available online
emblem3
Subscribe to the Guyana Chronicle.
Sign up to receive news and updates.
We respect your privacy.