CCJ rules in favour of miner

–says GGMC had no right to serve him cease order

THE Guyana Geology and Mines Commission (GGMC) had no authority to order Wayne Vieira in November 2010 to cease all work at his Chinese Landing operation in spite of having a mining permit to do so.

This is according to a ruling issued last Thursday by the Caribbean Court of Justice (CCJ), which overturned a decision made by the Court of Appeal here.
According to the ruling, which was seen by this newspaper, the CCJ’s decision rests on the fact that Vieira had no agreement with the Chinese Landing-Tassawini Village Council in Region One at the time the Cease Work Order (CWO) was issued.
As such, what the CCJ’s ruling has done is to effectively restore the High Court’s decision and awarding Vieira costs to this effect.

According to the facts presented before the court, a GGMC mines officer issued the order, dated November 26, 2010, to Vieira under Regulation 98 of the Mining Act.
Vieira testified that the day before he was issued the CWO, the then Prime Minister, with whom he had previously engaged, called him by telephone and told him to pay to the Village Council a tribute of 10%.
Vieira said that after finding that the Prime Minister was reneging on an agreement in writing that he and other miners like himself they should only pay 7%, he objected to the new directive.

Vieira said he told the Prime Minister that he’d already gone to the Village Council to make payment at the agreed rate, but that neither they nor the Ministry of Amerindian Affairs would accept it from him. He said it was the day after that conversation that he was served with the CWO.

The Commission, however, had a different take on the matter, in that they are saying that it would have been pointless giving the miner a hearing, as, having spent over two years trying to get an agreement with the Village Council and having had two meetings with the Prime Minister and meetings with other officials, he should have seen the decision coming.
The CCJ noted in its judgment that when the CWO was issued on November 26, 2010, it was done under the Mining Regulations because of the absence of an agreement with the Village Council, as was required under Amerindian law.

It was noted also that Vieira had made several attempts to secure a new agreement with the Village Council, but his efforts had proven futile.

In the High Court, Vieira had successfully challenged the decision on the issuance of the CWO and won. Judgment was duly passed by Justice Diana Insanally, who determined that the order could only be issued in relation to breaches concerning the Mining Act and not the Amerindian law.

The GGMC responded by taking the matter to the Court of Appeal, and won. It was at this point that Vieira took the matter to the CCJ.

SHARE THIS ARTICLE :
Facebook
Twitter
WhatsApp
All our printed editions are available online
emblem3
Subscribe to the Guyana Chronicle.
Sign up to receive news and updates.
We respect your privacy.