-court says tenancy was validly terminated
JUSTICE Nareshwar Harnanan has ruled that the government does not owe the Linden Holdings Inc. $120M for the rental of the controversial Sussex Street pharmaceutical bond. The building which is owned by businessman Larry Singh was rented to the Ministry of Health in 2016 under the then APNU+AFC government.
On October 31, 2016, the ministry wrote to the company about terminating the tenancy and notified officials that it was giving up possession of the bond on November 1, 2017. Again, on October 3, 2017, the ministry wrote to the company reminding it of the intended termination of the tenancy. However, the company through its attorney notified the ministry that it did not receive the notice of termination and did not recognise the ministry as being lawfully entitled to give up possession of the premises.
The company also claimed that rent was payable for the unexpired term of the tenancy. The ministry did not actually leave the premises until August 2018, following which the company claimed $120M as the total rent payable for the full term of the tenancy up to June 30, 2019, or 10 months at $12.6M per month.
The company, through its Attorneys-at-law Glen Hanoman and Joshua Abdool, then took the Attorney-General and the Central Board of Health to court for the payment of the outstanding monies. The Attorney-General and Central Board of Health were represented by Attorney-at-law Andrew Pollard, SC and Solicitor-General Nigel Hawke. Justice Harnanan, after reviewing the submissions made in the case, granted judgement in favour of the State and dismissed the claim from the company after finding that the termination notice had been properly given, and that the tenancy had been validly terminated.
Against this backdrop, the court found that it had no jurisdiction to hear the claim as at all material times, the ministry had been a statutory tenant. According to the judge, the claim should have been filed in the Magistrates’ Court where, by law, such claims must be decided. In 2016, after the coalition government terminated the arrangement under which New Guyana Pharmaceutical Corporation (New GPC) had provided storage free of cost for more than a decade, the company submitted an invoice for the continued use of its facility. New GPC submitted an invoice for the rental of its facilities at a cost of $237 per square feet but Government instead opted to pay Linden Holding Inc $1,250 per square feet which was five times as much. Moreover, a $25 million deposit was paid to Linden Holding Inc, in order to rent the bond in question to store pharmaceuticals. This generated widespread public criticism. Subsequently on June 11, 2019, a $539 million Central Supplies Unit (CSU) which is also known as the Kingston bond, was commissioned.







